4.5
200+ Ratings
Pie Five Pizza (Nicholasville Rd)
4.5 x (200+) • 2053.4 mi • Pizza • Wings • Salads • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
3401 Nicholasville Rd, Lexington, KY 40503, USA
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"I’ve had loads of pizzas across America and until now New York pizza spots were always my favorites. But now Pie Five Pizza on Nicholasville Road in Lexington KY has taken the top prize! Their Old World Maggie pizza with Parmesan crunch stuffed crust is a taste of HEAVEN!"
• David G. • 10/08/23
"Had a delicious pizza with pepperoni, feta and garlic! Was still warm when it arrived. Delivery was great! Will order again!"
• Joy W. • 02/27/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
11:00 AM - 6:45 PM
Monday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 8:45 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:45 PM
Featured items
Buy 3 Pizzas, Get 4th Pizza FREE
Buy 3 personal pizzas, get the 4th pizza FREE (offer valid for only personal pizzas in this group)Personal Pizzas
- Build Your Own Pizza (Special Promo)$12.99 • 89% (91)Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and up to 5 toppings.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Cheese Pizza$10.09 • 440 - 1280 Cal.signature flavor combination of crust / sauce / mozzarella
- High Five-Meat$12.99 • 100% (8) • 990 - 1560 Cal.tuscan marinara / mozzarella / pepperoni / italian sausage / bacon / Canadian bacon / beef
- NEW Old World Maggie$12.99 • 100% (3) • 860 - 1430 Cal.Named after our longest standing employee, this old school margherita boasts fresh mozzarella, olive oil, grape tomatoes, and fresh basil[ fresh mozzarella / tuscan marinara / olive oil / tomatoes / parmesan / fresh basil ]
- NEW Mike's Sticky Fingers$12.99 • 950 - 1550 Cal.spicy marinara / mozzarella / pepperoni / curl and crisp pepperoni / fresh basil / Mike's Hot Honey®
- NEW Gaucho Steak$12.99 • 940 - 1510 Cal.Rustic flavors born in the La Pampa grass-lands and beloved as sandwiches on the streets of Argentina make up this little steak-centric piece of heaven[ marinated steak / mozzarella / roasted red peppers / parmesan / red onion / mushrooms/ tomatoes / fresh basil / lawry's casero seasoning / olive oil & garlic / parsley ]
- NEW Five-Alarm Fire$12.99 • 740 - 1310 Cal.Brace yourself for our signature inferno sauce - a blistering blend of yellowbird ghost pepper sauce & mike's hot honey - and marinated inferno sausage.[ signature inferno sauce with mike's hot honey / ghost pepper marinated italian sausage / curl & crisp pepperoni / mozzarella / fresh jalapeno slices / red onions / tomatoes ]
- NEW Not Your Father's Veggie$12.99 • 740 - 1310 Cal.Step aside pops, the new school veggie pizza isn't for the blue-haired crowd. It's made with pineapple, fresh jalapeno slices & lawry's casero seasoning.[ tuscan marinara / mozzarella / feta / green peppers / red onions / mushrooms / roasted red peppers / pineapple / tomatoes / fresh jalapeno slices / lawry's casero seasoning / fresh basil ]
- Build Your Own - Up to 5 Toppings$11.19 • 100% (3)Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and up to 5 toppings.
- Athenian$12.99 • 1020 - 1590 Cal.olive oil / mozzarella / feta / grilled chicken / minced garlic / banana peppers / red onions / basil / kalamata olives / sun-dried tomato purée
- Five Star$12.99 • 880 - 1450 Cal.tuscan marinara / mozzarella / italian sausage / pepperoni / beef / green olives / red & green peppers / black olives / red onions
- Build Your Own - Whatever I Want (unlimited toppings)$12.99 • 100% (3)Uniquely yours! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want.
Secret Menu
shhh! These secret pizzas are back!- Pesto Chicken Alfredo$12.99 • 850 - 1440 Cal.alfredo sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / chicken / red onions / tomatoes / basil pesto drizzle
- BBQ Chicken$12.99 • 910 - 1480 Cal.bbq sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / chicken / red onions / chopped cilantroPopular
- Maui Wowwi$12.99 • 890 - 1480 Cal.bbq sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / Canadian bacon / bacon / red onions / pineapple / chopped cilantro
- Chicken Carbonara$12.99 • 870 - 1440 Cal.alfredo sauce / house-shredded whole milk mozzarella cheese / parmesan cheese / chicken / bacon / mushrooms / crushed red peppers
Salads
Breadstix
You don’t have to share a pizza but breadstix are meant for sharing. Each one comes with a dipping sauce, choose from garlic butter, marinara or ranch.Sides
Sweets
Drinks
- Rating and reviews
4.5
•200+ Ratings •
9 Reviews
Joy W.• 02/27/24Had a delicious pizza with pepperoni, feta and garlic! Was still warm when it arrived. Delivery was great! Will order again!
Logan B.• 01/16/24Quick, delicious, affordable. The best
Rachel L.• 01/13/24very tasty 😋
Motunrayo O.• 11/18/23best pizza
Rachel L.• 11/13/23always love me some Five
David G.• 10/08/23I’ve had loads of pizzas across America and until now New York pizza spots were always my favorites. But now Pie Five Pizza on Nicholasville Road in Lexington KY has taken the top prize! Their Old World Maggie pizza with Parmesan crunch stuffed crust is a taste of HEAVEN!
Motunrayo O.• 10/04/23Nice pizza
Rachel L.• 09/15/23always love yalls pizza
Rachel L.• 08/03/23delious now, my favorite pizza place
