Which places offer Key Lime Pie delivery in West Babylon?

There are a number of Key Lime Pie delivery spots in West Babylon. Whether you’re in 11757, or elsewhere, enter your address to start browsing the places that offer delivery to your location.

From where can I order the best Key Lime Pie delivery in West Babylon?

As you seek out the best Key Lime Pie delivery in West Babylon, you might want to first try the places that have earned a high star rating from users.

Are there different kinds of Key Lime Pie available for delivery in West Babylon?

There are a number of menu items for Key Lime Pie delivery or that come with Key Lime Pie in West Babylon, including the Bang Key Lime Pie 16oz from 7-Eleven. Compare your options then order some tasty Key Lime Pie delivery online.

What’s the cheapest place for Key Lime Pie delivery in West Babylon?

Budget-friendly Key Lime Pie delivery options can be found at 7-Eleven.

How much is Key Lime Pie delivery in West Babylon?

Menu options for Key Lime Pie delivery or that come with it are priced around $2.99 on average. This number does not include any additional fees for a delivery order.

What’s open now for Key Lime Pie delivery near me in West Babylon?

You can order Key Lime Pie takeout 24 hours a day in West Babylon. Be sure to enter your address to find out which places deliver to your address.

How much should I tip for my Key Lime Pie delivery order?

You can add a tip as an extra way to thank your delivery person for their efforts. How much you tip is up to you, and 100% of it goes to the delivery person.

Does Uber Eats offer free Key Lime Pie delivery?

If you’re looking to save money on Key Lime Pie delivery, consider subscribing to Eats Pass. One of the benefits of this subscription offer is $0 Delivery Fee. Subject to terms, fees and availability. Learn about Eats Pass here .

Can I pick up my Key Lime Pie order in West Babylon?

Some places in West Babylon offer pickup, like 7-Eleven.

Key Lime Pie Delivery in West Babylon - Order Key Lime Pie Near Me Online

Kiana Wine and Liquor

10–25 min

4.7

Josh Cellars Sauvignon Blanc (750ml bottle)

$19.86

Sweet Surrender Bake House (Wantagh Avenue)

45–60 min

• $

4.9

Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace North Babylon

Offers available

Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace North Babylon

25–45 min

4.7

Yoplait Whips! Key Lime Pie Lowfat Yogurt Mousse

$1.08

Buttercooky Bakery (495 New York Ave)

55–70 min

• $

4.6

Key Lime Pie

$28.95

Made by Lilis

15–30 min

4.8

The Dirty Cheesecake (1160 Deer Park Avenue)

15–30 min

4.6

Zio’s Casa Di Dolce

45–60 min

New

Dortoni Bakery & Cafe

40–55 min

4.9

Americano Pie Bar

30–50 min

• $

4.7

Dortoni Bakery & Cafe e (Huntington)

50–65 min

New

Key Lime Pie

$23.95

Krispy Mango Cafe & Bakeshop

2 Offers Available

Krispy Mango Cafe & Bakeshop

50–65 min

4.7

Scoops And Cones Cafe - Farmingdale

30–45 min

New

Nanitos Deli

30–50 min

• $

4.7

NY Cupcakery

60–75 min

• $

4.5

Waffle Magic

10–25 min

4.6

Cafe Gio

20–35 min

4.5

Cheese Pie (18")

$21.54

Sweet Spot Cafe

45–65 min

4.9

Sweet Sensations

15–30 min

• $

4.4

D & D Bakery

25–40 min

• $$

New

The International Delight Cafe

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

The International Delight Cafe

55–70 min

4.8

Sweet Karma Desserts (136 Manetto Hill Rd)

60–75 min

• $

4.6

Mary Carroll’s

2 Offers Available

Mary Carroll’s

15–30 min

• $$

4.7

Lindenhurst Diner

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Lindenhurst Diner

20–35 min

• $$

4.7

Belfast Gastro Pub

20–35 min

4.5

Food Bazaar (101 Wicks Rd)

Offers available

Food Bazaar (101 Wicks Rd)

