4.5
1000+ Ratings
Setauket Pastaria
4.5 x (1,000+) • Pizza • Seafood • Salads • Pasta • $ • Info
x Available at 9:30 AM
x Delivered by store staff
4082 Nesconset Hwy, East Setauket, NY 11733
Rating and reviews
"Food came hot and was one of the best Sunday Italian dinners we have ever had. Very reasonable pricing and will just rock your world overall. New customer for life."
• Michael N. • 03/04/24
"Pizza was delicious and delivered on time and Maxim was courteous and took care of the pie - cheese was on the pizza nowhere on the box!!! 😊"
• Christina L. • 03/02/25
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
10:00 AM - 9:45 PM
Friday - Saturday
9:30 AM - 9:45 PM
Appetizers
Gluten-Free Appetizers
Soups
Salads
Gluten-Free Salad
Heros
Create Your Own Personal Pie
Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Specialty Pies
Gluten-Free Pizza
Pasta Specials
Pastaria Pasta
Gluten-Free Pasta
Pastaria Delights
Vegetable
Gluten-Free Veal and Beef
Veal
Gluten-Free Eggplant
Chicken
Gluten-Free Chicken
Shrimp
Gluten-Free Seafood
Side Orders
Gluten-Free Side Dishes
Desserts
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.5
•1000+ Ratings •
18 Reviews
Pamela F.• 08/01/25The food is very good and arrived hot.
Christina L.• 03/02/25Pizza was delicious and delivered on time and Maxim was courteous and took care of the pie - cheese was on the pizza nowhere on the box!!! 😊
Susan D.• 11/03/24Always fresh. Tastes delicious
Virginia L.• 08/04/24Best Francese in town!
John M.• 05/31/24Very professional. Delivered to my hands!
Roseann N.• 04/10/24Always come through with great food
Michael N.• 03/04/24Food came hot and was one of the best Sunday Italian dinners we have ever had. Very reasonable pricing and will just rock your world overall. New customer for life.
Melissa R.• 02/20/24Pizza was great!
Denise A.• 12/16/23Delicious food!!! ✌🏻♥️
Elizabeth F.• 08/11/23The slices are big and the speciality slices are amazing
Tara C.• 07/18/23Love Setauket Pastaria
Karolina B.• 07/09/23Tasty hot and fresh
Christopher T.• 02/25/23Some of the best pizza on LI and good staff. Delicious Zepoles and Calzones always available!
Edward L.• 03/11/22Always hot and delicious
Timothy H.• 11/14/21Such a great dinner!
William O.• 09/17/21Amazing food
Jae B.• 08/23/21Delicious
Steven S.• 08/22/21Delicious
