4.6
1500+ Ratings
Sexton’s Pizza 8.1 (Gahanna)
4.6 x (1,500+) • Pizza • American • Italian • Info
x Delivered by store staff
x Not accepting orders
943 East Johnstown Road, Gahanna, OH 43230
Rating and reviews
"I’m absolutely in love with the Kevin Bacon! Sexton’s offers what they call a “New York” style crust. I’m originally from Connecticut, and this is the closest I’ve had to a “New Haven” style pie since I’ve been in Columbus. The amazing char, flavor, and texture of the crust reminds me of Sally’s or Modern. All of the ingredients seem to be very high quality, and delicious! This place is a real gem, I can’t recommend Sexton’s enough!"
• Rich F. • 12/15/23
"Sexton's pizza ranks with the best pizza places in NYC. It is just in a different league than any other places in the greater Columbus area. From the dough, to the cooking method, to quality control.. I rarely take the time to do a review but I happily wait an hour for this delivery."
• ryan P. • 08/10/23
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
12:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Monday - Thursday
3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:30 AM - 10:00 PM
Featured items
Specialty Pizza
12" Cauliflower Crust
Extra Sauces
CupCakes
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•1500+ Ratings •
59 Reviews
ERDEM K.• 10/27/25Great pizza. Unfortunately the order came from a store located 3 times further than the closest store from our house and the wait was longer. But it was worth the wait.
David S.• 10/26/25Really good pizza - great crust
Dale R.• 01/19/25Best pizza in town!!!!
Lisa T.• 12/09/24The pizza was excellent!
V S.• 11/26/24Love it. Don’t forget the fresh mozz.
Sean C.• 11/17/24good pizza
Kristin K.• 09/21/24Phenomenal pizza! Chewy crust and awesome toppings! LOVED it!
Edwin R.• 09/14/24Fresh and tasty pizza
connie O.• 09/08/24We luv their pizza... Sadly several times we placed an order it states the order is prepared & shows us the driver shows up then bam our order gets canceled... but the pizza is delicious if you get lucky and it gets delivered.
Robert L.• 07/08/24Best Detroit style in the 614
James W.• 07/06/24Amazing
Bryant T.• 07/04/24good portion
JASON W.• 06/20/24Pizza is awesome.
DEBRA C.• 06/18/24Love presentation,texture and taste of the pizza crust, Cheese baked perfectly.
JEFFERY B.• 05/20/24best pizza I've ever had
Molly S.• 04/29/24Absolutely delicious pizza! Definitely will order again!!
Joe P.• 04/25/24Great service
CODY C.• 04/16/24great pizza
Tiara T.• 03/24/24the pizza is so good!
Peter L.• 02/26/24Great
Amy M.• 02/24/24AMAZING
Wes B.• 02/23/24One of Columbus’s best pizzas without a doubt!
Guillermo D.• 01/24/24Great pizza. I’m from NYC and glad I found Sextons. They legit.
Tiffany M.• 01/21/24Great “MIKE!”
Melissa K.• 01/17/24I seriously think this is the best pizza I’ve ever tasted in my life!!! So excited to find authentic NY style pizza in the Columbus area!
James B.• 01/04/24The best pizza in Columbus
Rich F.• 12/15/23I’m absolutely in love with the Kevin Bacon! Sexton’s offers what they call a “New York” style crust. I’m originally from Connecticut, and this is the closest I’ve had to a “New Haven” style pie since I’ve been in Columbus. The amazing char, flavor, and texture of the crust reminds me of Sally’s or Modern. All of the ingredients seem to be very high quality, and delicious! This place is a real gem, I can’t recommend Sexton’s enough!
Meredith T.• 11/25/23So yummy!!
Archie N.• 11/14/23darn good Pizza, I want them to open more branches
Nathan R.• 11/09/23Always a great pizza to get!
Christin K.• 10/02/23The best traditional New York style pizza I've had since moving to Columbus!!
Katie K.• 09/27/23Great variety of pizza! Super delicious
Katie W.• 09/05/23Delicious
lori K.• 08/24/23Absolutely delicious!!!!!! Hats off Sexton Pizza;
Trevor H.• 08/17/23Get the Kevin bacon! Beet pizza around. Currently eating their ranch w a spoon.
david D.• 08/12/23Great crust and sauce is perfect.
ryan P.• 08/10/23Sexton's pizza ranks with the best pizza places in NYC. It is just in a different league than any other places in the greater Columbus area. From the dough, to the cooking method, to quality control.. I rarely take the time to do a review but I happily wait an hour for this delivery.
Michael L.• 08/10/23Best pizza in Columbus imo. Quality ingredients, wood fired
Lauren G.• 08/06/23So so so good! Get the ranch!
Alisa R.• 08/05/23Really delish!
Jeffery J.• 07/25/23Honestly the best pizza I have ever had. Nice work
Chad K.• 07/24/23Best pizza on the North side of Cbus
Dustin L.• 07/16/23Always very good pizza. Give them a try.
Matthew R.• 07/13/23Great fresh ingredients, made with pride
MASON L.• 07/13/23Best pizza in Columbus hands down not even close
Gibran B.• 07/07/23Great pizza all around
TRia B.• 06/19/23Perfectly charred, amazing taste with a nice crisp pizza. Ranch side has a sweetness to it I can’t explain but I need it with my pizza.
Christina S.• 06/18/23best pizza in gahanna by far, only place we go anymore
Danielle G.• 06/09/23Amazing!
Matthew P.• 06/07/23Best Pizza in Columbus
Robert M.• 05/19/23Great pizza every time!
Debra F.• 05/01/23This is the best pizza I have ever ate
Billie G.• 04/29/23it was yummy
Ann H.• 04/19/23Amazing pizza! So refreshing to find good pizza. It’s harder and harder anymore. Great quality and taste. Driver was late and it was cold and still amazing. ❤️
SHANI M.• 03/27/23"I got the ""Kevin Bacon"" omg so good! Candied Bacon on pizza!?! idk why no one else has thought of this! absolutely delicious "
Justin V.• 11/26/22Love it
Paul A.• 08/18/22Amazing pizza
Brian K.• 08/03/22One of our favs!
Elizabeth A.• 08/01/22Nice n hot 🔥
