Uber Eats Home

    American pizza Delivery in Bay Shore

    Find Food

    American pizza Delivery in Bay Shore

      1. United States
      2. New York
      3. Bay Shore
      4. American pizza

      American pizza Delivery in Bay Shore

      Order American pizza for delivery or pickup from a local restaurant or shop in Bay Shore. Compare your options for American pizza delivery then place your order online.

      Domino's Pizza (55 3rd Ave)

      Save on Select Items

      Domino's Pizza (55 3rd Ave)

      30–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Butera's Restaurant

      Butera's Restaurant

      10–25 min
       
      4.8

      KFC - Bay Shore

      Free Item (Spend $10)

      KFC - Bay Shore

      10–20 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille - Bay Shore

      Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille - Bay Shore

      10–25 min
       
      New

      Amore Pizzeria & Fine Food

      Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

      Amore Pizzeria & Fine Food

      35–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Grimaldi's Pizza & Pasta

      Grimaldi's Pizza & Pasta

      15–30 min
       
      New

      Umberto's of Massapequa Park

      Umberto's of Massapequa Park

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Goody Two Shoes

      Goody Two Shoes

      10–25 min
       
      New

      Pino's Pizza

      Pino's Pizza

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      Tap Room (Bayshore)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Tap Room (Bayshore)

      20–35 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Villa Pizza

      Villa Pizza

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Nunzio's Pizza Town

      Nunzio's Pizza Town

      35–50 min
       
      New

      Albert's Pizza

      Albert's Pizza

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.1

      Gustoso Pizzeria

      Gustoso Pizzeria

      55–70 min
       
      4.6

      Rock City Dogs

      Rock City Dogs

      15–30 min
       
      4.7

      KC's Pizza N Wings (Islip)

      KC's Pizza N Wings (Islip)

      30–45 min
       
      4.7

      Panera (1701 Sunrise Highway )

      Panera (1701 Sunrise Highway )

      10–25 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Pasqually's Pizza & Wings P511 (155 Sunrise Hwy)

      Pasqually's Pizza & Wings P511 (155 Sunrise Hwy)

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      New

      Buseto Pizza & Restaurant

      Buseto Pizza & Restaurant

      15–30 min
       
      5.0

      American Standard - Whiskey Bar & Grill (W Main St)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      American Standard - Whiskey Bar & Grill (W Main St)

      10–25 min
       
      4.4

      Rocco’s Pizza & Pasta

      Rocco’s Pizza & Pasta

      55–70 min
       
      New

      Subway (1735 Union Blvd)

      Spend $15, Save $3

      Subway (1735 Union Blvd)

      10–20 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Lark Pub and Grub

      Lark Pub and Grub

      50–65 min
       
      New

      Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

      Save on Select Items

      Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

      15–30 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Don Jono's Pizzeria

      Don Jono's Pizzeria

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.9

      Canz Bar & Grill Bohemia

      Canz Bar & Grill Bohemia

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

      Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

      10–25 min
       
      4.6

      The Penny Pub

      The Penny Pub

      10–25 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Marcony Pizza

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Marcony Pizza

      20–35 min
       
      4.7

      Sal's Ristorante & Bar

      Sal's Ristorante & Bar

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      New

      Classico Pizzeria

      Classico Pizzeria

      20–35 min
       
      4.6

      Papa Johns Pizza (452A Suffolk Ave)

      2 Offers Available

      Papa Johns Pizza (452A Suffolk Ave)

      25–40 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Angela's Pizza

      Angela's Pizza

      20–35 min
       
      4.8

      Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

      Top Offer • 20% off (Spend $15)

      Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

      45–60 min
       
      4.8

      Victor's Pizza & Pasta

      Victor's Pizza & Pasta

      50–65 min
        •  $$
       
      4.8

      Milano's Pizzeria & Restaurant

      Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

      Milano's Pizzeria & Restaurant

      50–65 min
       
      4.6

      Pizza Stop

      Pizza Stop

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.4

      Chefs of New York - East Northport

      Chefs of New York - East Northport

      50–65 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Bonillas Pizza

      Free Item (Spend $20)

