4.7
2000+ Ratings
Tony’s NY Pizza
4.7 x (2,000+) • 2476.4 mi • Pizza • Salads • Italian • Group Friendly • Info
3398 Forum Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905, USA
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Best pizza I've ever had. Great stromboli and calzones. Large packed with meat, cheese and other ingredients you choose. I crave their food and order frequently."
• Stephen R. • 01/28/23
"It was really tasty! We definitely enjoyed everything and it was right on time! We can't wait to go to the restaurant and enjoy it!"
• Stephanie H. • 07/16/21
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Every Day
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Appetizers
- Garlic Knots$6.95 • 74% (329)8 garlic knots served with marinara sauce.
- Chicken Wings (10 pcs)$15.95 • 85% (231)10 wings served with blue cheese.
- Fried Mozzarella (4 pcs)$10.95 • 88% (112)fried mozzarella served with marinara sauce.
- Meatballs and Ricotta$11.95 • 84% (64)Two meatballs served with our home-made sauce and topped with ricotta cheese.
- Caprese Plate$11.95 • 95% (49)Fresh tomato, buffalo mozzarella, roasted red peppers, fresh basil, olive oil, and balsamic reduction.
- Eggplant Tower$11.95 • 86% (43)Hand-breaded eggplant stacked with fresh tomato, buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and finished with a balsamic reduction.
Salads
- Antipasto Salad$14.95 • 96% (91)Romaine lettuce, genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, buffalo mozzarella, tomato, cucumber, carrot, roasted red peppers, and olives. Served with our house vinaigrette.
- Caesar Salad$11.95 • 85% (47)Romaine lettuce, croutons, and shredded Romano cheese.
- Garden Salad$10.95 • 87% (40)Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, roasted peppers, shredded carrot, olives, and onion.
- Athens Salad$13.95 • 97% (69)Feta, black and green olives, onion, tomato, cucumber, and banana peppers, served over lettuce and served with a herb vinaigrette.
Classic Italian Subs
- Chicken Parmesan Sub$13.95 • 89% (67)Breaded chicken cutlets, marinara, and mozzarella cheese.
- Meatball Parmesan Sub$13.95 • 84% (63)Meatballs, marinara, and mozzarella cheese.
- NY Cheese Steak$14.50 • 80% (20)Rib Eye Steak , Peppers, onions, mushrooms and provolone cheese
- Philly Cheese Sub$14.50 • 66% (3)Rib eye steak with peppers, onions, mushrooms, and provolone cheese.
- Italian Combo Sub$13.95 • 93% (31)Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and roasted red peppers. Topped with a herb vinaigrette.
- Eggplant Parmesan Sub$13.95 • 100% (18)Eggplant, marinara, and mozzarella.
- Sausage, Peppers and Onions Sub$13.95 • 100% (13)Sausage, peppers, onions topped with light tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
Create a Pie
Tony's New York Pies
Calzones and Strombolis
Italian Dinners
Desserts
Beverages
Sides
Slices
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•2000+ Ratings •
102 Reviews
Shelby R.• 05/17/24So good!!
Shari L.• 04/30/24Excellent pizza every time I order it.
Paul J.• 03/22/24Food is awesome
Cherie B.• 03/10/24Some of the best pizza I’ve had here in Florida.
Colleen O.• 03/03/24Hands down favorite pizza place in town. Never disappointed.
Dana M.• 03/01/24The best pizza
David O.• 02/24/24Amazing pizza
Judy W.• 02/22/24The pizza is always delicious!!
TALES H.• 02/21/24I love their food
Meza P.• 02/14/24It''s delicious
LISA P.• 02/14/24they have the best pizza
Beth A.• 02/12/24It tastes like home New York real flavors. Always hot and fresh!!!
LISA P.• 02/06/24awesome pizza
Isabel F.• 02/03/24Good
Lucas H.• 02/01/24Ahead of schedule. Pizza was very good
Judy W.• 01/18/24Perfect NY pizza every time!
Cyrus B.• 01/16/24Great pizza reminds me of home in New York
Donna T.• 01/14/24Good is delicious
Barbara P.• 12/21/23Awesome!
Steve K.• 12/17/23Great Meatballs
Ryan R.• 12/16/23Best pizza around! I’m from NY and this is the closest thing to a NY slice I’ve found
Colleen O.• 12/16/23Favorite pizza place of all time. I would definitely recommend it.
Darrell H.• 12/10/23Good pizza
Lori B.• 11/29/23Closest to New York style I’ve found so far.
Christine D.• 11/12/23exactly as ordered!
Ruben S.• 11/11/23great food
Elizabeth V.• 11/10/23The best NY style pizza in the area.
Tom D.• 11/03/23It’s simply the best pizza in SWFL
Paul J.• 10/24/23Always great as usual
Rachel N.• 10/18/23Always the best.
April S.• 10/14/23great food
JASON T.• 10/13/23Underrated place the sauce cheese combo is really good here. This place has been consistent since opening as well
Trish O.• 10/01/23Great classic Italian.
