4.7
2000+ Ratings
4.7 x (2,000+) • Pizza • Salads • Italian • Group Friendly • Info
x Delivery unavailable
3398 Forum Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905, USA
2000+ Ratings
"I have to watch my carb intake so I thought I would try a gluten-free pizza. It was delicious! I had extra cheese, sauce and basil put on it and it was perfect. Lovely girl delivered it so I didn't have to leave the house. My husband and I love Tony's NY Pizza; they make a wonderful Antipasto salad as well."
"Best pizza I've ever had. Great stromboli and calzones. Large packed with meat, cheese and other ingredients you choose. I crave their food and order frequently."
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM • Menu
8:00 AM - 6:00 PM • Menu
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM • Menu
4.7
•2000+ Ratings •
117 Reviews
Best pizza
Highly recommended
Fast and efficient delivery! Best tasting pizza 🍕 that looks great. You won't be disappointed! 😊
The best
Amazing
The best
They actually read the notes which is fantastic!!!
order pizza and wings very goods
Tony's Pizza was very good so where there's zeppole's and cannoli
Most delicious pizza ever!!!
The pizza was big and the perfect NY STYLE slices! Great food!
Pizza is the best in ft Myers
The best pizza since I left NY
I have to watch my carb intake so I thought I would try a gluten-free pizza. It was delicious! I had extra cheese, sauce and basil put on it and it was perfect. Lovely girl delivered it so I didn't have to leave the house. My husband and I love Tony's NY Pizza; they make a wonderful Antipasto salad as well.
I loved the pizza!!
So good!!
Excellent pizza every time I order it.
Food is awesome
Some of the best pizza I’ve had here in Florida.
Hands down favorite pizza place in town. Never disappointed.
The best pizza
Amazing pizza
The pizza is always delicious!!
I love their food
they have the best pizza
It''s delicious
It tastes like home New York real flavors. Always hot and fresh!!!
awesome pizza
Good
Ahead of schedule. Pizza was very good
Perfect NY pizza every time!
Great pizza reminds me of home in New York
Good is delicious
Awesome!
Great Meatballs
Favorite pizza place of all time. I would definitely recommend it.
Best pizza around! I’m from NY and this is the closest thing to a NY slice I’ve found
Good pizza
Closest to New York style I’ve found so far.
exactly as ordered!
great food
The best NY style pizza in the area.
It’s simply the best pizza in SWFL
Always great as usual
Always the best.
great food
Underrated place the sauce cheese combo is really good here. This place has been consistent since opening as well
Great classic Italian.
We love Tonys pizza
Amazing technique for “pick up”
2nd time, This time I got the Marg. Pie and it was awesome great flavor great crust no flop. we finally found our pizza place.
The BEST NY pizza on either coast of FL hands down!
great pizza
Great NY style pizza. You won’t be disappointed!
great pizza
Amazing
Sicilian and Anti Pasta was terrific!
Wonderful spaghetti!
I have never received a bad pizza from Tony’s. Guaranteed delicious every time.
Delicious
Very delicious
Was prompt and pleasant
Awesome pizza
Best Sicilian pie
good food
Great pizza
They always pay attention to the notes. I wish more people did that. The food was perfect.
Always honors our special requests perfectly. Wish other restaurants were as conscientious. Amazing food every time.
Best pizza place in lee county! Our go to no matter how far the drive! Absolutely love the staff and food! It never disappoints
Everything is amazing
pizza is amazing, and the Philly cheese steak is tender
Good pizza!
Just like New York pizza
Food was good. Didn't know that the food was delivered.
Always great!
tasty Chicken parm sub.
N/a
Definitely the best pizza around.
Best Pizza ever!!!
Tony's is Always fresh and delicious it's almost like being in new york which is a big compliment.
the best
they have huge slices and it's good for the price
They never disappoint
big portions
Best Stromboli I have ever tasted and I’m from NJ lol
Followed special instruction perfectly, unlike other restaurants!!
Best pizza I've ever had. Great stromboli and calzones. Large packed with meat, cheese and other ingredients you choose. I crave their food and order frequently.
As close to NY pizza as you can get. so so good.
so good!!
one of the greatest pizzas
Fast and Good
100% Satisfied !!
Vegan cheze pizza
soooo yummy always & great size for the $ TY !
Best pizza in town
Quick and affordable and delicious
Food was on point, exactly what you would expect.. Great pizza, fresh toppings and nice portions. Good friggin food
Delicious! Great New York crust!
Food was tasty with great portion sizes
On time, hot, delicious!
Delish!!!
Delicious
Best pizza in town! Delicious salad!
Best NY style pizza I have has since moving to Florida
True NY style pizza! Best I have had since moving to Florida!
Fresh fresh fresh and perfect crust!!!!
Great service
Great
I bought this pizza just for me, because I love me.
The Bronx is our favorite!!
Always delicious five stars!!
Good pizza but don’t use ubereats. Driver delivered to the gatehouse and told the guard to eat it.
Excellent
Tasty
the food was delicious! a little pricey, but we will definitely be ordering from there again.
Always happy with the food from Tony’s!
It was really tasty! We definitely enjoyed everything and it was right on time! We can't wait to go to the restaurant and enjoy it!
Yes. Tony’s NY Pizza (3398 Forum Blvd) delivery is available on Uber Eats in Fort Myers.
Enter your address to see if Tony’s NY Pizza (3398 Forum Blvd) delivery is available to your location in Fort Myers.
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Tony’s NY Pizza (3398 Forum Blvd) menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Tony’s NY Pizza (3398 Forum Blvd) here on this page.
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Tony’s NY Pizza (3398 Forum Blvd) order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.