Sign in
Top categories
Top dishes
Popular cities
Browse by state
Popular chains
Skip to content
Uber Eats Home
    Petey Wheaty's
    Too far to deliver

    Petey Wheaty's

    4.2
    (12)
      •  
    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday
    03:00 PM - 10:00 PMMenu
    Monday - Tuesday
    01:00 PM - 10:00 PMMenu
    Wednesday
    01:00 PM - 10:00 PMMenu
    03:00 PM - 08:45 PMMenu
    Thursday
    01:00 PM - 10:00 PMMenu
    Friday
    01:00 PM - 10:00 PMMenu
    02:00 PM - 10:00 PMMenu
    Saturday
    02:00 PM - 10:00 PMMenu
    If you're a fan of hard cup takeout like the rest of your city, you'll be happy to know it's offered at Petey Wheaty's. Wish you could ask Petey Wheaty's customers what to order here? If you could, you might expect the answer to be the brownie ice cream sundae, since it's one of the most-ordered items on the entire menu at this evening go... Show more
    If you're a fan of hard cup takeout like the rest of your city, you'll be happy to know it's offered at Petey Wheaty's. Wish you could ask Petey Wheaty's customers what to order here? If you could, you might expect the answer to be the brownie ice cream sundae, since it's one of the most-ordered items on the entire menu at this evening go-to. • ¢ • Burgers • American • Sandwiches • Ice Cream + Frozen Yogurt

    145 S Main St, New City, NY 10956 • More


    • Picked for you

      • "Shamster" Shake

        Choice of any of hard ice cream flavors blended with milk.
        $8.26
      • Brownie Ice Cream Sundae

        Hot brownie, your choice of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry.
        $9.50
      • Hard Cup

        Choose up to 2 flavors for regular and 3 flavors for large: Please see Facebook & Instagram @PeteyWheatys for updated ice-cream images! :) Flavors: Graham Slam Cracker, Cookie Monster, Pub Crawl, Strawberry, Trash Can, Cherry Chocolate Chunk, Low-Fat Raspberry Chunk, Cookies & Cream, Cappuccino Explosion, Death by Chocolate, Devil Dawg, Tahitian Vanilla, Dulce de Leche, Cotton Candy, Nutella, Mint Chocolate Chip, No Sugar Added Peanut Butter Cups & Fudge, Dairy-Free Cookies & Cream, Dairy-Free Lemon Italian Ice, Dairy-Free Chocolate Italian Ice, Dairy-Free Mango Sorbet, Dairy-Free Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet,
        $6.70
      • Chucky Cheeseburger

        5 oz. With a mix of chuck, short ribs, and brisket pasture.
        $10.50
      • Mac n' Cheese a la Kel

        Cheesy, creamy, delicious homemade mac n' cheese. This is Petey Wheaty's daughter's recipe, who he calls Kel!
        $8.99
    • From the Fryer

      • Chicken Tenders

        Breaded chicken strips, juicy, and succulent on the inside and crispy on the outside.
        $10.99
      • Pepperoni Pizza Rolls

        Three mouth watering wanton wrappers filled with pepperoni, sauce, and cheese. Deep fried to perfection.
        $7.99
      • Wings

        Hot, fried, and tender wings.
        $9.99
      • Empandas

        Mouth watering meat and plant-based Argentinean-style empanadas.
        $5.49
      • Mozzarella Sticks

        Battered mozzarella sticks, ooey, gooey and delicious.
        $8.99
      • Perfectly Southern 3 Piece Tender Meal

        Petey's NEW Southern Fried Chicken Program! Meal includes 3 tenders and a side of fries!
        $12.99
      • Perfectly Southern 6 Piece Tender Meal

        Petey's NEW Perfectly Southern Fried Chicken, 6 tenders and 2 servings of fries!
        $19.99
      • Perfectly Southern 9 Piece Tender Meal

        Petey's Perfectly Southern chicken tenders, served with 3 portions of french fries.
        $27.99
    • From the Grill

      • Hamburger

        A classic grilled and juicy served on a martin potato roll or gluten free roll. 5 oz. With a mix of chuck, short ribs, and brisket pasture.
        $9.50
      • Chucky Cheeseburger

        5 oz. With a mix of chuck, short ribs, and brisket pasture.
        $10.50
      • Binster Burger

        A delicious veggie burger for our veggie friends
        $8.99
      • Beef or Chicken Quesadilla

        Our brand new, DELICIOUS beef or chicken quesadillas, served with a side of sour cream!
        $7.89
      • Beef or Chicken Quesadilla DELUXE

        Brand new quesadilla served with sour cream and a side of fries!
        $11.69
    • Hot Dogs

      • Classic Dog

        4 oz. 100% beef, natural casing hot dog served on a potato bun.
        $7.99
    • Sammies

      • Breaded Chicken Sandwich (4 Variations)

        Juicy breaded chicken breast served on a Martins potato roll. Try chicken parmesan, buffalo, BBQ or classic!
        $8.99
    • Salads