      Bonillas Pizza

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Mozzarella's Pizza

      Mozzarella's Pizza

      40–60 min
       
      4.9

      Albert’s Pizza (Ronkonkoma)

      Albert’s Pizza (Ronkonkoma)

      50–65 min
       
      5.0

      Mary's Pizza and Pasta (Connetquot )

      Mary's Pizza and Pasta (Connetquot )

      30–45 min
       
      4.7

      Pizzaiola

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Pizzaiola

      25–40 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Royal Pizza

      Royal Pizza

      50–65 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      Mama Tita's Pizza and Pasta

      3 Offers Available

      Mama Tita's Pizza and Pasta

      45–60 min
       
      New

      Pita & Pizza - Brentwood

      Pita & Pizza - Brentwood

      25–40 min
       
      4.4

      Pizza Network

      Pizza Network

      25–40 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      Americano Pie Bar

      Americano Pie Bar

      30–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Dominick's Pizza & Pasta

      Dominick's Pizza & Pasta

      40–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Mamma Santina Pizza

      Mamma Santina Pizza

      30–50 min
       
      4.8

      Gino's Pizza of West Babylon

      Gino's Pizza of West Babylon

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Mario's Pizzeria (Melville)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Mario's Pizzeria (Melville)

      50–65 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Original Brooklyn Pizza

      Original Brooklyn Pizza

      40–55 min
       
      4.6

      Piazzetta

      Piazzetta

      30–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Catusco's Pizza

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Catusco's Pizza

      70–85 min
       
      5.0

      Francesco's Trattoria

      Francesco's Trattoria

      20–35 min
       
      4.0

      3 Brothers Pizza Cafe

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      3 Brothers Pizza Cafe

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Gino's of Lindenhurst Pizzeria & Restaurant

      Gino's of Lindenhurst Pizzeria & Restaurant

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Bella Napoli

      Bella Napoli

      40–55 min
       
      New

      Pizza Hut (717 Suffolk Ave)

      2 Offers Available

      Pizza Hut (717 Suffolk Ave)

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.4

      La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria

      La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria

      30–45 min
       
      4.7

      Brooklyn Calzones (287 Second Ave)

      Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

      Brooklyn Calzones (287 Second Ave)

      35–50 min
        •  $$
       
      4.2

      MB Pizzeria & Restaurant

      Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

      MB Pizzeria & Restaurant

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Parisi's Pizza & Pasta

      Parisi's Pizza & Pasta

      40–55 min
       
      4.7

      Amore Pizza

      Amore Pizza

      50–65 min
       
      4.8

      Gino's of Kings Park

      $0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

      Gino's of Kings Park

      60–80 min
       
      4.8

      Richie's Pizza

      Richie's Pizza

      35–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Crostini Pizza on Broadway

      Crostini Pizza on Broadway

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Fredos Pizza & Pasta

      Fredos Pizza & Pasta

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.9

      Carlo's Pizza of Holbrook

      Carlo's Pizza of Holbrook

      60–80 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Filetto's Pizzeria and Restaurant

      Filetto's Pizzeria and Restaurant

      50–65 min
       
      4.7

      Restaurant and pizza Taormina

      Restaurant and pizza Taormina

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Nonna's Pizzeria

      Nonna's Pizzeria

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Vinardos Pizza - Suffolk

      Vinardos Pizza - Suffolk

      30–45 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      California Pizza Kitchen (160 Walt Whitman Rd)

      California Pizza Kitchen (160 Walt Whitman Rd)

      60–75 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      Giorgios

      Giorgios

      30–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Umberto's of Sayville

      Umberto's of Sayville

      35–50 min
       
      4.8

      Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza (Bohemia)

      Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza (Bohemia)

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Mamma Lombardis

      Mamma Lombardis

      65–80 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

      Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

      35–50 min
       
      4.7

      VICO

      2 Offers Available

      VICO

      45–60 min
       
      4.4

      La Slice Pizzeria

      La Slice Pizzeria

      30–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Little Caesars (70 W Suffolk Ave)

      Little Caesars (70 W Suffolk Ave)

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Alfredo's Pizza

      Save on Select Items

      Alfredo's Pizza

      25–45 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Mario’s Pizzeria (Commack)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Mario’s Pizzeria (Commack)

