4.4
252 Ratings
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"If you want authentic Italian style New York pizza, look no further. From the great staff to the fast delivery service,this is the place to go. I'm a twice a week buyer 😊"
• Robert R. • 03/03/24
"Fast delivery, the spicy rigatoni pizza was amazing the pasta was fresh and it had a nice kick. The meat lover slice was unreal definitely recommend."
• Jagger K. • 01/29/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Monday - Wednesday
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Thursday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 4:00 AM
Featured items
Menu for Baxter Street Pizza
- The Classic Pie$15.40 $22.00 • 71% (28)Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.
- Pepperoni$18.20 $26.00 • 100% (7)4.25 slice. Classic NY style pizza topped with spicy pepperoni.
- Margherita Pizza$18.90 $27.00 • 50% (6)4.5 slice. Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, touch of tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.
- Vodka Sauce Pizza$17.50 $25.004.25 slice. Our delicious homemade light red cream sauce with sauteed prosciutto di parma and vodka with fresh mozzarella.Popular
- Meat Lovers Pizza$22.40 $32.00 • 62% (8)5 slice. classic NY style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled italian sausage and bacon.
- Classic White Pie Pizza$18.90 $27.004.25 slice. Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.
- Italian Sausage$22.40 $32.004.25 slice. Classic NY style pizza topped with crumbled italian style sausage
- Buffalo Chicken$19.60 $28.00House made spicy buffalo sauce, fresh mozzarella, topped with ranch drizzle.
- Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza$24.50 $35.005 slice. Our delicious homemade vodka sauce finished with calabrian chili, fresh mozzarella and baked rigatoni.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch$21.70 $31.004.50 slice.
- Mushroom$16.80 $24.00 • 100% (3)4.25 slice. Classic NY style pizza with mushroom topping
- Grandma Pizza$19.60 $28.004.5 slice. Homemade mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, basil, fresh garlic, authentic pecorino romano and extra virgin olive oil.
- Supreme Pizza$22.40 $32.00Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms
Slices
- The Classic Slice$2.45* $3.50 • 76% (39)3.5 slice. Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.
- Pepperoni Slice$2.97* $4.25 • 95% (46)4.25 slice. Classic NY style pizza topped with spicy pepperoni.
- Vodka Sauce Slice$2.97* $4.25 • 90% (33)4.25 slice. Our delicious homemade light red cream sauce with sauteed prosciutto di parma and vodka with fresh mozzarella.
- Classic White Slice$2.97* $4.25 • 75% (20)4.25 slice. Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.
- Margherita SLice$3.15* $4.50 • 77% (27)4.5 slice. Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, touch of tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.
- Meat Lovers Slice$3.50* $5.00 • 82% (23)5 slice. classic NY style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled italian sausage and bacon.
- Mushroom Slice$2.97* $4.25 • 78% (14)4.25 slice. Classic NY style pizza with mushroom topping
Rolls
Drinks
- Rating and reviews
4.4
•252 Ratings •
23 Reviews
Shanteek T.• 04/05/24love it, love it, love it.......!
Henry P.• 03/29/24Les recomiendo buena pizza
Lisa F.• 03/04/24Fresh and tasty
Robert R.• 03/03/24If you want authentic Italian style New York pizza, look no further. From the great staff to the fast delivery service,this is the place to go. I'm a twice a week buyer 😊
Doug P.• 02/11/24Great nyc pizza
Deepika N.• 02/03/24Taste was great and portion was huge.
Jamie T.• 02/03/24Excellent pizza, friendly staff, quick service.
Adam O.• 02/01/24this is the best new pizza joint in the city. vodka sauce + white slices are a must!!
Olivia C.• 01/31/24Amazing pizza!! Cooked to perfection
Justin S.• 01/31/24Can’t go wrong with this place. Really great pizza
Jagger K.• 01/29/24Fast delivery, the spicy rigatoni pizza was amazing the pasta was fresh and it had a nice kick. The meat lover slice was unreal definitely recommend.
Sujata S.• 01/25/24Delicious
Michael S.• 01/17/24Food was fantastic. My favorite was the vodka slice. Arrived warm and was delicious. I suggest all pizza lovers check out this new hidden gem
Jonathan E.• 11/22/23Fire
Lisa F.• 09/09/23Fresh and affordable. Fast delivery and pizza was still hot
Shawn L.• 08/29/23Excellent pizza, fresh and reasonably priced...
Jay R.• 07/30/23Great pizza thank you
Clifton M.• 07/23/23Great and delicious
Daniel M.• 07/14/23The best i had in NYC, thank you!
Jessica F.• 07/11/23Best pizza… great crust
jt B.• 07/11/23Best spicy rigatoni slice in NYC
Annie D.• 07/11/23The pie guy never misses. Best pizza in the city for sure.
Ryan S.• 06/30/23Authentic pizza
Can I order The Pie Guy Pizza delivery in New York City with Uber Eats?
Yes. The Pie Guy Pizza delivery is available on Uber Eats in New York City.
Is The Pie Guy Pizza delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if The Pie Guy Pizza delivery is available to your location in New York City.
How do I order The Pie Guy Pizza delivery online in New York City?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the The Pie Guy Pizza menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find The Pie Guy Pizza online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by The Pie Guy Pizza here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my The Pie Guy Pizza order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my The Pie Guy Pizza order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for The Pie Guy Pizza delivery in New York City?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your The Pie Guy Pizza order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