50–70 min

4.7

Yoplait Original Calcium Low Fat Key Lime Pie Yogurt

$1.43

Chili's Grill & Bar (2020 Sunrise Hwy)

25–40 min

• $$

4.3

Brooklyn Fish & Chicken

25–40 min

4.4

Legs

$2.29

Hauppauge Palace Diner

50–65 min

• $$

4.6

Hershey’s Ice Cream

20–35 min

• $

4.8

Colony Diner

50–65 min

• $$

4.6

Houlihan's (Farmingdale)

35–50 min

• $$

4.4

Friendly's (50 Montauk Highway)

35–50 min

• $

4.5

Reese's® Pieces® Sundae

$9.19

East Bay Diner

40–55 min

4.6

Scoops & Cones Cafe

55–70 min

New

Dortoni Bakery-Levittown

55–70 min

4.5

Bread In Oven

45–60 min

4.9

Pierogibites & More

45–60 min

4.6

PIEROGI 8pc

$18.75

Nautilus Diner

35–50 min

4.5

Lighthouse Diner

35–50 min

• $

4.6

Dix Hills Diner

35–50 min

• $$

4.8

Yo Go Wild Creperie

2 Offers Available

Yo Go Wild Creperie

25–40 min

• $

4.5

Sunrise Diner

40–55 min

• $$

4.8

Greekrave

15–30 min

• $

4.7

SPINACH PIE

$7.95

Massapequa Diner

35–50 min

• $

4.7

The Penny Pub

30–45 min

• $

4.5

Sgambati's

60–75 min

New

Embassy Diner

30–45 min

4.6

Pietro's Pizzeria

30–50 min

4.5

Large Pie

$22.95

T Swirl Crepe

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

T Swirl Crepe

55–70 min

4.8

Richie's Pizza

35–50 min

• $

4.6

Regular Pie

$24.95

Candlelight Diner Restaurant

45–60 min

• $

4.7

The Ice Cream Chick

50–65 min

• $

4.6

Doctor Cuisine

30–50 min

4.6

Apollo Diner

55–70 min

• $

4.8

Red Lobster (1700 The Arches Circle)

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Red Lobster (1700 The Arches Circle)

35–50 min

• $$

4.5

New! Key Lime Pie

$11.99

Rustic Root

2 Offers Available

Rustic Root

55–70 min

• $

4.5

Golden Globe Diner

55–70 min

• $$

4.6

ASSORTED PIES

$7.95

Mulberry St

40–60 min

• $

4.8

Neopolitan Pie (Regular)

$25.22

Pigs On A Wing

15–35 min

4.7

Zest

2 Offers Available

Zest

35–50 min

4.7

Fogo de Chão (Huntington Station)

55–70 min

• $$

4.3

Key Lime Pie

$13.45

Pecosa Bakery

Spend $20, Save $5

Pecosa Bakery

65–80 min

• $$

4.7

Gino's Pizza of West Babylon

15–30 min

• $

4.7

18" Regular Pie

$27.24

Yo Go Wild Cafe

Spend $30, Save $6

Yo Go Wild Cafe

25–40 min

• $

4.7

Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

25–40 min

4.8

Regular Pie Pizza 16''

$24.30

Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille - Bay Shore

25–40 min

4.5

Farmingdale Diner (Ordermark)

30–50 min

• $

4.8

The Pizzeria of Islip

30–45 min

4.8

Large Pie

$24.09

Chip City (Woodbury Commons)

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Chip City (Woodbury Commons)

55–70 min

• $

4.8

Cookie Face Keychain

Celebrity Diner

50–65 min

• $

4.5

Doughology Donuts - Babylon

15–30 min

• $

4.8

Marcony Pizza

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Marcony Pizza

25–40 min

4.7

Cheese Pie

$13.95

Dominick's Pizza & Pasta

40–60 min

• $

4.6

18" Large Cheese Pie

$17.50

Big Belly Que

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Big Belly Que

55–70 min

• $

4.8

Crown Chicken & Grill - Hicksville

Spend $20, Save $5

Crown Chicken & Grill - Hicksville

55–70 min

• $

4.6

3 Piece Chicken

$7.49

Angiana’s Ice Cream

20–35 min

• $

4.1

The Pit Stop

55–70 min

4.8

Target (Bay Shore)