      35–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Papa's Pizza

      Papa's Pizza

      35–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Our Little Italy

      Free Item (Spend $50)

      Our Little Italy

      40–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Chuck E. Cheese (155 Sunrise Hwy)

      Chuck E. Cheese (155 Sunrise Hwy)

      25–40 min
        •  $
       
      4.4

      Joe's Pizza & Pasta

      Joe's Pizza & Pasta

      25–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      The Burger (17)

      Top Offer • 3 Offers Available

      The Burger (17)

      35–55 min
       
      New

      Poppop's Pizzeria

      Poppop's Pizzeria

      50–65 min
       
      New

      Cafe Gio

      Cafe Gio

      25–40 min
       
      4.4

      Nunzi's

      Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

      Nunzi's

      45–60 min
       
      4.6

      Buona Sera Ristorante Pizzeria

      Buona Sera Ristorante Pizzeria

      50–65 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      Patrizia's of Long Island (Hauppauge)

      Top Offer • 4 Offers Available

      Patrizia's of Long Island (Hauppauge)

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      1683 SPORTS BAR & GRILLE

      1683 SPORTS BAR & GRILLE

      25–40 min
       
      New

      Haunted House of Hamburgers

      Haunted House of Hamburgers

      40–55 min
       
      New

      Lily's - Babylon

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Lily's - Babylon

      25–40 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Crown Fried Chicken (Wyandanch)

      Crown Fried Chicken (Wyandanch)

      25–40 min
       
      4.3

      La estacion (Zabiha Halal)

      3 Offers Available

      La estacion (Zabiha Halal)

      15–35 min
       
      4.5

      La Piazza - Cucina Italiana & Wine Bar

      La Piazza - Cucina Italiana & Wine Bar

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Buster's American Kitchen (Islandia)

      Buster's American Kitchen (Islandia)

      35–50 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      Burger King (335 Montauk Highway)

      Burger King (335 Montauk Highway)

      10–20 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Big Al's Burgers

      2 Offers Available

      Big Al's Burgers

      55–70 min
       
      New

      Mannino's Italian Kitchen and Lounge

      Mannino's Italian Kitchen and Lounge

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Brightwaters Inn

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Brightwaters Inn

      15–30 min
       
      4.6

      Butterfields Restaurant

      Butterfields Restaurant

      35–50 min
       
      New

      Philly Cheez (1912)

      Top Offer • 3 Offers Available

      Philly Cheez (1912)

      30–45 min
       
      4.4

      Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant

      Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant

      40–55 min
       
      New

      Portion Kitchen

      Portion Kitchen

      50–65 min
       
      New

      Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar

      Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar

      15–30 min
       
      New

      Chiddy's Cheesesteaks - West Islip

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Chiddy's Cheesesteaks - West Islip

      15–30 min
       
      4.6

      Matteos Trattoria

      Matteos Trattoria

      55–70 min
        •  $$
       
      4.8

      Jersey Mike's Subs (585 Main Street - Montauk Highway)

      Jersey Mike's Subs (585 Main Street - Montauk Highway)

      10–25 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Dave & Buster's (Islandia)

      Spend $35, Save $8

      Dave & Buster's (Islandia)

      35–50 min
        •  $$
       
      4.4

      Regino's Restaurant & Pizzeria (235 Broadway)

      Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

      Regino's Restaurant & Pizzeria (235 Broadway)

      30–50 min
       
      New

      Taco Bell (490 E Main Street)

      Taco Bell (490 E Main Street)

      10–20 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Popeyes - Bay Shore

      $0 Delivery Fee (Spend $15)

      Popeyes - Bay Shore

      10–25 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      Katty's Mac & Cheese

      2 Offers Available

      Katty's Mac & Cheese

      50–65 min
       
      New

      Applebee's (East Islip)

      Applebee's (East Islip)

      25–40 min
        •  $$
       
      4.4

      Carmelina's - Smithtown

      Carmelina's - Smithtown

      25–45 min
        •  $
       
      New

      Miller's Ale House Deer Park

      Spend $60, Save $15

      Miller's Ale House Deer Park

      30–45 min
        •  $$
       
      4.4

      TIESTO’S Restaurant

      TIESTO’S Restaurant

      35–50 min
       
      4.6

      BeeBeeZ Burgers and Wings - West Islip

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      BeeBeeZ Burgers and Wings - West Islip

