4.5
1000+ Ratings
Supreme Bakery
4.5 x (1,000+) • 12632.1 km • Bakery • Desserts • American • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
40 Main St
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"What can I say? At the very last minute I needed a cake for my son’s birthday. I was able to order his favorite cake that only Supreme Bakery had. With only a few minutes to closing they still manage to get the cake to order out the door and delivered to my home. The cake taste delicious. This was a first and will surely NOT be the last time I use Supreme. Thank you"
• Gisela T. • 08/15/23
"thank you thank you thank you... my order came in as soon as they opened and they got it done very fast and accurately... I appreciate it"
• DANIELLE P. • 02/06/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Monday - Saturday
7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Featured items
Supreme Large Cookies
Brownies & Squares
Layer Cakes
1/4 sheet cakes
Large Pastries
Assorted "4 Tarts
Mini Pastries
Cheesecake & Slices
Butter Cookies
Holiday Items
Holiday Items
- Rating and reviews
4.5
•1000+ Ratings •
58 Reviews
Richard A.• 05/23/24Best cannolies in the area!
Brianne O.• 04/09/24Easy experience from order through delivery!
Eric B.• 03/20/24good quality
Rosey M.• 03/14/24Great cupcakes
Shonda B.• 02/27/24Thank you so much for the beautiful personalization!
Bryan C.• 02/20/24chocolate was good boi
Blana M.• 02/16/24awesome cookies!
Jamillah R.• 01/11/24good
charlie A.• 01/10/24good cookie.
charlie A.• 01/09/24good cupcake.
Della M.• 01/01/24Crumb bun is the best
Andrea C.• 12/31/23There products is always fresh.
Andrea C.• 12/23/23great taste great service.
Joan K.• 11/23/23delicious cakes and pies
Sam T.• 11/10/23It was a hit
Willie M.• 11/04/23best strawberry shortcake slices
Simone C.• 10/25/23The cupcakes taste great and not expensive
Michael P.• 10/17/23Great dessert
Shayla G.• 09/30/23the best strawberry shortcake i've ever had. my boyfriend gets me one every year for my birthday!
Anna L.• 09/02/23Fresh, clean and tasty?
Brianna S.• 08/16/23Supreme Bakery has the best sweets ! Been coming there since I was a little girl. Classic pastries and cakes!
Gisela T.• 08/15/23What can I say? At the very last minute I needed a cake for my son’s birthday. I was able to order his favorite cake that only Supreme Bakery had. With only a few minutes to closing they still manage to get the cake to order out the door and delivered to my home. The cake taste delicious. This was a first and will surely NOT be the last time I use Supreme. Thank you
AlNisa S.• 07/27/23Tasty and fresh
Alberta D.• 07/27/23Beautiful birthday cake. It was delicious.
Gabby J.• 07/18/23Quick delivery and great cakes!
Willie M.• 07/12/23I love their individualized strawberry shortcake slices.
Tiffany D.• 07/04/23best cake in jersey
Valerie H.• 06/30/23Their baked goods are the BEST!!!
Khayri W.• 06/12/23It was baked just as I requested loved it
STEPHANY R.• 06/07/23They were so kind and added customization just as I asked! Delivered cake right on time.
June C.• 06/07/23Tasty bake goods if my toddler loves it that means it taste great
Eram S.• 06/06/23Amazing cupcakes from birthday cup cake to red and blue velvet and the best softest cupcakes I’ve had in assorted
Kenneth H.• 05/30/23Very accommodating for my little boys birthday
Simone C.• 05/20/23I love their Oreo cake.There items are tastes and inexpensive
Chadd M.• 05/19/23Love the cupcakes. Fav bakery in Essex been going there for year's. Never dissapoints
Della M.• 05/19/23Love their crumb cake
Della M.• 04/23/23I love fresh baked things
linda P.• 04/20/23Cupcakes were delicious
Simone C.• 04/19/23The cupcakes are great I love their icing
Della M.• 04/11/23It's delicious
Della M.• 04/06/23They have the freshest bakery
Kim S.• 04/05/23The only bakery I go to for everything
Della M.• 03/12/23I love their crumb cake
Della M.• 02/22/23The best bakery
Emanuel O.• 02/19/23Quality is awesome, food is great! Highly recommend!!
DANIELLE P.• 02/06/23thank you thank you thank you... my order came in as soon as they opened and they got it done very fast and accurately... I appreciate it
Shiwanda A.• 01/21/23I love the fresh cupcakes and cakes my favorite bakery in New Jersey
Satin D.• 01/02/23because it was good
Kimberly G.• 12/03/22Always fresh and delicious!
Veronica S.• 11/25/22The red velvet and the chocolate muffins were delicious
Joan K.• 10/23/22Excellent
Raphael P.• 09/05/22Great tasting cake!
Elizabeth B.• 05/08/22Delicious!
Christine W.• 03/25/22The cupcake was good
Hubie D.• 09/29/21Awesome
JAMES K.• 09/17/21RED VELVET CAKE WAS MOIST & DELICIOUS
Larry M.• 09/11/21Thanks it made my friend day! 💪🏿👑
Inti B.• 07/25/21Fast and awesome treats