Save on Select Items

Target (Bay Shore)

30–50 min

• $$

4.8

Edwards Key Lime Pie (2 ct)

$4.58

Peter's Diner

25–40 min

• $

4.7

Thin Cookies

2 Offers Available

Thin Cookies

55–70 min

4.9

KFC - Deer Park

15–30 min

• $$

4.5

Apple Pie Poppers

$2.99

Lia's Pizzeria

50–65 min

4.8

Personal Cheese Pie

$14.40

Village Idiot Irish Pub - Oakdale

45–60 min

4.7

Francesco’s Bakery

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Francesco’s Bakery

50–65 min

New

Vinnies Mulberry Street Pizzeria

35–50 min

• $

4.7

Regular Pie

$28.00

Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar

25–40 min

• $$

4.6

Key Lime Pie

$13.00

Krispy Rice (546 - Central Islip, NY)

Spend $15, Save $3

Krispy Rice (546 - Central Islip, NY)

45–60 min

• $$

3.2

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

25–40 min

• $

4.8

Grape Leaves Piece

$1.00

Umberto's of Massapequa Park

55–70 min

• $

4.7

Neapolitan Classic Pie

$21.85

Angela's Pizza

25–40 min

4.8

Pie

$18.00

Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar

30–45 min

New

Key Lime Pie

$8.00

IHOP (Montauk Highway)

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

IHOP (Montauk Highway)

20–35 min

• $

4.5

Portofino Pizza Huntington Village

60–75 min

• $$

4.7

18" Neopolitan Pie

$18.75

Cafe Dolce Vita - Deer Park

30–45 min

New

Regular Pie

$23.00

Cachapas- Long Island

60–75 min

• $

4.8

Fresh Lime and Sugar Cane (Papelon)

$4.95

Ideal Food Basket (Farmingdale)

Offers available

Ideal Food Basket (Farmingdale)

30–50 min

• $$

4.8

Ben's Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant & Caterers

65–80 min

4.8

Mamma Santina Pizza

30–50 min

4.9

2 Piece Jumbo Meatballs

$11.80

Cookoo Rico

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Cookoo Rico

65–80 min

4.8

Village BBQ

70–85 min

4.5

Emilio's Pizzeria & Ristorante

55–70 min

• $$

4.6

Regular Pie

$24.95

Krinti Mediterranean Grill

55–70 min

• $$

4.7

Spinach Pie

$10.95

Restaurant Depot (1966 Broadhollow Rd,)

40–60 min

• $$

New

Frozen Chef's Quality - Key Lime Pie - 12 slices (4 Units per Case)

$100.46

Mary's Pizza and Pasta (Farmingdale)

30–45 min

4.9

Large Cheese Pie

$25.00

Amore Pizza

65–80 min

4.7

Cheese Pie (Small)

$20.85

La Slice Pizzeria

30–50 min

• $

4.7

Regular Pie

$19.80

BAR GRAZIE

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

BAR GRAZIE

40–55 min

• $

New

Crown Fried Chicken (Wyandanch)

15–30 min

4.5

Sweet Potato Pie

$3.90

Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant (Massapequa)

45–60 min

• $

4.7

Regular Pie

$24.75

American Waffle House

40–55 min

4.6

KC's Pizza N Wings (Islip)

45–60 min

4.6

Classico Pizzeria

20–35 min

4.7

18" Neopolitan

$23.05

High Tide Taco Bar

35–50 min

4.6

Key Lime Pie

$8.00

Italiano

45–60 min

4.9

Greek Street

40–55 min

• $$

4.8

Spinach Pie

Fredos Pizza & Pasta

45–60 min

• $

4.7

Regular Cheese Pie (18")

$25.25

Pasta Time Deli

40–55 min

New

White Castle (6207 Sunrise Hwy.)