      20–35 min
       
      4.3

      Smokey Bones (Ronkonkoma)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Smokey Bones (Ronkonkoma)

      45–60 min
        •  $$
       
      4.4

      Mercato Kitchen and Cocktails

      Mercato Kitchen and Cocktails

      55–70 min
        •  $$
       
      4.8

      South Bay Diner - Lindenhurst

      South Bay Diner - Lindenhurst

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Gino's of Farmingdale

      Top Offer • 3 Offers Available

      Gino's of Farmingdale

      45–60 min
       
      New

      It's Just Wings (2020 Sunrise Hwy)

      It's Just Wings (2020 Sunrise Hwy)

      15–30 min
        •  $$
       
      4.1

      The Dark Horse Tavern

      The Dark Horse Tavern

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.4

      Cosmos Burgers & Creamery

      Cosmos Burgers & Creamery

      20–35 min
       
      4.6

      Sayville Bait & Tackle

      Sayville Bait & Tackle

      35–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.9

      Hootie's Burger Bar (Farmingdale)

      Hootie's Burger Bar (Farmingdale)

      35–50 min
        •  $$
       
      New

      Old City Public House (Portion Rd)

      Old City Public House (Portion Rd)

      45–60 min
       
      4.7

      Fat Boys Burrito (East Northport)

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Fat Boys Burrito (East Northport)

      35–50 min
       
      4.8

      Tango Argentinian Steakhouse

      Tango Argentinian Steakhouse

      35–50 min
        •  $$$
       
      4.7

      BEER KING

      Spend $15, Save $3

      BEER KING

      20–40 min
        •  $
       
      5.0

      The Villager Farmingdale

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      The Villager Farmingdale

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      Millennium Diner

      Millennium Diner

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      The Villager

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      The Villager

      25–40 min
       
      4.7

      Five Guys (1701 Sunrise Hwy.) NY - 1767

      Five Guys (1701 Sunrise Hwy.) NY - 1767

      10–25 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Burrito Palace and Grill (Lake Ronkonkoma)

      Burrito Palace and Grill (Lake Ronkonkoma)

      40–55 min
       
      New

      IHOP (Sunrise Hwy)

      IHOP (Sunrise Hwy)

      15–30 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Pardon My Cheesesteak - 25 West Sunrise Highway

      Spend $15, Save $3

      Pardon My Cheesesteak - 25 West Sunrise Highway

      30–45 min
       
      3.2

      Burgerology (Farmingdale)

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Burgerology (Farmingdale)

      65–80 min
        •  $
       
      4.4

      Nathan's Famous (314 Commack Rd)

      Nathan's Famous (314 Commack Rd)

      50–65 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      The Local

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      The Local

      40–55 min
       
      4.8

      Hot Ones Wings & Sandwiches

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Hot Ones Wings & Sandwiches

      30–45 min
       
      5.0

      Chicken Tonight

      Chicken Tonight

      20–40 min
        •  $
       
      4.3

      Boxcar Burgers

      Boxcar Burgers

      35–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Mary Carroll’s

      Mary Carroll’s

      20–35 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Harbor Wings (Lake Ronkonkoma)

      Harbor Wings (Lake Ronkonkoma)

      50–65 min
        •  $
       
      4.3

      Mile High Wings - East Northport

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Mile High Wings - East Northport

      50–65 min
       
      4.7

      Hurricane Grill & Wings (Lindenhurst)

      Hurricane Grill & Wings (Lindenhurst)

      35–50 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      Wing Nation

      2 Offers Available

      Wing Nation

      45–60 min
       
      4.6

      Toxic Wings - Deer Park

      Toxic Wings - Deer Park

      25–40 min
        •  $
       
      4.4

      Wayback Burgers - East Northport

      $0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

      Wayback Burgers - East Northport

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Wagyu Steak House

      Wagyu Steak House

      35–50 min
       
      New

      Faraday's of Smithtown

      Faraday's of Smithtown

      50–65 min
       
      New

      Super's Cafe

      Free Item (Spend $20)

