4.8
1500+ Ratings
Pizza by Lucilles
4.8 x (1,500+) • 5743.7 km • Pizza • American • Italian • € • Info
x Delivery unavailable
Tap for hours, info, and more
26C Macombs Pl
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"Seriously, their square slice “Supreme Pepperoni” pizza is probably the best pizza in all of NYC. I cannot get enough of it!!!!!!"
• Devin C. • 12/12/23
"nothing beats it in the area...up there with some of the best ive had in the city...hidden gem i wouls say"
• geraldo U. • 12/18/22
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday - Wednesday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Thursday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
Featured items
Pies
- Lg Classic pie$22.00 • 92% (515)18nch 8pc New York City style sauce & cheese pizza
- Lg Margherita pie$26.00 • 91% (49)18 inch 8pc pie made with Lucilles Homemade Fresh mozzarella cheese, marinara, fresh basil and extra-virgin olive oil
- Lg Vokda Pie$28.00Vodka sauce topped off with Lucille’s Homemade Fresh Mozzarella and parm.
- Lg Bianca pie$28.00Lucille's homemade fresh mozzarella , ricotta and parmesan cheese. Topped with extra virgin olive oil,
- Lg MVP pie$28.00 • 100% (4)Marinara, Vodka-sauce, Pesto sauce and Homemade Fresh Mozzarella and parm.
Squares
- SUPREME square$27.00 • 95% (109)12x9" 6pc Spicy Uptown Pepperoni. mozzarella, spicy garlic tomato sauce , extra chard crispy roni cups & parm on our square style pizza (comes well-done)
- Grandma square$19.00 • 81% (116)12x9" 6pc Cooked down Homemade tomato sauce topped with Lucille’s Fresh Homemade Mozzarella and Basil.
- Buffalo Chicken square$24.00 • 77% (40)12x9" 6pc Fried breaded popcorn Chicken, blue cheese, hot sauce, Mozzarella & Scallions.
- Vodka Sauce square$21.00 • 94% (69)12x9" 6pc creamier style tomato Vodka sauce topped off with Lucille’s Homemade Fresh Mozzarella.
- MVP square$22.00 • 94% (58)12x9" 6pc Marinara, Vodka-sauce, Pesto sauce and Homemade Fresh Mozzarella
- Meatball & Burrata square$25.00 • 96% (27)12by9" 6pc All Beef Meatball lathered in a Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce set over Burrata cheese that’s spread and melted over our square style pizza finished with Provolone & Basil.
- Sausage Peppers square$24.00 • 92% (13)12x9" 6pc Sweet Italian sausage , red peppers and Homemade fresh mozzarella on a base of tomato sauce.
- Broc-Rabe Sausage square$24.00 • 81% (22)12x9" 6pc Broccoli-Rabe and Sweet Italian Sausage on a base of creamy Béchamel topped with Lucille’s Fresh Homemade Mozzarella and Fennel set on our square style pizza.
- Veggie Pesto square$22.00 • 92% (13)12x9" 6pc Pesto pizza with cherry tomatoes, black olives, peppers and homemade fresh mozzarella.
- Artichoke square$22.00 • 100% (7)12x9" 6pc Creamy spinach ricotta sauce, artichoke, fresh mozzarella and parmesan.
- Bianca square$22.00 • 100% (4)12x9" 6pc All cheese no sauce pie. Mozzarella (fresh & low moisture) Ricotta and Parm drizzle Extra virgin olive oil
- Arthur Ave square$24.00 • 100% (4)12x9" 6pc Sweet Italian sausage , peppers, onions, pepperoncini Homemade fresh mozzarella, parmesan and olive oil
- Mushrooms & Peas Square$22.00Mushrooms, shaved asparagus, fresh homemade mozzarella over a sweet pea & carrots sauce, finished with Parmesan.
Frozen Square Pizza
- Frozen Grandma$18.0012by9" Cooked down Homemade tomato sauce topped with Lucille’s Fresh Homemade Mozzarella and Basil.
Frozen instructions
1. Set oven rack to middle position and preheat oven to 450°F.
2. While still frozen remove pizza from shrink wrap & let thaw
3. Place pizza on middle rack
4. Bake for 10-12 minutes or until cheese bubbles and crust is to desired crisp . - Frozen Roni Grandma$22.0012by9" Essentially our Grandma Square topped with Pepperoni parm and basil.
Frozen instructions
1. Set oven rack to middle position and preheat oven to 450°F.
2. While still frozen remove pizza from shrink wrap & let thaw
3. Place pizza on middle rack
4. Bake for 10-12 minutes or until cheese bubbles and crust is to desired crisp .
Jumbo Wings 6pc
Add ons
dessert
Beverages
Vegan Squares
Round pies 12 inch
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•1500+ Ratings •
36 Reviews
Mariam L.• 05/23/24Always amazing, my favorite place!🩷🙌🫡
Omid G.• 05/19/24Amazing!!
Mariam L.• 04/27/24Amazing as always! Super fresh and yummmmmm!❤️🔥🩷🙌✨😋
Mariam L.• 04/26/24Best place to satisfy your pizza cravings! 🍕 🩷😋
Dawn M.• 04/26/24Great NYC style Pizza!
Mariam L.• 04/19/24Super yummy! Amazing Vegan option! Best vegan pizza periodtttt!!!!🩷🩷🩷🩷
Charles P.• 04/05/24Hands down the Best buffalo chicken wings around. Outstanding flavor and great price
Prince N.• 03/01/24Perfection!
Omid G.• 03/15/24Amazing
Maximo J.• 03/01/24Great taste
Olin J.• 02/22/24♥️♥️♥️♥️ so good!!
rachel B.• 02/20/24Finally can get great vegan pizza delivered
Olin J.• 01/22/24AMAZING!!!
Omid G.• 12/24/23The sauce and ingredients are sensational!!
M L.• 12/17/23Best pizza I’ve had in a minute!
Devin C.• 12/12/23Seriously, their square slice “Supreme Pepperoni” pizza is probably the best pizza in all of NYC. I cannot get enough of it!!!!!!
Ebony B.• 12/04/23Awesome sauce cooked perfectly with layers of sausage and cheese and meat.
Olin J.• 11/21/23Soooooo good !! ♥️♥️♥️♥️
Kyle I.• 09/29/23Lasagna is delicious
Wibo M.• 09/22/23Great
Jeremy G.• 09/06/23Very good Pizza, amazing tangy sauce.. I love this place.
Dawood S.• 09/05/23The best pizza and wings in harlem hands down
Kara T.• 08/15/23Best pizza in Harlem possibly even the whole city.
Brian S.• 06/28/23Great pizza.
Elena O.• 06/20/23Delicious & fast!
Teon M.• 06/16/23great pizza for our neighborhood
Dawood S.• 06/13/23Best tasting pizza in Harlem
Chacha R.• 03/27/23simply amazing!
Nadia Azza C.• 01/08/23Helped with order mistake. Very responsive
geraldo U.• 12/18/22nothing beats it in the area...up there with some of the best ive had in the city...hidden gem i wouls say
Aly T.• 04/27/22Oh my god delicious pizza uptown
Tracy H.• 03/07/22Made to my exact (picky) instructions, so very pleased.
Brandon F.• 12/05/21The Grandma pizza is always good. Just wish they still made the larger version!
Tracy H.• 12/04/21Fast, fresh and as I asked to be prepared.
Tracy H.• 12/04/21My order was to my exact specifications, fresh and still hot. So very satisfied. Thanks!
Carlos P.• 07/24/21Fantastico
