4.9
130+ Ratings
Sundaes on Main
4.9 x (130+) • 2651.3 mi • Comfort Food • Desserts • Ice Cream • Info
2414 Montauk Highway
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"really nice and always really good. they make the orders feel special"
• david H. • 12/30/23
"Always TLC with order, and new things added. Try the Icebox Cake!!"
• Laura C. • 08/08/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
12:05 PM - 11:00 PM
Monday - Thursday
12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Featured items
Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream
- ToppingsPriced by add-ons • 60% (5)If you'd like to add toppings to your fro-yo!
- Pineapple Dole Whip Straight Up 12oz$12.99 • 100% (6)The name says it all ;)
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product. - Pineapple Creamsicle 12oz$12.9912oz of Pineapple Creamsicle - it's a must try as it holds the title of best seller! A twist of Dole Pineapple and Velvety Vanilla Ice Cream.
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.Popular - Traditionalist, Vanilla Ice Cream with Rainbow Sprinkles$14.9912oz of Plain Ol' Vanilla along with a cup of rainbow sprinkles.
All our frozen yogurt cups come with the yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae.
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product. - Sundaes On Main Sundae$19.9912oz of Southampton Salted Caramel fro-yo along with cherry sauce, hot caramel, walnuts, chocolate sprinkles. Yum!
Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae.
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product. - Chocolate on Chocolate on Chocolate Ice Cream Sundae$17.99 • 100% (7)12oz of chocolate ice cream along with chocolate sprinkles, chocolate crunchies, chocolate chips and hot fudge. The more chocolate the better!
Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae.
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product. - Pup Cup, Vanilla Ice Cream$5.99 • 100% (3)Don't forget about a treat for your pup! 4oz of vanilla ice cream topped with a milk bone dog biscuit & drizzled with peanut butter.
- Backyard Dirt Cup Sundae$18.99 • 100% (3)Make your kids happy with this one as it's a kid favorite. 12oz of Plain Ol' Vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate cookie crunchies, hot fudge & squiggly, wiggly gummy worms.
Cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae!
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product. - **Caramel Frozen Yogurt Turtle Sundae$17.99 • 100% (3)12oz cup of caramel frozen yogurt, along with hot fudge, chopped almonds and miniature caramel filled chocolate turtles. So CUTE!
Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae.
Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae!
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product. - Mystery Grab Frozen Dessert$5.99 • 100% (3)12oz of randomly selected frozen yogurt flavors.
Please note these cups may contain nuts, peanuts, milk, eggs, wheat. If you have an allergy to any of the above, we would suggest avoiding this offer.
This offer includes just the yogurt, toppings sold separately.
Flavors will be chosen at random.
Some flavors contain gluten, nuts, peanuts, milk, eggs.
We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product. - Mini Sundaes 6oz$6.99
- Neopolitan Sundae$10.99Vanilla & Chocolate Cream & Strawberry Sorbet along with hot fudge and mini Swedish Fish.
- Alana’s Sundae$15.9912oz of Fat Free Montauk Mint fro-yo is sandwiched between two very generous servings of rainbow sprinkles (on the top & bottom of cup) then topped with crushed Reese’s peanut butter cups.
Candy
- Laffy Taffy Mystery Flavors$3.25
- Cinnamon Yogurt & Honey Graham Pretzels$5.99
- Laffy Taffy Blue-Raspberry$3.25
- Pop Rocks Watermelon$2.75Popular
- Candy Mystery Grab Bag$8.99A mystery of candy awaits you!Popular
- Salt Water Taffy Bowl$11.99Assorted flavors of salt water taffy in a 11oz bowl, flavors chosen at random..
- Chocolate Covered Cherry Marshmallow Twists$6.99Popular
Drinks
Desserts
- Rating and reviews
4.9
•130+ Ratings •
17 Reviews
Laura C.• 04/23/24Always reliable and attention to detail. Packaged to travel well!
valorie A.• 04/08/24Great packaging and delicious flavor, love this place
JESS R.• 03/25/24One of my favorite spots.
Rylee F.• 03/03/24“my fav ice cream place”
david H.• 12/30/23really nice and always really good. they make the orders feel special
Tricia O.• 11/22/23Delicious!!!!!
Belinda B.• 10/17/23The BEST!!!
Tina A.• 10/12/23Their froyo is amazing
Jeanie S.• 08/18/23The creamiest Fro-yo and ice-cream around. I have a cup everyday.
Laura C.• 08/08/23Always TLC with order, and new things added. Try the Icebox Cake!!
Julie R.• 08/03/23Everything about it. The packaging is the icing on the cake.
Dorian B.• 07/28/23Great experience and thoughtful
Michelle W.• 07/09/23Delicious frozen yogurt
Lianne H.• 06/23/23Yummy
Rae K.• 06/14/23Best flavors and assortment of candy in the Hamptons!
Taylor K.• 03/08/23Amazing frozen yogurt and candy
THOMAS S.• 01/29/23Creamiest, tastiest Fro-Yo around!!