      Super's Cafe

      50–65 min
       
      New

      Arby's (1050 Broadhollow Road)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Arby's (1050 Broadhollow Road)

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.4

      Momo’s (Union Ave)

      Momo’s (Union Ave)

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Jackson's

      Jackson's

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace North Babylon

      Offers available

      Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace North Babylon

      25–45 min
       
      4.7

      Momos Too Sports Bar & Grill

      Momos Too Sports Bar & Grill

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Chili's Grill & Bar (2020 Sunrise Hwy)

      Top Offer • Spend $35, Save $10

      Chili's Grill & Bar (2020 Sunrise Hwy)

      15–30 min
        •  $$
       
      4.4

      Babylon Burger Bar

      Babylon Burger Bar

      20–35 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      McDonald's® (107 Main St)

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      McDonald's® (107 Main St)

      10–20 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Harbor Burgers (Lake Ronkonkoma)

      Top Offer • 3 Offers Available

      Harbor Burgers (Lake Ronkonkoma)

      50–65 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      The Roasted Wing (Bohemia)

      The Roasted Wing (Bohemia)

      35–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      BEVMO WINE & LIQUOR

      10% off (Spend $20)

      BEVMO WINE & LIQUOR

      10–30 min
        •  $
       
      5.0

      Tender Box (5012 Express Drive South)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Tender Box (5012 Express Drive South)

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      3.6

      Chip City (Babylon)

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Chip City (Babylon)

      30–45 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Hot Spot

      Hot Spot

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.1

      MrBeast Burger (50 Montauk Highway)

      Spend $15, Save $3

      MrBeast Burger (50 Montauk Highway)

      15–30 min
        •  $$
       
      4.4

      California Diner

      California Diner

      35–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Wings Out (Islandia)

      Spend $35, Save $8

      Wings Out (Islandia)

      35–50 min
        •  $$
       
      4.1

      Lindenhurst Diner

      Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Lindenhurst Diner

      30–45 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      TGI Fridays (546 - Central Islip, NY)

      TGI Fridays (546 - Central Islip, NY)

      30–45 min
        •  $$
       
      4.3

      Wendy's (168 Main Street)

      Wendy's (168 Main Street)

      10–20 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      The Wing Experience (Ronkonkoma)

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      The Wing Experience (Ronkonkoma)

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.3

      Milano Bean Cafe

      Milano Bean Cafe

      15–30 min
       
      4.3

      The Olympic Diner

      The Olympic Diner

      25–40 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Chop Shop Bar & Grill

      Chop Shop Bar & Grill

      60–75 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Fogo de Chão (Huntington Station)

      Fogo de Chão (Huntington Station)

      55–70 min
        •  $$
       
      4.0

      The Good Life

      The Good Life

      50–65 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Lucky Clucker

      Lucky Clucker

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.1

      Buffalo Wild Wings (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

      Spend $30, Save $5

      Buffalo Wild Wings (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

      20–35 min
        •  $$
       
      4.3

      Wild Burger (1701 Sunrise Hwy.)

      Spend $25, Save $5

      Wild Burger (1701 Sunrise Hwy.)

      25–40 min
        •  $$
       
      4.2

      Casa Stellina

      Casa Stellina

      45–60 min
       
      New

      7-Eleven (1639 Fifth Ave)

      Spend $20, Save $3

      7-Eleven (1639 Fifth Ave)

      10–30 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Honky Tonks Sandwich Shop

      Honky Tonks Sandwich Shop

      40–55 min
       
      New

      Hauppauge Palace Diner

      Hauppauge Palace Diner

      45–60 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

      Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Island Wings (VR) (340 West Jericho Turnpike)

      Island Wings (VR) (340 West Jericho Turnpike)

      55–70 min
       
      4.6

      Croxley's Ale House - Farmingdale

      Croxley's Ale House - Farmingdale

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.5

      Dunkin' (529 E. Main St)

      Dunkin' (529 E. Main St)

      10–20 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Hooters - Farmingdale (25 Smith Street)

      Hooters - Farmingdale (25 Smith Street)