Spend $25, Save $4

White Castle (6207 Sunrise Hwy.)

25–40 min

• $

4.6

Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria

60–75 min

4.5

GF Eggplant Rollatini appetizer (2 pieces)

$18.85

317 Main Street

30–45 min

• $$

4.3

Key Lime Pie

$8.00

Mercato Kitchen and Cocktails

45–60 min

• $$

4.7

Raimos of Amityville

30–45 min

• $$

4.9

Seaqua Deli & Catering

40–55 min

• $

4.8

Energy Fuel

20–35 min

• $

4.8

Paradise Caribbean Restaurant - West Babylon

15–30 min

• $$

4.4

Accra (2 pieces)

$2.00

Monaco's Pizzeria & Restaurant

30–50 min

• $

4.6

Gino's of Lindenhurst Pizzeria & Restaurant

20–35 min

• $

4.7

Pink's Vegan Diner (Merrick)

3 Offers Available

Pink's Vegan Diner (Merrick)

60–75 min

4.6

Gustoso Pizzeria

65–80 min

4.6

Margherita

$11.95

Cactus Cafe (Huntington)

55–70 min

4.8

LIMEADE (Homemade)

$4.20

Matteo’s Of Bellmore - Bellmore

80–95 min

• $$$

4.8

Buffalo Grille

30–50 min

• $

4.8

Wheatley Deli(10 Colonial Springs Rd)

20–35 min

4.7

Seaford Harbor Deli

35–50 min

4.9

Dang BBQ

30–50 min

4.8

4 Piece Corn Bread

$7.20

Mario's Pizza & Restaurant

40–55 min

• $

4.7

Round Cheese Pie (18")

$24.00

Hurricane Grill & Wings (Lindenhurst)

30–45 min

• $$

4.6

Key Lime Pie

$9.19

Shah's Halal Food - Lindenhurst

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Shah's Halal Food - Lindenhurst

15–30 min

• $

4.6

Hot Wings (Six Pieces)

$6.99

Bellagio Pizzeria & Restaurant

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Bellagio Pizzeria & Restaurant

30–50 min

New

Checkers Drive-In (1825 Brentwood Road)

30–45 min

• $$

4.4

Apple Pies

$1.29

DI Carlo's Pizzeria

60–75 min

• $

4.8

1932 Deer Park Coffee and Bakery LLC

20–35 min

4.8

Big Daddy's

35–50 min

• $$

4.6

Key Lime Pie

$13.00

Captree Gourmet Deli

30–50 min

• $

4.8

Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint

55–70 min

4.5

Ciro's Pizzeria & Restaurant

60–75 min

• $

4.7

Popeyes (1670 Deer Park Ave)

3 Offers Available

Popeyes (1670 Deer Park Ave)

15–30 min

• $

4.4

Cinnamon Apple Pie

$2.39

La Piazza - Cucina Italiana & Wine Bar

45–60 min

• $

4.8

Neopolitan Round Pie

$26.75

Riko's Pizza - Merrick

50–65 min

4.9

Classic Plain Cheese

$13.19

Original Brooklyn Pizza

50–65 min

4.7

Little Gyro Kitchen

55–70 min

• $

4.6

Spinach Pie (Spanakopita)

$10.30

Chicken Carnival

50–65 min

• $$

4.5

Individual Fish Pieces

$8.75

Stew Leonard's Wines of Farmingdale

30–50 min

• $

4.9

Robert Mondavi Private Selection Chardonnay White Wine - 750ml Bottle

$12.08

Burger King (700 Farmingdale Road)

2 Offers Available

Burger King (700 Farmingdale Road)

10–25 min

• $

4.6

Birthday Pie Slice

$3.69

Riko's Pizza- Levittown

50–65 min

4.7

Reese's Peanut Butter Pie (sl)

$5.99

Roma Pizza - Merrick

50–65 min

• $

4.8

G TASTE Crêpe Café

55–70 min

4.7

Frida's Mexican Grill

55–70 min

4.5

Pie De Coco Custard

$7.28

Delicias Latinas Bakery Restaurant

30–50 min

• $

4.6

Wagyu Steak House

25–40 min

4.4

Wendy's (625 W Montauk Hwy)