Carmen O.• 09/24/23We love Tonys pizza
Kayla H.• 09/15/23Amazing technique for “pick up”
Christine W.• 09/03/232nd time, This time I got the Marg. Pie and it was awesome great flavor great crust no flop. we finally found our pizza place.
Tom D.• 08/26/23The BEST NY pizza on either coast of FL hands down!
Richard H.• 08/25/23great pizza
Carlos R.• 08/15/23Great NY style pizza. You won’t be disappointed!
STEVEN L.• 08/13/23great pizza
David O.• 08/11/23Amazing
Christine W.• 08/08/23Sicilian and Anti Pasta was terrific!
Roger N.• 08/07/23Wonderful spaghetti!
Debbie D.• 07/27/23I have never received a bad pizza from Tony’s. Guaranteed delicious every time.
Jen W.• 07/26/23Delicious
Corey L.• 07/25/23Very delicious
Steven C.• 07/19/23Was prompt and pleasant
David O.• 07/15/23Awesome pizza
Donna F.• 07/14/23good food
Marylou W.• 07/14/23Best Sicilian pie
Jonathan M.• 07/10/23Great pizza
Barb C.• 06/30/23They always pay attention to the notes. I wish more people did that. The food was perfect.
BRIANNA M.• 06/24/23Best pizza place in lee county! Our go to no matter how far the drive! Absolutely love the staff and food! It never disappoints
Barb C.• 06/24/23Always honors our special requests perfectly. Wish other restaurants were as conscientious. Amazing food every time.
Jonathan M.• 06/23/23Everything is amazing
SHERRICE R.• 06/18/23pizza is amazing, and the Philly cheese steak is tender
Victoria A.• 06/14/23Good pizza!
Colleen E.• 06/11/23Just like New York pizza
Ann C.• 06/09/23Food was good. Didn't know that the food was delivered.
Miguel M.• 05/26/23Always great!
JENNIFER S.• 05/24/23tasty Chicken parm sub.
Genna P.• 05/14/23N/a
Paul B.• 04/27/23Definitely the best pizza around.
Cheryl L.• 04/20/23Best Pizza ever!!!
Leslie G.• 04/14/23Tony's is Always fresh and delicious it's almost like being in new york which is a big compliment.
AMY M.• 04/06/23the best
LISA P.• 03/27/23they have huge slices and it's good for the price
CAROLYN C.• 03/25/23They never disappoint
Latoya H.• 03/03/23big portions
Jason A.• 03/02/23Best Stromboli I have ever tasted and I’m from NJ lol
Buzz F.• 02/26/23Followed special instruction perfectly, unlike other restaurants!!
Stephen R.• 01/28/23Best pizza I've ever had. Great stromboli and calzones. Large packed with meat, cheese and other ingredients you choose. I crave their food and order frequently.
Daniel G.• 12/31/22As close to NY pizza as you can get. so so good.
Olivia V.• 12/30/22so good!!
Michael R.• 12/29/22Fast and Good
Poplar)) M.• 12/29/22one of the greatest pizzas
Valerie W.• 12/22/22100% Satisfied !!
Gregg L.• 12/19/22Vegan cheze pizza
Michelle S.• 11/23/22soooo yummy always & great size for the $ TY !
Thomas M.• 10/16/22Best pizza in town
Jennifer P.• 09/14/22Quick and affordable and delicious
Michael S.• 07/24/22Food was on point, exactly what you would expect.. Great pizza, fresh toppings and nice portions. Good friggin food
Marcia T.• 07/12/22Delicious! Great New York crust!
Yvette E.• 05/28/22Food was tasty with great portion sizes
Michael W.• 03/29/22On time, hot, delicious!
Karen M.• 03/25/22Delish!!!
Jeanne Z.• 03/10/22Delicious
Amanda S.• 02/11/22Best pizza in town! Delicious salad!
patrick F.• 01/02/22Best NY style pizza I have has since moving to Florida
patrick F.• 12/27/21True NY style pizza! Best I have had since moving to Florida!
Amanda S.• 11/02/21Fresh fresh fresh and perfect crust!!!!
tatanisha V.• 10/28/21Great service
Tirso S.• 09/16/21Great
Marina T.• 09/14/21I bought this pizza just for me, because I love me.
Ray J.• 09/08/21The Bronx is our favorite!!
Heidi H.• 09/05/21Always delicious five stars!!
Tara P.• 08/30/21Good pizza but don’t use ubereats. Driver delivered to the gatehouse and told the guard to eat it.
Suzanne H.• 08/23/21Excellent
Volodymyr B.• 08/19/21Tasty
Leslie G.• 08/12/21the food was delicious! a little pricey, but we will definitely be ordering from there again.
Heidi H.• 08/10/21Always happy with the food from Tony’s!
Stephanie H.• 07/16/21It was really tasty! We definitely enjoyed everything and it was right on time! We can't wait to go to the restaurant and enjoy it!
