4.8
1000+ Ratings
Patellini's Pizza (Sarasota)
4.8 x (1,000+) • 2412.5 mi • Pizza • Fast Food • American • Italian • Group Friendly • Alcohol • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
1429 Main St
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Born and raised Nyer here and this is THE closest thing to an Italian American slice. Bravo!!!"
• Angelica C. • 03/02/24
"Food was top notch and the quality is excellent. One of the best pizzas I have tasted!!"
• Susan D. • 04/08/22
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
Monday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Main Menu (3PD)
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 5:00 PM • Main Menu (3PD Fri/Sat)
5:00 PM - 10:45 PM • Weekend Evening Menu (3PD)
Featured items
New York Style Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Garlic Bread & Knots
Fresh 8 Inch New York Hoagie Roll with our Homemade Garlic Butter Recipe
Served with Marinara SauceFresh Salads
All Our Salads Are Made Daily with Fresh Lettuce and Vegetables. A Variety of Dressings are available and served on the sideItalian Desserts
Drinks
Bottled Beer
Wine by the Glass
Side Items
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•1000+ Ratings •
39 Reviews
Jill N.• 05/22/24Good food. Big slices
Kathleen B.• 05/03/24Okay I’ll say it: This is the best pizza in Sarasota, bar none.
TIMOTHY C.• 05/01/24Just the way it should be.
THERESA B.• 04/20/24Good pizza in the heart of Sarasota. Thank you.
Brian S.• 03/26/24Everything was amazing!!
Janet N.• 03/19/24Best New York pizza!
RYAN O.• 03/17/24Great pizza.
RICHARD L.• 03/16/24Always perfect
Angelica C.• 03/02/24Born and raised Nyer here and this is THE closest thing to an Italian American slice. Bravo!!!
Kathleen L.• 01/11/24Absolutely fantastic pizza! We also had the canelloni which tasted like Mammas!
Jason Y.• 01/02/24Great pizza !!!!
Chris C.• 12/01/23Great pizza
RICHARD L.• 12/02/23great as always
Brandi S.• 12/01/23terrific as always
Vadim !.• 11/14/23NY style tasty pizza
c J J.• 11/07/23I order from them all the time. The food is consistently good and hot.
Alicia K.• 11/06/23Great pizza!
Ray F.• 10/06/23Amazing as usual. Best pizza in Sarasota by a large margin.
c J J.• 10/03/23I order from here a lot. It is consistently good and hot.
Luke P.• 09/06/23the food is ALWAYS great. it's my top for pizza.
Matthew S.• 08/26/23Very good quality and very consistent.
Wendy D.• 08/13/23The best
Arielle H.• 08/12/23So good and grateful for gluten free options
Luke P.• 08/04/23I'm always very pleased with the food. The pizza and steak and cheese sub are my fav.
Rob W.• 07/29/23Great pizza
Charlene P.• 07/18/23More than enough in the servings.
Wendy D.• 07/18/23Fabulous, pretty much authentic NY pizza
Charlene P.• 07/02/23good food, generous servings
Brandi S.• 07/02/23gluten-free yumminess
Victoria T.• 06/18/23Actually was really good! And I’m from NY so it did taste similar !
Carisa K.• 06/04/23Loved iT!
Ranjeet S.• 05/27/23Great food, best pizza in Sarasota!
Brandi S.• 05/23/23always great
Tanya M.• 05/20/23Whether it's a whole pie, or by the slice this pizza is a great choice!
Brandi S.• 04/18/23gluten free is delicious
Susan D.• 04/08/22Food was top notch and the quality is excellent. One of the best pizzas I have tasted!!
Jay N.• 02/12/22Good pizza
JoAnn G.• 08/07/21Amazing pizza!!!
Alvin J.• 07/11/21Convenient and tasty