10–25 min

• $

4.5

Bistro Cassis (Huntington)

60–75 min

• $$$

4.8

Taco Bell (85 E. Sunrise Hwy)

10–25 min

• $

4.5

Alex Pizza

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Alex Pizza

65–80 min

4.3

Pepperoni Pie Slice

$5.00

Atlantis Diner - West Islip

20–35 min

4.4

McDonald's® (131 Sunrise Hwy (Bobs Shopping Center))

10–20 min

• $

4.7

Strawberry & Crème Pie

$2.59

Crostini Pizza on Broadway

35–50 min

• $

4.7

12" Old Style Pizzetta

$12.35

Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

2 Offers Available

Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

25–40 min

• $

4.6

S'more Pie

$3.99

Lindencrest Diner

25–40 min

4.7

Smith Street Deli

70–85 min

4.8

Pizzaiola

25–40 min

• $

4.7

Greek Xpress Plainview

60–75 min

• $

4.7

Spinach Pies

$12.95

Frankie's Pizzeria and Restaurant

65–80 min

4.7

16" Regular Pie

$22.50

La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria

40–55 min

4.7

Roast Sandwich House (Hicksville)

20–40 min

• $

4.8

Filetto's Pizzeria and Restaurant

60–75 min

4.7

Mozzarella's Pizza

40–60 min

4.8

Cheese Pie

$14.24

Sonic (1380 Deer Park Avenue)

15–30 min

• $

4.4

Nathan's Famous (1086 The Arches Circle)

30–45 min

• $

4.3

Pollo Campero (Bayshore-Fifth Ave)

45–60 min

• $$

4.6

Three Piece Meal

$13.25

Panera (1025 Montauk Highway )

Save on Select Items

Panera (1025 Montauk Highway )

15–30 min

• $

4.7

Hunan Kitchen

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Hunan Kitchen

20–35 min

4.2

Voodoo Crab - Massapequa

30–50 min

• $$

4.7

Smashburger (36 E. Sunrise Hwy.)

15–30 min

• $$

4.7

Sabor A Colombia

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Sabor A Colombia

60–75 min

• $$

4.7

Pita & Pizza - Brentwood

35–50 min

4.3

Teal Kitchen & Cafe

50–65 min

4.6

South Bellmore Deli

60–75 min

• $

4.6

Three Amigos Fresh Mexican Grill

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Three Amigos Fresh Mexican Grill

35–50 min

4.5

Wine Obsession

2 Offers Available

Wine Obsession

10–30 min

• $$

5.0

Robert Mondavi Private Selection Chardonnay White Wine - 750ml Bottle

$11.54

Santorini Greek Restaurant

50–65 min

• $

4.7

Spinach Pie

$9.00

Dunkin' (393 Little East Neck Rd)

10–20 min

• $

4.5

Juventus Pizza Ristorante (Grand Blvd)

30–45 min

4.6

Large Classic Cheese Pie (16 Inch)

$18.75

Buzz'd Express Coffee

Spend $20, Save $5

Buzz'd Express Coffee

50–65 min

4.7

Don Jono's Pizzeria

50–65 min

• $$

4.7

Wing Zone (NY200085)

Top Offer • Spend $40, Save $11

Wing Zone (NY200085)

65–80 min

• $

4.6

8 Piece Original

$13.59

Power Tacos

35–50 min

4.4

Jarritos Soda Lime

$3.50

Tropical Smoothie Cafe (Lindenhurst)

Spend $20, Save $5

Tropical Smoothie Cafe (Lindenhurst)

10–25 min

• $

4.5

BLIMEY LIMEY™

$9.79

Ginos Tuscany

40–55 min

• $$

4.7

Regular Pie Pizza (18")

$25.00

Raimo's Pizza of Hicksville

Top Offer • Spend $45, Save $15

Raimo's Pizza of Hicksville

55–70 min

New

Pie (18")