      • Kale, Edamame, and Chickpea Salad

        Fresh kale, edameme, and chickpea dressed in a light vinaigrette and served over baby spinach.
        $8.50
        vegan and gluten free
      • Mediterranean Couscous Salad

        Tender and plump Israeli couscous, walnuts, and cranberries dressed in a light vinaigrette served over baby spinach.
        $8.50
    • Sides

      • French Fries

        Skin on fries.
        $3.99
      • Cheese Fries

        $4.99
    • Ice Cream

      • Hard Cup

        Choose up to 2 flavors for regular and 3 flavors for large: Please see Facebook & Instagram @PeteyWheatys for updated ice-cream images! :) Flavors: Graham Slam Cracker, Cookie Monster, Pub Crawl, Strawberry, Trash Can, Cherry Chocolate Chunk, Low-Fat Raspberry Chunk, Cookies & Cream, Cappuccino Explosion, Death by Chocolate, Devil Dawg, Tahitian Vanilla, Dulce de Leche, Cotton Candy, Nutella, Mint Chocolate Chip, No Sugar Added Peanut Butter Cups & Fudge, Dairy-Free Cookies & Cream, Dairy-Free Lemon Italian Ice, Dairy-Free Chocolate Italian Ice, Dairy-Free Mango Sorbet, Dairy-Free Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet,
        $6.70
      • Soft Cup

        $6.00
      • Classic Sundae

        Your choice of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry.
        $8.50
      • Brownie Ice Cream Sundae

        Hot brownie, your choice of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry.
        $9.50
      • "Shamster" Shake

        Choice of any of hard ice cream flavors blended with milk.
        $8.26
      • Banana Split

        Choice of any of hard ice cream flavors served over a banana and topped with hot fudge, whipped cream. A cheery and any 2 toppings.
        $11.05
      • Ice Cream Float

        Classic vanilla ice cream served over root beer is a house favorite, but feel free to mix and match from our other ice creams and sodas!
        $6.25
      • Ice Cream Sandwiches (1/2 Dozen)

        Delicious and creamy homemade ice cream sandwiches. These are the real deal. Available in vanilla and chocolate!
        $12.99
    • Petey Wheaty's Treaties

      • Apple Pie Rolls

        Two apple filled wanton wrapper. Served with powdered sugar and whipped cream.
        $3.99
      • Crumb Cake

        Per slice. Most vanilla crumb cake with a buttery streusel topping.
        $4.25
      • Plain Brownie

        Made with all butter and cream
        $4.95
      • Petey's Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies

        $0.90
    • Fountain

      • Diet Coke

        $3.25
      • Coke

        $3.25
      • Sprite

        $3.25
      • Fanta Orange

        $3.25
      • Bart's Root Beer

        $3.25
    • Bottled

      • Gold Peak Tea

        $2.29
      • Water

        $2.99
    • SPECIALS***

      • Croissant a La Mode

        A freshly baked buttery croissant with your choice of hand crafted ice cream, chocolate drizzle and powdered sugar. Regular- 2 Scoops Large- 3 Scoops
        $8.99
      • Mac n' Cheese a la Kel

        Cheesy, creamy, delicious homemade mac n' cheese. This is Petey Wheaty's daughter's recipe, who he calls Kel!
        $8.99
    • Perfectly Southern

      • Perfectly Southern 3 Piece Tender Meal

        Petey's NEW Southern Fried Chicken Program! Meal includes 3 tenders and a side of fries!
        $12.99
      • Perfectly Southern 6 Piece Tender Meal

        Petey's NEW Perfectly Southern Fried Chicken, 6 tenders and 2 servings of fries!
        $19.99
      • Perfectly Southern 9 Piece Tender Meal

        Petey's Perfectly Southern chicken tenders, served with 3 portions of french fries.
        $27.99
      • Perfect Side Sauce

        Choice of Barbecue, Honey Mustard, Honey Barbecue, Ranch, or Perfect Sauce!
        $1.00
      • Perfectly Southern Fried Chicken 4 Piece

        Perfectly Southern fried chicken, served with a small side of fries and a biscuit!
        $11.99
      • Perfectly Southern Fried Chicken 8 Piece

        Perfectly Southern Fried Chicken, served with 2 sides of fries and 2 biscuits!
        $19.99
      • Perfectly Southern Fried Chicken 12 Piece

        Petey's Perfectly Southern Fried Chicken served with 3 sides of fries and 3 biscuits!
        $23.99
      • Perfectly Southern Baked Beans Side

        $4.99
      • Perfectly Southern Mac n Cheese Side

        $5.25
      • Perfectly Southern Mashed Potatoes Side

        $5.99
      • Perfectly Southern Sweet Potato Mash Side

        $5.99
      • Perfectly Southern Coleslaw Side

        $4.99
      • Perfectly Southern Rt. 40 Side of Fries

        $4.99
      • Perfectly Southern Chicken Gravy

        $3.99
      • Perfectly Southern Biscuit

        $1.99
      • Perfectly Southern Honey BBQ Sauce

        $1.00
      • Perfectly Southern Honey Mustard Side Sauce

        $1.00
      • Perfectly Southern Ranch Side Sauce

        $1.00