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.3

      Mi Pueblo Restaurant 2

      Mi Pueblo Restaurant 2

      40–55 min
       
      4.1

      Amity Ales

      Amity Ales

      40–55 min
       
      4.9

      Hacienda Real

      Hacienda Real

      30–45 min
       
      4.7

      Brooklyn Fish, Chicken, & Soul Food

      Brooklyn Fish, Chicken, & Soul Food

      30–45 min
       
      4.1

      Brooklyn Fish & Chicken

      Brooklyn Fish & Chicken

      35–50 min
       
      4.4

      Hell's Kitchen

      Hell's Kitchen

      25–40 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Holbrook Diner

      Holbrook Diner

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Red Lobster (801 Sunrise Highway)

      Red Lobster (801 Sunrise Highway)

      40–55 min
        •  $$
       
      4.6

      Sun shore liquors

      Sun shore liquors

      10–30 min
        •  $$
       
      4.9

      Dirty Taco + Tequila - Smithtown

      Dirty Taco + Tequila - Smithtown

      40–55 min
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Capriottis Sandwich Shop (373 Smithtown Bypass)

      Free Item (Spend $30)

      Capriottis Sandwich Shop (373 Smithtown Bypass)

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Jersey Mike's (1500 Smithtown Avenue)

      Jersey Mike's (1500 Smithtown Avenue)

      45–60 min
       
      New

      Atlantis Diner - West Islip

      Atlantis Diner - West Islip

      20–35 min
       
      New

      Cafe Joelle

      Cafe Joelle

      40–55 min
       
      4.6

      Farmingdale Diner (Ordermark)

      Farmingdale Diner (Ordermark)

      30–50 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Kebab Express | Halal Grill

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Kebab Express | Halal Grill

      55–70 min
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Empanada Mama

      Empanada Mama

      45–60 min
       
      New

      Mito - Smith Haven

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Mito - Smith Haven

      55–70 min
       
      4.6

      Cantina azul

      Cantina azul

      45–60 min
       
      New

      Big Lots (Bay Shore)

      Offers available

      Big Lots (Bay Shore)

      15–35 min
       
      New

      Friendly's (50 Montauk Highway)

      Friendly's (50 Montauk Highway)

      20–35 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      GTO

      Top Offer • 20% off (Spend $20)

      GTO

      65–80 min
       
      4.7

      Village Idiot Irish Pub - Oakdale

      Village Idiot Irish Pub - Oakdale

      35–50 min
       
      4.7

      Post Office Cafe

      Post Office Cafe

      20–35 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Side Chick Chicken (206 Main Street)

      Side Chick Chicken (206 Main Street)

      45–60 min
       
      New

      Guac Shop - Commack

      Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

      Guac Shop - Commack

      35–50 min
       
      4.6

      Cancun Mexican Grill

      Cancun Mexican Grill

      45–60 min
       
      4.9

      Smashburger (36 E. Sunrise Hwy.)

      Smashburger (36 E. Sunrise Hwy.)

      25–40 min
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Cayenne Nashville Hot Chicken

      Cayenne Nashville Hot Chicken

      35–50 min
        •  $
       
      New

      Bang bang burritos

      Bang bang burritos

      15–30 min
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Wing It On! (Copiague)

      $0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

      Wing It On! (Copiague)

      35–50 min
       
      4.7

      Village Idiot Pub (Lake Grove)

      Village Idiot Pub (Lake Grove)

      55–70 min
        •  $
       
      4.5

      LIMANI GRILLE

      LIMANI GRILLE

      35–50 min
       
      5.0

      Harbor Q Smokehouse - Lake Ronkonkoma

      Top Offer • 4 Offers Available

      Harbor Q Smokehouse - Lake Ronkonkoma

      45–60 min
        •  $
       
      4.2

      Jahaira Restaurant

      Jahaira Restaurant

      40–55 min
       
      New

      Instant Replay Sports Bar and grill

      Instant Replay Sports Bar and grill

      60–75 min
       
      5.0

      Energy Fuel - Northport

      Energy Fuel - Northport

      40–55 min
       
      New

      Medford's Pizza and Deli

      Too far to deliver

      Medford's Pizza and Deli

      13.6 mi
       
      4.9

      Tommy's Vegan Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      Tommy's Vegan Pizzeria