$23.00

Brentwood Market Deli

35–50 min

• $

5.0

Rice & Beans Delicatessen

20–35 min

4.3

YAAAS TEA - Farmingdale

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

YAAAS TEA - Farmingdale

30–45 min

• $$

4.9

Fuel Your Body Cafe

50–70 min

• $

4.8

Aloha Poke & Crêpe

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Aloha Poke & Crêpe

45–60 min

4.9

Mongo's Coffee Roastery & Lounge

4 Offers Available

Mongo's Coffee Roastery & Lounge

55–70 min

• $

4.7

The Eagle's Nest Food & Smoothie Cafe

30–50 min

3.8

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers

45–60 min

• $

4.7

Peri Peri Guys

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Peri Peri Guys

60–75 min

4.7

MANGO & LIME

$0.60

Amias delicatessen

60–75 min

• $

4.8

Ming Stars Kitchen

$0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

Ming Stars Kitchen

60–75 min

New

Jones Beach Deli

45–60 min

4.8

Fratellis Italian Gourmet Market

25–40 min

4.8

Mama Linos Pizzeria & Restaurant - Old Country Rd

60–75 min

• $

4.4

Garlic Knots (6 pieces)

$2.99

Arby's (100 Sunrise Highway)

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Arby's (100 Sunrise Highway)

10–30 min

• $

4.4

Show Win Cuisine

60–75 min

• $

4.9

Hootie's Burger Bar (Farmingdale)

35–50 min

• $$

New

Toby Pierre Bubble Tea, Crepes, Waffles Cafe

Spend $40, Save $11

Toby Pierre Bubble Tea, Crepes, Waffles Cafe

55–70 min

4.6

Chiddy's Cheesesteaks - Deer Park

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Chiddy's Cheesesteaks - Deer Park

25–40 min

4.4

Apple Pie Empanada

$6.00

BEVMO WINE & LIQUOR

2 Offers Available

BEVMO WINE & LIQUOR

25–45 min

• $

5.0

Robert Mondavi Private Selection Chardonnay White Wine - 750ml Bottle

$14.29

ZA Pizzeria - Seaford

45–65 min

• $

4.5

A1 Market

2 Offers Available

A1 Market

40–60 min

4.8

Bang Key Lime Pie Energy Drink ( 16 fl oz )

$2.75

Takeshi Sushi & Teriyaki

20–35 min

• $

4.7

Great Neck Wine & Liquor

20–40 min

5.0

KeKe Beach Liqueur Key Lime Cream - 750ml Bottle

$23.99

Francesca’s Pizza

45–60 min

• $

4.8

Tim Hortons (2475 Hempstead Tpke)

3 Offers Available

Tim Hortons (2475 Hempstead Tpke)

45–60 min

• $$

4.5

Ferraro's Liquor Store

10–30 min

New

Robert Mondavi Private Selection Chardonnay White Wine - 750ml Bottle

$14.97

Venezia deli

25–40 min

4.9

Chicken Gyro Galaxy

Free Item (Spend $40)

Chicken Gyro Galaxy

60–75 min

New

Dirty Taco + Tequila - Wantagh

50–65 min

4.7

Bagel Chalet (Merrick)

55–70 min

• $

4.8

Bango Bowls - Bay Shore

3 Offers Available

Bango Bowls - Bay Shore

25–40 min

• $

4.8

Wings Over Farmingdale

40–55 min

• $

4.7

Chick-fil-A (1991 Broadhollow Road and 33 Gazza Boulevard)

20–35 min

• $

4.7

LIQUOR & WINE

2 Offers Available

LIQUOR & WINE

35–55 min

• $

4.8

Josh Cellars Sauvignon Blanc (750ml bottle)

$15.39

Bagel Boss - Hicksville

30–50 min

• $

4.7

Cherrywood Wine And Spirits INC

35–55 min

• $$

4.9

Robert Mondavi Private Selection Chardonnay White Wine (750ml )

