4.9
110+ Ratings
Tortuga Sandwich Shop
4.9 x (110+) • 2293.8 mi • Sandwich • South American • Tacos • Info
x Delivery unavailable
5835 Buffalo Street
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Those street corn fritter things are my new favorite thing. Their sandwiches are awesome, even the next day, their cherry lime juice is nice and tart not sweet AND I LOVE the chocolate mousse cake with the cinnamon dust. ugh! talking about it making"
• Jamie Lee A. • 01/22/23
"I really hope people know about Tortuga Sandwich Shop. Everything they make is so fresh and delicious. Bread is top notch."
• Kyle S. • 02/09/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Monday
Tuesday - Saturday
11:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Featured items
Sandwiches/Specials
- Gustavo Sandwich$17.00 • 94% (34)Crispy fried chicken with mild smoky pepper crust, fresh avocado, Jack cheese, garlic aioli, sweet jalapenos (Write in Special Instructions to sub grilled chicken)
- Chivito Sandwich$17.80 • 93% (30)Thinly sliced marinated ribeye, bacon, grilled provolone, chimichurri, garlic aioli, lettuce and tomato, and an over-easy egg.
- Chino Sandwich$17.50 • 100% (21)Marinated strip steak, sauteed onions & peppers, blistered tomatoes, Peruvian cheese sauce, aji verde (herb aioli), and crispy fried potatoes.
- Evita Sandwich$11.00 • 100% (7)Grilled provolone cheese and chimichurri grilled cheese sandwich
- Phoenix Sandwich$17.00 • 100% (12)Roast turkey breast, bacon, fresh avocado, Jack cheese, chipotle sauce, lettuce & tomato, sweet jalapeños.
- Lanza Sandwich$16.00 • 100% (4)Argentinian style sausage, grilled provolone, chimichurri, sauteed peppers and onions, garlic aioli, sliced tomato
- Pepe Sandwich$15.60 • 100% (10)Serrano ham, Manchego cheese, fresh tomato, dressed greens, and garlic aioli.
- Salmita Sandwich$12.00 • 100% (11)Grilled zucchini, Salsa Brava (smoky tomato sauce), dressed greens, and whipped goat cheese.
- Brasa Sandwich$16.50 • 100% (4)Peruvian marinated grilled chicken, fresh avocado, coleslaw, aji verde, sliced tomato, crispy fried potatoes
- Special: Stay Classy San Diego Burrito$18.75Carne Asada, Jack Cheese, fresh avocado, salsa roja, Mexican sour cream, pico de gallo and crispy french fries all piled high onto a 14” flour tortilla
Sides
- Elocos$6.85 • 100% (35)Crispy Mexican street food corn fritters dusted in ancho chili and cotija cheese. Served with chipotle may, pickled jalapenos, and a wedge of lime.
- Andes Style Potatoes$7.00 • 100% (6)Super crispy potatoes topped with Peruvian cheese sauce and an herb aioli.
- Pelotas$7.50 • 100% (7)Now made with Spanish paella rice. Breaded saffron rice balls stuffed with Manchego cheese, served with Brava sauce and garlic aioli. 2 per order.
- Tortuga Mac & Cheese - Large$7.50Shell pasta in a mild sauce made from hatch chiles and sharp cheddar
- Toluca Style Potatoes$7.80 • 100% (10)Super crispy potatoes topped with queso Blanco cheese sauce, Mexican chorizo, chipotle sauce, and sweet jalapenos.
- Tortuga Mac & Cheese - Small$5.00 • 100% (4)Shell pasta in a mild sauce made from hatch chiles and sharp cheddar
- Madrid Style Potatoes$7.00Super crispy potatoes topped with Manchego cheese, Brava sauce, and garlic aioli.
- Street Corn Mac n Cheese - Small$6.25Shell pasta, roasted corn, spicy cheese blend, chipotle mayo, queso fresco and tajin spice.
- Street Corn Mac n Cheese- Large$8.75Shell pasta, roasted corn, spicy cheese blend, chipotle mayo, queso fresco and tajin spice.
- Agave-Lime Slaw$1.25 • 100% (6)Shredded cabbage and carrot, dressed with our agave lime coleslaw dressing.
Dessert
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.9
•110+ Ratings •
8 Reviews
stefanie M.• 12/12/23Everything is always outstanding here.
Bob Z.• 08/10/23Awesome menu! Everything is delicious!! A definite gem. Sandwich was large and flavorful.
Will Q.• 07/29/23Everything was super flavorful and delicious! Been wanting to try Tortuga for a while now and was not disappointed!
Julianne B.• 04/01/23Delicious! Thank you for following through on our modifications!
Kyle S.• 02/09/23I really hope people know about Tortuga Sandwich Shop. Everything they make is so fresh and delicious. Bread is top notch.
Jamie Lee A.• 01/22/23Those street corn fritter things are my new favorite thing. Their sandwiches are awesome, even the next day, their cherry lime juice is nice and tart not sweet AND I LOVE the chocolate mousse cake with the cinnamon dust. ugh! talking about it making
Jamie Lee A.• 01/20/23I just ordered from them again. that's how much I enjoyed it the first time.
Jaime D.• 05/06/22Amazing!