      13.8 mi
        •  $
       
      New

      Calzone Corner - Seaford

      Too far to deliver

      Calzone Corner - Seaford

      13.8 mi
        •  $
       
      4.1

      The Dough & Co. Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      The Dough & Co. Pizza

      13.9 mi
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Mario's Pizza & Pasta (659 Old Country)

      Too far to deliver

      Mario's Pizza & Pasta (659 Old Country)

      13.1 mi
       
      New

      The Social Bar & Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      The Social Bar & Pizza

      12.3 mi
       
      New

      Uncle Frank's

      Too far to deliver

      Uncle Frank's

      14.2 mi
       
      4.1

      Salvinos Pizza and Restaurant

      Too far to deliver

      Salvinos Pizza and Restaurant

      14.7 mi
       
      New

      Singas Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      Singas Pizza

      14.1 mi
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Halal BOi Pizza, Platters & Sandwiches

      Too far to deliver

      Halal BOi Pizza, Platters & Sandwiches

      13.7 mi
       
      4.4

      Stony Brook Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      Stony Brook Pizza

      12.5 mi
       
      4.7

      Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

      Too far to deliver

      Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

      14.2 mi
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Spaceship Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      Spaceship Pizza

      12 mi
       
      4.1

      Riko's Pizza- Levittown

      Too far to deliver

      Riko's Pizza- Levittown

      14.4 mi
       
      4.7

      Pizza Corner - Medford

      Too far to deliver

      Pizza Corner - Medford

      14.9 mi
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Mozzafiato Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      Mozzafiato Pizzeria

      12.6 mi
        •  $
       
      4.9

      Sgambati's

      Too far to deliver

      Sgambati's

      11.6 mi
       
      New

      Umberto's Plainview

      Too far to deliver

      Umberto's Plainview

      12.7 mi
       
      4.8

      Il Caffe Italiano

      Too far to deliver

      Il Caffe Italiano

      12 mi
       
      New

      DI Carlo's Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      DI Carlo's Pizzeria

      16.8 mi
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Giovanni’s Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      Giovanni’s Pizzeria

      13.4 mi
       
      4.7

      ZA Pizzeria - Seaford

      Too far to deliver

      ZA Pizzeria - Seaford

      13.8 mi
        •  $
       
      4.5

      Flora's Pizza Cafe

      Too far to deliver

      Flora's Pizza Cafe

      14.3 mi
       
      4.4

      Zara Pizza - Selden

      Too far to deliver

      Zara Pizza - Selden

      15.1 mi
       
      4.7

      Pizza Italia Nyc

      Too far to deliver

      Pizza Italia Nyc

      14 mi
       
      New

      Lia's Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      Lia's Pizzeria

      14.4 mi
       
      4.7

      Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria

      13.3 mi
       
      4.6

      Umberto's of Bellmore

      Too far to deliver

      Umberto's of Bellmore

      15.3 mi
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Super Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      Super Pizza

      15.3 mi
        •  $
       
      4.8

      Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant (Massapequa)

      Too far to deliver

      Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant (Massapequa)

      12.7 mi
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Francesca’s Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      Francesca’s Pizza

      14.7 mi
        •  $
       
      4.8

      O Sole Mio

      Too far to deliver

      O Sole Mio

      12 mi
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Li Gluten Free Eatery (1378 Wantagh Avenue)

      Too far to deliver

      Li Gluten Free Eatery (1378 Wantagh Avenue)

      14.1 mi
       
      New

      DiMaggio's Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      DiMaggio's Pizzeria

      15.2 mi
       
      New

      Mama Bella's Pizzeria & Restaurant (Route 112)

      Too far to deliver

      Mama Bella's Pizzeria & Restaurant (Route 112)

      13.4 mi
        •  $
       
      4.7

      GREGORIOS PIZZERIA

      Too far to deliver

      GREGORIOS PIZZERIA

      12.1 mi
        •  $$
       
      4.8

      Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant (Wantagh)

      Too far to deliver

      Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant (Wantagh)