$13.19

Victor's Pizza & Pasta

45–60 min

• $$

4.9

(l) Large Pie

$24.07

On Parade Diner

55–70 min

4.6

Mr. Sausage

50–65 min

• $$

4.8

Umberto's Plainview

40–60 min

4.7

Regular Pie

$26.50

Layers Bakeshop-Roslyn Heights

Too far to deliver

Layers Bakeshop-Roslyn Heights

16.4 mi

4.6

Prestano Bagel & Bakery

Too far to deliver

Prestano Bagel & Bakery

13.6 mi

4.6

Mitchell's Diner

Too far to deliver

Mitchell's Diner

15.7 mi

• $

4.6

Sugar Free Apple Pie

$8.39

Island Bakery & Desserts

Too far to deliver

Island Bakery & Desserts

17 mi

4.8

Bigelows New England Fried Clams

Too far to deliver

Bigelows New England Fried Clams

15.2 mi

4.7

Key Lime Pie

$9.25

Dortoni Bakery- East Norwich

Too far to deliver

Dortoni Bakery- East Norwich

12.8 mi

4.7

Cold Stone Creamery (984 Franklin Ave)

Too far to deliver

Cold Stone Creamery (984 Franklin Ave)

14.8 mi

• $

4.8

Apple Pie a la Cold Stone®

$10.39

Holbrook Diner

Too far to deliver

Holbrook Diner

15.9 mi

• $

4.7

Carle Place Diner

Too far to deliver

Carle Place Diner

13.8 mi

• $

4.6

Sweet Surprise Gifts

Too far to deliver

Sweet Surprise Gifts

15.2 mi

4.2

Sonny's Canal House

Too far to deliver

Sonny's Canal House

14 mi

• $

4.7

Key Lime Pie

$14.00

Millennium Diner

Too far to deliver

Millennium Diner

12.9 mi

• $$

4.5

Arooga's Grille House & Sports Bar (Patchouge)

Too far to deliver

Arooga's Grille House & Sports Bar (Patchouge)

18.1 mi

• $

4.6

The Village Idiot Pub - Patchogue

Too far to deliver

The Village Idiot Pub - Patchogue

18.1 mi

• $

4.6

Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea: West Main

Too far to deliver

Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea: West Main

12.4 mi

• $

4.9

RHUM

Too far to deliver

RHUM

18.1 mi

• $

4.6

Award-Winning Key Lime Pie

$13.50

Williston Townhouse Diner

Too far to deliver

Williston Townhouse Diner

15.4 mi

• $

4.7

Just Like Mama's

Too far to deliver

Just Like Mama's

13.5 mi

• $

4.2

Imperial Diner

Too far to deliver

Imperial Diner

12.8 mi

• $$

4.8

Individual Apple Pie

$7.00

Golden Reef Diner

Too far to deliver

Golden Reef Diner

15.6 mi

• $

4.7

Las Vinas

Too far to deliver

Las Vinas

15.3 mi

• $$

4.2

Ralph's Italian Ices & Ice Cream (Hillside Ave)

Too far to deliver

Ralph's Italian Ices & Ice Cream (Hillside Ave)

15.4 mi

• $

4.9

Key Lime Pie

$6.23

Camila's of Front Street

Too far to deliver

Camila's of Front Street

15.8 mi

4.3

Regular pie

$26.00

Famous Dave's - Carle Place (Corporate Dr)

Too far to deliver

Famous Dave's - Carle Place (Corporate Dr)

