4.8
1000+ Ratings
Patellini's Pizza (Sarasota)
4.8 x (1,000+) • 1872 km • Pizza • Fast Food • American • Italian • Group Friendly • Alcohol • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
1429 Main St
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"Born and raised Nyer here and this is THE closest thing to an Italian American slice. Bravo!!!"
• Angelica C. • 03/02/24
"Food was top notch and the quality is excellent. One of the best pizzas I have tasted!!"
• Susan D. • 04/08/22
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday
Monday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Main Menu (3PD)
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 5:00 PM • Main Menu (3PD Fri/Sat)
5:00 PM - 10:45 PM • Weekend Evening Menu (3PD)
Featured items
New York Style Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Garlic Bread & Knots
Fresh 8 Inch New York Hoagie Roll with our Homemade Garlic Butter Recipe
Served with Marinara SauceMelted Sub Sandwiches
Served On A Fresh 8 Inch New York Hoagie Roll With Fresh Deli Meats & Cheese. All Of Our Sandwiches Are Toasted To Perfection In Our Brick OvenDeli Sub Sandwiches
Fresh 8 Inch New York Hoagie Roll with Lettuce, Tomatoes and Our Homemade Dressing, Toasted To Perfection With A Pickle And A Bag Of ChipsPasta
Patellini's Serves Italian Dishes With The Most Flavorful Ingredients. All Of Our Italian Dishes Are Served With A Freshly Baked Garlic KnotsFresh Salads
All Our Salads Are Made Daily with Fresh Lettuce and Vegetables. A Variety of Dressings are available and served on the sideItalian Desserts
Drinks
Bottled Beer
Wine by the Glass
Side Items
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•1000+ Ratings •
39 Reviews
Jill N.• 05/22/24Good food. Big slices
Kathleen B.• 05/03/24Okay I’ll say it: This is the best pizza in Sarasota, bar none.
TIMOTHY C.• 05/01/24Just the way it should be.
THERESA B.• 04/20/24Good pizza in the heart of Sarasota. Thank you.
Brian S.• 03/26/24Everything was amazing!!
Janet N.• 03/19/24Best New York pizza!
RYAN O.• 03/17/24Great pizza.
RICHARD L.• 03/16/24Always perfect
Angelica C.• 03/02/24Born and raised Nyer here and this is THE closest thing to an Italian American slice. Bravo!!!
Kathleen L.• 01/11/24Absolutely fantastic pizza! We also had the canelloni which tasted like Mammas!
Jason Y.• 01/02/24Great pizza !!!!
Chris C.• 12/31/23Great pizza
RICHARD L.• 12/02/23great as always
Brandi S.• 12/01/23terrific as always
Vadim !.• 11/14/23NY style tasty pizza
c J J.• 11/07/23I order from them all the time. The food is consistently good and hot.
Alicia K.• 11/06/23Great pizza!
Ray F.• 10/06/23Amazing as usual. Best pizza in Sarasota by a large margin.
c J J.• 10/03/23I order from here a lot. It is consistently good and hot.
Luke P.• 09/06/23the food is ALWAYS great. it's my top for pizza.
Matthew S.• 08/26/23Very good quality and very consistent.
Wendy D.• 08/13/23The best
Arielle H.• 08/12/23So good and grateful for gluten free options
Luke P.• 08/04/23I'm always very pleased with the food. The pizza and steak and cheese sub are my fav.
Rob W.• 07/29/23Great pizza
Wendy D.• 07/18/23Fabulous, pretty much authentic NY pizza
Charlene P.• 07/18/23More than enough in the servings.
Charlene P.• 07/02/23good food, generous servings
Brandi S.• 07/02/23gluten-free yumminess
Victoria T.• 06/18/23Actually was really good! And I’m from NY so it did taste similar !
Carisa K.• 06/04/23Loved iT!
Ranjeet S.• 05/27/23Great food, best pizza in Sarasota!
Brandi S.• 05/23/23always great
Tanya M.• 05/20/23Whether it's a whole pie, or by the slice this pizza is a great choice!
Brandi S.• 04/18/23gluten free is delicious
Susan D.• 04/08/22Food was top notch and the quality is excellent. One of the best pizzas I have tasted!!
Jay N.• 02/12/22Good pizza
JoAnn G.• 08/07/21Amazing pizza!!!
Alvin J.• 07/11/21Convenient and tasty
