4.7
1500+ Ratings
Pizza by Lucilles
4.7 x (1,500+) • 2569.3 mi • Pizza • American • Italian • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
26C Macombs Pl
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Seriously, their square slice “Supreme Pepperoni” pizza is probably the best pizza in all of NYC. I cannot get enough of it!!!!!!"
• Devin C. • 12/12/23
"nothing beats it in the area...up there with some of the best ive had in the city...hidden gem i wouls say"
• geraldo U. • 12/18/22
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Wednesday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Thursday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
Featured items
Pies
- Lg Classic pie$22.00 • 92% (505)18nch 8pc New York City style sauce & cheese pizza
- Lg Margherita pie$26.00 • 91% (46)18 inch 8pc pie made with Lucilles Homemade Fresh mozzarella cheese, marinara, fresh basil and extra-virgin olive oil
- Lg Vokda Pie$28.00Vodka sauce topped off with Lucille’s Homemade Fresh Mozzarella and parm.
- Lg Bianca pie$28.00Lucille's homemade fresh mozzarella , ricotta and parmesan cheese. Topped with extra virgin olive oil,
- Lg MVP pie$28.00Marinara, Vodka-sauce, Pesto sauce and Homemade Fresh Mozzarella and parm.
Squares
- SUPREME square$27.00 • 95% (106)12x9" 6pc Spicy Uptown Pepperoni. mozzarella, spicy garlic tomato sauce , extra chard crispy roni cups & parm on our square style pizza (comes well-done)
- Grandma square$19.00 • 81% (115)12x9" 6pc Cooked down Homemade tomato sauce topped with Lucille’s Fresh Homemade Mozzarella and Basil.
- Buffalo Chicken square$24.00 • 77% (40)12x9" 6pc Fried breaded popcorn Chicken, blue cheese, hot sauce, Mozzarella & Scallions.
- Vodka Sauce square$21.00 • 94% (69)12x9" 6pc creamier style tomato Vodka sauce topped off with Lucille’s Homemade Fresh Mozzarella.
- MVP square$22.00 • 94% (58)12x9" 6pc Marinara, Vodka-sauce, Pesto sauce and Homemade Fresh Mozzarella
- Meatball & Burrata square$25.00 • 96% (27)12by9" 6pc All Beef Meatball lathered in a Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce set over Burrata cheese that’s spread and melted over our square style pizza finished with Provolone & Basil.
- Sausage Peppers square$24.00 • 100% (12)12x9" 6pc Sweet Italian sausage , red peppers and Homemade fresh mozzarella on a base of tomato sauce.
- Broc-Rabe Sausage square$24.00 • 81% (22)12x9" 6pc Broccoli-Rabe and Sweet Italian Sausage on a base of creamy Béchamel topped with Lucille’s Fresh Homemade Mozzarella and Fennel set on our square style pizza.
- Veggie Pesto square$22.00 • 92% (13)12x9" 6pc Pesto pizza with cherry tomatoes, black olives, peppers and homemade fresh mozzarella.
- Artichoke square$22.00 • 100% (7)12x9" 6pc Creamy spinach ricotta sauce, artichoke, fresh mozzarella and parmesan.
- Bianca square$22.00 • 100% (4)12x9" 6pc All cheese no sauce pie. Mozzarella (fresh & low moisture) Ricotta and Parm drizzle Extra virgin olive oil
- Arthur Ave square$24.00 • 100% (4)12x9" 6pc Sweet Italian sausage , peppers, onions, pepperoncini Homemade fresh mozzarella, parmesan and olive oil
- Mushrooms & Peas Square$22.00Mushrooms, shaved asparagus, fresh homemade mozzarella over a sweet pea & carrots sauce, finished with Parmesan.
Frozen Square Pizza
- Frozen Grandma$18.0012by9" Cooked down Homemade tomato sauce topped with Lucille’s Fresh Homemade Mozzarella and Basil.
Frozen instructions
1. Set oven rack to middle position and preheat oven to 450°F.
2. While still frozen remove pizza from shrink wrap & let thaw
3. Place pizza on middle rack
4. Bake for 10-12 minutes or until cheese bubbles and crust is to desired crisp . - Frozen Roni Grandma$22.0012by9" Essentially our Grandma Square topped with Pepperoni parm and basil.
Frozen instructions
1. Set oven rack to middle position and preheat oven to 450°F.
2. While still frozen remove pizza from shrink wrap & let thaw
3. Place pizza on middle rack
4. Bake for 10-12 minutes or until cheese bubbles and crust is to desired crisp .
Jumbo Wings 6pc
Add ons
dessert
Beverages
Vegan Squares
Round pies 12 inch
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•1500+ Ratings •
34 Reviews
Mariam L.• 04/27/24Amazing as always! Super fresh and yummmmmm!❤️🔥🩷🙌✨😋
Mariam L.• 04/26/24Best place to satisfy your pizza cravings! 🍕 🩷😋
Dawn M.• 04/26/24Great NYC style Pizza!
Mariam L.• 04/19/24Super yummy! Amazing Vegan option! Best vegan pizza periodtttt!!!!🩷🩷🩷🩷
Charles P.• 04/05/24Hands down the Best buffalo chicken wings around. Outstanding flavor and great price
Prince N.• 03/31/24Perfection!
Omid G.• 03/15/24Amazing
Maximo J.• 03/01/24Great taste
Olin J.• 02/22/24♥️♥️♥️♥️ so good!!
rachel B.• 02/20/24Finally can get great vegan pizza delivered
Olin J.• 01/22/24AMAZING!!!
Omid G.• 12/24/23The sauce and ingredients are sensational!!
M L.• 12/17/23Best pizza I’ve had in a minute!
Devin C.• 12/12/23Seriously, their square slice “Supreme Pepperoni” pizza is probably the best pizza in all of NYC. I cannot get enough of it!!!!!!
Ebony B.• 12/04/23Awesome sauce cooked perfectly with layers of sausage and cheese and meat.
Olin J.• 11/21/23Soooooo good !! ♥️♥️♥️♥️
Kyle I.• 09/29/23Lasagna is delicious
Wibo M.• 09/22/23Great
Jeremy G.• 09/06/23Very good Pizza, amazing tangy sauce.. I love this place.
Dawood S.• 09/05/23The best pizza and wings in harlem hands down
Kara T.• 08/15/23Best pizza in Harlem possibly even the whole city.
Brian S.• 06/28/23Great pizza.
Elena O.• 06/20/23Delicious & fast!
Teon M.• 06/16/23great pizza for our neighborhood
Dawood S.• 06/13/23Best tasting pizza in Harlem
Chacha R.• 03/27/23simply amazing!
Nadia Azza C.• 01/08/23Helped with order mistake. Very responsive
geraldo U.• 12/18/22nothing beats it in the area...up there with some of the best ive had in the city...hidden gem i wouls say
Aly T.• 04/27/22Oh my god delicious pizza uptown
Tracy H.• 03/07/22Made to my exact (picky) instructions, so very pleased.
Brandon F.• 12/05/21The Grandma pizza is always good. Just wish they still made the larger version!
Tracy H.• 12/04/21Fast, fresh and as I asked to be prepared.
Tracy H.• 12/04/21My order was to my exact specifications, fresh and still hot. So very satisfied. Thanks!
Carlos P.• 07/24/21Fantastico