12.9 mi

• $$

4.5

Novi Italian Restaurant

Too far to deliver

Novi Italian Restaurant

14.3 mi

4.7

Cheese Pie

$16.95

Karvers Grille

Too far to deliver

Karvers Grille

16.4 mi

• $

4.6

California Diner

Too far to deliver

California Diner

17 mi

• $

4.6

Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria

Too far to deliver

Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria

14.7 mi

• $

4.7

Majestic Diner

Too far to deliver

Majestic Diner

12.8 mi

• $$

4.7

Pantry Diner - Rockville Centre

Too far to deliver

Pantry Diner - Rockville Centre

15.3 mi

• $$

4.6

Key Lime Pie

$7.00

Satelite Pizza & Catering

Too far to deliver

Satelite Pizza & Catering

15.9 mi

4.7

Large Pie

$23.53

Southern Girl take 2

Too far to deliver

Southern Girl take 2

12.8 mi

4.3

Buona Sera Ristorante Pizzeria

Too far to deliver

Buona Sera Ristorante Pizzeria

12.8 mi

• $$

4.6

Gluten Free Cheese Pie

$15.95

Island Lake Diner

Too far to deliver

Island Lake Diner

16.1 mi

• $

4.7

Brews Brothers Grille - Franklin Square

Too far to deliver

Brews Brothers Grille - Franklin Square

17 mi

• $

4.6

6 Pieces

$10.00

Holbrook Market Place and Delicatessen

Too far to deliver

Holbrook Market Place and Delicatessen

15.5 mi

4.6

Sweet Mama's (Northport)

Too far to deliver

Sweet Mama's (Northport)

12.1 mi

• $

4.7

BLD's Restaurant

Too far to deliver

BLD's Restaurant

14.7 mi

• $$

4.6

Gino's of Kings Park

Too far to deliver

Gino's of Kings Park

12.5 mi

4.8

Regular Pie

$25.50

Da Angelo Pizzeria & Ristorante

Too far to deliver

Da Angelo Pizzeria & Ristorante

15.7 mi

• $

4.9

Neapolitan Pie

$20.13

Tous Les Jours Café

Too far to deliver

Tous Les Jours Café

12.7 mi

4.8

Old Westbury Diner

Too far to deliver

Old Westbury Diner

14.2 mi

• $$

4.7

Raimo's Pizza & Restaurant

Too far to deliver

Raimo's Pizza & Restaurant

13.1 mi

• $

4.7

Regular Pie

$18.95

Skinny Pizza - Roslyn Heights

Too far to deliver

Skinny Pizza - Roslyn Heights

16.1 mi

• $

4.8

10" Simple Skinny

$11.00

Parkville Plaza Deli

Too far to deliver

Parkville Plaza Deli

14 mi

4.8

Old City Public House (Portion Rd)

Too far to deliver

Old City Public House (Portion Rd)

15 mi

4.6

Heartisan Pastries

Too far to deliver

Heartisan Pastries

13.2 mi

4.7

Cugini Pizzeria and Restaurant

Too far to deliver

Cugini Pizzeria and Restaurant

15.7 mi

4.8

sweetFrog (Sayville)

Too far to deliver

sweetFrog (Sayville)

15 mi

• $$

4.7

Intermezzo Brick Oven Trattoria

Too far to deliver

Intermezzo Brick Oven Trattoria

13.7 mi

4.8

Vodka Pie 18" Pizza <ol>

$36.90

270 Deli NY

Too far to deliver

270 Deli NY

13.3 mi

• $

4.7

Kennedy Fried Chicken, Grill, & Kabab - Hempstead (Franklin St)

Too far to deliver

Kennedy Fried Chicken, Grill, & Kabab - Hempstead (Franklin St)

14.3 mi

• $

4.6

Sweet potato pie

$4.50

Regina Pizzeria

Too far to deliver

Regina Pizzeria

16.9 mi

• $

4.7

Large Pie (8 Slice)

$25.74

Crazy Crepe Cafe - Smithtown

Too far to deliver

Crazy Crepe Cafe - Smithtown

12.7 mi

• $$

4.6

Montana Brothers

Too far to deliver

Montana Brothers

12.6 mi

• $$

4.5

Large pie 18"

$21.25

Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

Too far to deliver

Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

18.8 mi

4.7

ValleyBites Deli & Grocery

Too far to deliver

ValleyBites Deli & Grocery

18.1 mi

3.8

That Meetball Place - Patchogue

Too far to deliver

That Meetball Place - Patchogue

18 mi

• $$

4.6

Prime Wine & Liquor

Too far to deliver

Prime Wine & Liquor

12.5 mi

5.0

Josh Cellars Sauvignon Blanc - 750ml Bottle

$14.94