Too far to deliver
Strong Island Ice Cream
View delivery time and booking fee.
Location and hours
| Every Day | ||
| 01:00 PM - 09:30 PM |
Wondering what's the best thing on the menu? The banana split is one of the most popular items among the 51 things on the menu and the 2 scoop sundae and the double chocolate chip are two of the items most commonly ordered together at this evening go-to. • ₩ • Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • Comfort Food • Desserts • Allergy Friendly
127 Smithtown Blvd , Suite 19, Nesconset, NY 11767 • More
Picked for you
- 2 Scoop SundaeComes with whipped cream, 1 topping of your choice, and a cherry.$9.50
- Brownie SundaeComes with 2 scoops, a brownie, whipped cream, and a cherry.$11.50
- Milkshakes (22 0z)22 ounces.$9.50
- Cookie SundaeComes with a warmed cookie, whipped cream, and a cherry.$11.50
- Banana SplitComes with a banana, whipped cream, one topping, and a cherry.$11.50
Flavors
- Banana$5.50
- Black Raspberry$5.50
- Burgundy Cherry$5.50
- Butter Pecan$5.50
- Cake Batter$5.50
- Chocolate$5.50
- Chocolate Peanut Butter$5.50
- Coffee$5.50
- Cookie Dough$5.50
- Cookies and Cream$5.50
- Cotton Candy$5.50
- Dark Chocolate$5.50
- Double Chocolate Chip$5.50
- Maple Walnut$5.50
- Mint Chip$5.50
- Nutella$5.50
- Orange Sherbet$5.50
- Peach$5.50
- Peanut Butter Cup$5.50
- Pistachio$5.50
- Rainbow Cookie$5.50
- Rocky Road$5.50
- Rum Raisin$5.50
- Salted Caramel$5.50
- Strawberry$5.50
- Vanilla$5.50
- Vanilla Chip$5.50
- S'mores$5.50
- Fluffernutter$5.50
- Non-Dairy Acai Raspberry$6.50
- Non-Dairy Mango$6.50
- Vegan Chocolate$6.50
- Vegan Vanilla$6.50
- Vegan Pistachio$6.50
- Cherry Italian Ice$5.50
- Lemon Italian Ice$5.50
- Tropical Rainbow Italian Ice$5.50
- Rice Krispie Treat$5.50
- Coconut$5.50
Homemade Chocolates
- Chocolate Chip Cookie$3.00
- Mint Ice Cream TrufflesMint chip ice cream coated with chocolate on the outside and fudge in the middle.$5.50
- Chocolate Dipped Pretzels2 pretzels per bag$3.99
- Chocolate Chip BrownieChocolate brownie with chocolate chips$3.00
- Rocky Road BrownieChocolate brownie with peanut butter chips and walnuts$3.00
- Dark Chocolate Raspberry JelliesDark chocolate infused with raspberry jelly inside$14.00
- Dark Chocolate Cordial CherriesDark chocolate with cordial cherries inside$14.00
- Dark Chocolate Almond Bark$14.00
- Nonpareils$14.00
- Butter Crunch$14.00
- Chocolate Covered Pretzels3 Pretzels covered in chocolate$5.50
Sundaes
- Banana SplitComes with a banana, whipped cream, one topping, and a cherry.$11.50
- Wet Walnut DelightComes with wet walnuts, whipped cream, and a cherry.$11.50
- Brownie SundaeComes with 2 scoops, a brownie, whipped cream, and a cherry.$11.50
- Mini Waffle SundaeOne mini waffle. one scoop ice cream, one topping, whipped cream, and cherry.$11.50
- Waffle SundaeWith whipped cream, one topping, and cherry.$15.99
- Cookie SundaeComes with a warmed cookie, whipped cream, and a cherry.$11.50
- 1 Scoop SundaeComes with whipped cream, 1 topping of your choice and a cherry.$7.50
- 2 Scoop SundaeComes with whipped cream, 1 topping of your choice, and a cherry.$9.50
- Pound Cake Sundae2 scoops ice cream, whipped cream, and a cherry.$11.50
- Acai Bowl2 scoops of acai raspberry sorbet, granola, strawberries, bananas, and blueberries. You may write in the notes if you want a topping (nutella or peanut butter).$11.00
- Doggy Ice CreamThis ice cream is 100% safe for dogs to enjoy while you enjoy your ice cream too!$8.50
Extra Toppings
- Rainbow Sprinkles (1/2 lb )$2.75
- Oreo's (1/4 lb)$2.75
- Chocolate Sprinkles (1/2 lb )$2.75
- Gummy Bears (1/2 lb )$2.99
- Peanuts (1/2 lb)$2.99
Milkshakes
- Milkshakes (22 0z)22 ounces.$9.50
- Peanut Butter & Jelly Milkshake$10.50
Cones
- Wafer Cone$2.00
- Waffle Cone$2.00
- Sugar Cone$2.00
- Waffle Bowl$2.00
- Dipped Waffle Bowl w/ SprinklesWaffle Bowl dipped in chocolate and covered with rainbow sprinkles$3.00
- Dipped Waffle Cone w/ SprinklesWaffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with rainbow sprinkles$3.00
- Dipped Waffle Cone w/ PeanutsWaffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with peanuts$3.00
- Dipped Wafer Cone w/ SprinklesWafer Cone dipped in chocolate and covered in rainbow sprinkles$2.50
Mariah M. • 8/7/2020
Tried Strong Island Ice Cream for the first time tonight and am super impressed! Note it's cash only which was definitely annoying as we had to pay $3 at the bank next door to take out money.
I'm just a simple chocolate ice cream girl but WOW this was delicious! You can totally tell it...
Phil H. • 20/7/2021
Delicious ice cream here!
Soft and creamy and the flavors really stand out!
Fluffernutter, Butter Pecan, Burgundy Cherry, all terrific. So many flavors to choose from.
Nice shop. Large, bright, airy, clean. Good 80's music playing. Friendly staff. A bit pricey but so worth it for quality homemade ice cream.
Cash only and it says...
Erica L. • 24/12/2019
The ice cream is good! I got a pint of Cookies and cream, conveniently located in one of the freezers when you first walk in. The inside of the store is BRIGHT!
The price is good, the ice cream is 100% better than Ralph's.
Customer service was non existent.
William H. • 26/8/2020
Had me a Mint Chip 2 scoop cone. First of all, the safety precautions in this restaurant were great, with masks being required as well as required hand sanitizer usage. The ice cream was amazing! It tasted like spearmint, and was very unique and original! When I go to the thrift store next door, I...
Lucy A. • 26/3/2021
I think anyone who thinks this ice cream is good should compare it to the ice cream shop in Stonybrook Village. Now that is delicious ice cream and Strong Island Ice Cream is horrendous in comparison. Over-priced but I don't mind paying for quality. I wouldn't eat it again if it were free.
Also, the...
Mas F. • 23/1/2021
Went here with my husband to grab some ice cream. The ice cream was okay, nothing amazing but still good. We were a little weirded out by owner. We overheard him reprimand the customer before us, on ordering shakes after the ice cream. Then we ordered two items, 1 scoop on cone and 2 scoops...
