4.7
800+ Ratings
The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza
4.7 x (800+) • 2448 mi • Pizza • Italian • Pasta • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308, US
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"Food exceeded my expectations. The calamari was nicely battered and crisp. The pasta was perfectly seasoned and the portions were very decent."
• Bonnie S. • 02/04/24
"Always good service , very good food & the bet Italian bread ,friendly staff when we dine it. Great cocktails also , Clean establishment"
• RAYMOND C. • 03/29/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday
11:30 AM - 9:45 PM • Menu
Monday - Thursday
11:30 AM - 9:30 PM • Menu
11:30 AM - 3:00 PM • Lunch Menu
Friday
11:30 AM - 10:30 PM • Menu
11:30 AM - 3:00 PM • Lunch Menu
Saturday
12:00 PM - 10:30 PM • Menu
Featured items
Starters
- Goodfella's Famous Fried Calamari$16.00 • 77% (31)Always tender, crisp, and light. Served with lemon wedges and our famous Goodfella's sauce.
- Smoked Buratta$14.00Lightly smoked and served over a red pepper pesto, arugula, pine nuts, balsamic fig reduction
- Octopus Carpaccio$20.00Octopus sliced thin and garnished with olives, capers, balsamic fig reduction.
- Homemade Mozzarella, Tomato, & Basil$14.00 • 100% (6)Thick slices of fresh mozzarella and fresh tomato, with a garnish of basil and a drizzle of our seasoned olive oil.
- Stuffed Long Hots (2)$14.00Long hots stuffed with sweet Italian sausage and smoked mozzarella, baked with marinara and fresh mozzarella.
- Mussels Marinara Appetizer$18.00 • 83% (6)An lb. of cultured mussels sauteed with garlic, sherry wine, and plum tomato strips.
- Goodfella's Baked Clams (10)$16.00 • 63% (11)A dozen beautifully baked clams served with fresh lemon wedges.
- Stuffed Mushrooms$12.00 • 100% (7)
- Homemade Garlic Bread$5.00 • 92% (66)
- Goodfella's Buffalo-Style Chicken Wings (6)$12.00 • 85% (28)Delightfully seasoned and spicy.Spicy
- Homemade Mozzarella and Carrozza (4 pcs)$14.00 • 90% (20)Fresh mozzarella cheese between two pieces of bread, breaded, and lightly fried. Served with marinara sauce.
- Chicken Fingers$10.00 • 33% (9)A great starter for the kids. Served with honey mustard.
- Fried Zucchini Sticks$12.00 • 66% (6)
- Bruschetta$10.00Diced tomato, onion, herbs, and garlic marinated with extra virgin olive oil. Served over grilled garlic toast.
- Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (3)$15.003 jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce and horseradish.
Soup and Salad
- Goodfella's House Salad$10.00 • 95% (23)Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
- Strawberry Mesclun Salad$13.00 • 100% (7)Fresh mesclun greens with strawberries, sliced almonds, and homemade mozzarella tossed with honey balsamic.
- Our Famous Lobster Bisque Soup$9.00 • 73% (15)Delicious bits of lobster in an incredible cream bisque.
Dinner Pasta
Dinner Entrees
Specialty Pizzas
Italian Heroes and Wraps
Brick Oven Pizzas
Goodfella's Sides
Children's Menu
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•800+ Ratings •
37 Reviews
Joanne B.• 05/25/24Excellent
Gen B.• 05/13/24great dish
Vito D.• 05/11/24Very good glad the prices came down to earth finally
Randy W.• 04/27/24very good food & service
RAYMOND C.• 03/29/24Always good service , very good food & the bet Italian bread ,friendly staff when we dine it. Great cocktails also , Clean establishment
Beth O.• 03/23/24Exactly what I ordered
Francesca C.• 03/23/24Good pizza
Vincent M.• 03/21/24Great taste fresh ingredients made to order how I wanted it. Huge score 8.8 out of 10 and in the real deal at scoring
Marina G.• 03/12/24Our favorite Italian restaurant! Great menu!
Nick J.• 03/09/24Old world pie is phenomenal!
RAYMOND C.• 03/08/24Very good pizza. Thin & crispy as always made perfect.
Hector N.• 02/17/24food Was good
Jordan C.• 02/14/24Pizza was amazing
Bonnie S.• 02/04/24Food exceeded my expectations. The calamari was nicely battered and crisp. The pasta was perfectly seasoned and the portions were very decent.
RAYMOND C.• 01/24/24Great tasting chicken parm & pizza. All their food is delicious. Always a pleasure when we dine in or order to go
Jennifer L.• 01/01/24Always quality ingredients!!
JOEL K.• 12/24/23really good pizza
John G.• 12/09/23Good value for good quality
Inna R.• 12/06/23Great food
Nicholas D.• 12/05/23Pizza is genuinely amazing, some of the best in NYC. Best buffalo chicken and vodka pies I’ve had.
Jonathan C.• 12/03/23Delicious
nick P.• 11/30/23Pizza was great
Matt S.• 11/27/23The flavors were great
Mark H.• 11/16/23The best brick oven on the island
Bella S.• 11/06/23Amazing
Lila K.• 10/07/23Great customer service & delicious food!!
Colleen A.• 10/01/23favorite
Briana M.• 08/24/23Best GF pizza on Staten Island!
MICHAEL V.• 08/19/23The bick oven pizza has the best sauce ive had in a long time.
Hue W.• 08/12/23Everything is delicious, freshly made and well packaged. I ordered many times and they never failed to impress. Thank you Goodfella!
Danny D.• 07/12/23Classic place 💯
Chris C.• 04/03/23I was like an uppercut of pure flavor.
Chris C.• 03/06/23Their vodka sauce knocked me senseless in the best way
Toni C.• 03/04/23Astonishingly good!
Toni C.• 02/25/23They make interesting pies that tastes great! The dough is nicely aged. Avoid the lobster bisque. There's no lobster in it.
Arleen Bob K.• 04/11/22Great food, came hot and was delicious. Highly recommend.
Omar P.• 08/28/21Great pizza
