4.6
180+ Ratings
The Proper Pie Company
4.6 x (180+) • 2437.6 mi • Fish and Chips • Healthy • Chicken • $$ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
511 US Highway 17 92 West
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"I really liked the pie crusts, they were very light and the chicken curry pie was amazing, though I would say I should have ordered two!"
• Rudolph P. • 08/08/23
"Very helpful folk and lovely options for food"
• William B. • 05/28/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
Monday - Wednesday
11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Featured items
Proper Steak Pies
- Steak, Potato, Onion, and Cheese$8.65 • 96% (58)Handmade with tender steak, potato, onion and some cheese, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
- Cornish Pasty$8.65 • 81% (11)Made to the original recipe and ate old half moon shape, our pasty consisting of sliced beef, onion, potato, and turnip is an all time favorite!
- Steak and Ale$8.65 • 95% (67)Handmade with chopped tender steak, potato and traditional ale (which one is our secret!), all wrpaped in our signature double puff pastry
- Steak and Mushroom$8.65 • 92% (41)Handmade with tender steak with large field mushrooms and a touch of cream all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
Proper Chicken Pies
- Chicken Curry$8.65 • 98% (68)Handmade with tender pieces of chicken in a mild, but tangy, curry sauce, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
- Lemon Chicken$8.65 • 100% (12)Handmade with tender pieces of chicken in a creamy lemon and herb sauce. all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
- Chicken, Broccoli, and Cheese$8.65 • 91% (35)Handmade with tender pieces of chicken with broccoli and cheese, all wrapped in our signature puff pastry
- Chicken and Mushroom$8.65 • 96% (26)Handmade with tender chicken with large field mushrooms and a touch of cream all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
- Chicken, leek & potato$8.65
Other Proper Pies
- Shepherd’s Pie in a Pie$8.65 • 95% (63)A unique handmade pie made with finely ground lean beef, mashed potato and mixed vegetables with a sprinkle of cheese on the top, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
- Beef and Onion$8.65 • 100% (10)Handmade with lean scottish ground beef and onion, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
Proper Fruit Pies
- Blueberry Pie$3.95 • 97% (45)Our American favorite handmade sweet pie is full of blueberries and a great dessert (4-5 oz)
- Cherry Pie$3.95 • 91% (37)Our handmade sweet pie filled with cherries makes a great dessert (4-5 oz)
- Apple Pie$3.95 • 88% (45)Handmade with sweet green apples make this a very popular dessert (4-5 oz)
Proper Fish and Chips
- Cod and Chips$14.75 • 81% (81)Our freshly sourced succulent cod with our handmade double cooked chips (fries) in our own secret light and crispy ale batter is delicious on its own or with extra sides!
- Chips$3.45 • 74% (31)Our hand cut double cooked chips (fries) are the real deal
- Homemade Tartar Sauce$1.25 • 70% (20)Our own handmade Tartar sauce is made entirely with fresh ingredients (proper pickles, mayonnaise and capers) and is a perfect accompaniment to our delicious fish & chips
- Sausage in Batter$4.25 • 100% (3)Our great banger sausage in our secret light crispy batter
- Onion Rings (Five)$3.95 • 69% (13)Our 5 onion rings, lightly cooked to order in our secret light and crispy batter are a great accompaniment to our delicious fish & chips or any of our Proper Pies.
Proper Sides
Proper Snacks
Proper Homemade Sweets
Soda & Water
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•180+ Ratings •
6 Reviews
DECARLO C.• 02/23/24Just stop by, and you'll see for yourself.
Susan C.• 11/09/23Amazing pot pies delicious
Mayra M.• 11/03/23First time and it was delicious
Scott R.• 09/02/23Everything was fresh and delicious
Rudolph P.• 08/08/23I really liked the pie crusts, they were very light and the chicken curry pie was amazing, though I would say I should have ordered two!
William B.• 05/28/23Very helpful folk and lovely options for food