      14 mi
       
      4.6

      Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint

      Too far to deliver

      Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint

      13.7 mi
       
      4.5

      Via Roma Pizza

      Too far to deliver

      Via Roma Pizza

      16.7 mi
       
      4.6

      Vincenzo's of East Meadow

      Too far to deliver

      Vincenzo's of East Meadow

      15.7 mi
       
      4.9

      Medford Pastaria

      Too far to deliver

      Medford Pastaria

      15.4 mi
       
      4.7

      Riella's Homestyle

      Too far to deliver

      Riella's Homestyle

      14.5 mi
       
      4.9

      Portofino Pizza Huntington Village

      Too far to deliver

      Portofino Pizza Huntington Village

      13.7 mi
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Ciro's Pizzeria & Restaurant

      Too far to deliver

      Ciro's Pizzeria & Restaurant

      17 mi
        •  $
       
      4.7

      Bella Roma

      Too far to deliver

      Bella Roma

      16.5 mi
       
      4.8

      Nino's Pizzeria Pasta & Heros

      Too far to deliver

      Nino's Pizzeria Pasta & Heros

      13.1 mi
       
      4.7

      Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

      13.8 mi
       
      4.8

      Galleria Pizza & Ristorante - Merrick

      Too far to deliver

      Galleria Pizza & Ristorante - Merrick

      16.8 mi
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      L'Anatra Pizza And Kitchen

      Too far to deliver

      L'Anatra Pizza And Kitchen

      13.8 mi
       
      4.5

      Patrizia of Long Island

      Too far to deliver

      Patrizia of Long Island

      13.3 mi
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Intermezzo Brick Oven Trattoria

      Too far to deliver

      Intermezzo Brick Oven Trattoria

      13.2 mi
       
      4.8

      Umbertos of Wantagh

      Too far to deliver

      Umbertos of Wantagh

      14 mi
       
      4.8

      Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria

      Too far to deliver

      Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria

      15.2 mi
       
      4.5

      Locale Gastro Bar and Pizzette

      Too far to deliver

      Locale Gastro Bar and Pizzette

      12.4 mi
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      Setauket Pastaria

      Too far to deliver

      Setauket Pastaria

      15.5 mi
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Caffe Amici

      Too far to deliver

      Caffe Amici

      14 mi
       
      4.6

      Vinny's Pizzeria & Ristorante

      Too far to deliver

      Vinny's Pizzeria & Ristorante

      13.3 mi
       
      New

      Caspers Apps

      Too far to deliver

      Caspers Apps

      14.4 mi
       
      New

      Crown Chicken & Grill - Hicksville

      Too far to deliver

      Crown Chicken & Grill - Hicksville

      14.3 mi
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Elsie Lane Wing House - Huntington

      Too far to deliver

      Elsie Lane Wing House - Huntington

      13.9 mi
       
      4.7

      The Village Idiot Pub - Patchogue

      Too far to deliver

      The Village Idiot Pub - Patchogue

      12.4 mi
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Gusto Divino Trattoria

      Too far to deliver

      Gusto Divino Trattoria

      13.1 mi
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Philly Steak House

      Too far to deliver

      Philly Steak House

      18.4 mi
       
      New

      Arooga's Grille House & Sports Bar (Patchouge)

      Too far to deliver

      Arooga's Grille House & Sports Bar (Patchouge)

      12.4 mi
        •  $
       
      4.6

      Vauxhall Burger Bar

      Too far to deliver

      Vauxhall Burger Bar

      14 mi
        •  $$
       
      4.7

      The best American pizza in Bay Shore

      Enjoy the best American pizza delivery in Bay Shore with Uber Eats. Enter your address to browse the restaurants and shops offering American pizza delivery near you, then start comparing your options. Once you’ve placed your American pizza order online or via the Uber Eats app, you can track its arrival.

      Bay Shore American pizza delivery and pickup

      With Uber Eats, you can enjoy the best American pizza Bay Shore offers without ever having to leave your home. The places that offer American pizza for delivery or pickup may vary depending on your Bay Shore delivery address so be sure to check out which spots offer delivery to home, work, a friend’s house—wherever it is that you may want to enjoy some delicious American pizza. If you’d rather get your American pizza order yourself, see if there are any businesses in Bay Shore offering pickup.