4.6
700+ Ratings
Possum Holler Pizza
4.6 x (700+) • Pizza • American • Italian • Info
x Delivered by store staff
x No delivery people nearby
1874 Lisle Avenue, Obetz, OH 43207
Rating and reviews
"Great Pizza! The only thing that's better than the pizza is the quality, attention to detail and consistency. We've ordered multiple times and the food is always top notch and they ALWAYS make sure that we receive everything we ordered🏆"
• Jennifer K. • 09/25/24
"Delicious pie maybe could use one more minute for the bottom but nothing to complain about just preference. Love this pie though 2nd time trying it kind of reminds me of old school M&S in a way, kind of a Columbus nostalgic taste."
• Ricky E. • 03/07/25
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
Monday
4:00 PM - 10:30 PM
Tuesday - Thursday
10:00 AM - 10:30 PM
Friday
10:00 AM - 11:30 PM
Saturday
1:00 PM - 11:30 PM
Subs
Salads
Sauces
Cold Drinks
Build Your Own
Specialty Pizzas
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•700+ Ratings •
42 Reviews
Josh C.• 12/09/25Yaaaay pizza
Carrie K.• 12/03/25Freaking Delicious
Courtney H.• 11/19/25They put amazing amount of toppings on our pizza every time!
Lenita B.• 11/01/25Possum Holler is one of\nour families favorite pizza places.
Delana P.• 11/01/25Great pizza!!!!
Joey L.• 07/19/25Flavor is outstanding!
Eric H.• 07/17/25Was hot and delicious
Theresa I.• 06/06/25Soooooo good!
Amber P.• 05/30/25Great taste looked great, the medical staff loved it.\nThank you
Matthew F.• 04/04/25The BBQ chicken pizza was delicious.
Wes C.• 03/31/25Great pizza definitely not that fast food same ole pizza
Amber S.• 03/27/25Definitely the best pizza in town, although they sometimes forget the sauce.
abelraef• 03/08/25It's good to great every time, every item.
Ricky E.• 03/07/25Delicious pie maybe could use one more minute for the bottom but nothing to complain about just preference. Love this pie though 2nd time trying it kind of reminds me of old school M&S in a way, kind of a Columbus nostalgic taste.
Ej S.• 02/27/25Pizza was amazing Sub was delicious cooked just right !! Go get some!!!
Derek K.• 02/19/25Garlic bread with cheese is so good. Old world pepperoni is loaded with pepperonis and the chef salad is perfect!
Douglas D.• 01/21/25Fantastic Grinders!!! Reasonable price!!!
Chris D.• 01/01/25I just had to try the old world pizza, it was really good.
Frankie T.• 12/04/24Excellent food
Shawn R.• 12/01/24old world pepperoni is the best, and the Bosco sticks.
Debra A.• 11/22/24great
Michele D.• 11/21/24Hands down one of the BEST pizzas places I've found!! Their food is always fresh, tastes amazing, and never disappoints!!
Sidney H.• 11/14/24good food
Precious M.• 10/24/24Great as always!! Thank you
David V.• 10/20/24Good guy, grate service!
Brianne D.• 10/18/24Yummy old world pep pizza.
Nicole L.• 10/04/24Food looks awesome
Michelle P.• 10/03/24Foods were fresh, that sauce is so delicious...I can tell it's homemade...I'm trying to figure out all the herbs and spices I'm tasting...hummm
Jennifer K.• 09/25/24Great Pizza! The only thing that's better than the pizza is the quality, attention to detail and consistency. We've ordered multiple times and the food is always top notch and they ALWAYS make sure that we receive everything we ordered🏆
Sherrecka D.• 09/23/24amazing
Donna lee E.• 09/08/24great
Ashlee H.• 08/13/24Great pizza. Quick delivery. Would recommend and will be ordering again. 10/10
Brian L.• 07/20/24Always timely and delicious
Tashina K.• 07/07/24We got the regular cheese and opossum combo pizza, both were great! Definitely tastes more homemade than the corporate/chain pizzas. The opossum was LOADED with toppings. Will go back soon!!
tonya E.• 07/03/24great
Keith T.• 06/28/24great food
ELIJAH P.• 06/09/24Awesome old world style pep and cheese!
Shellie C.• 06/07/24very good
Mark F.• 05/29/24Good pizza
Tre C.• 05/21/24Good food
Daisy D.• 04/28/24Great pizza , glad we tried it.
Zachery S.• 04/24/24Pizza is always good here, have never had any issues
