4.7
3000+ Ratings
Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry
4.7 x (3,000+) • Pizza • American • Wings • Family Friendly • Sandwiches • $ • Info
x Available Monday 11:00 AM
1455 State Road 436, Casselberry, FL 32707
Rating and reviews
"I’m from New York so when i tried this pizza I melted in my chair at how nostalgic and back at home I felt. Yummy yummy yummy nothing like New York style pizza in Florida"
• Sandra M. • 05/07/26
"Best pizza that is not homemade by my son hahaha. And their extra large is actually...extra large! Also great prices. My new fave for delivered pizza."
• HEIDI K. • 07/29/23
x $0 delivery fee (new users)
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
12:00 PM - 9:00 PM • Menu
Monday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 2:30 PM • Lunch Specials ()
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Menu
Friday
11:00 AM - 2:30 PM • Lunch Specials ()
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Menu
Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Menu
Featured items
Appetizers
Pizza by the Slice
Pizza - 12" Small Pizzas
Pizza - 14" Medium Pizzas
Pizza - 16" Large Pizzas
Pizza - 18" Extra Large Pizzas
Calzones
Calzones served with side of marinaraStromboli
Hot & Cold Subs
Subs served with Lays potato chipsEntrées
Entrees served two garlic knots, add tossed side salad $2.49Kids
Sides
Beverages
Desserts
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•3000+ Ratings •
67 Reviews
lisa G.• 09/10/23Tasty good.
Michael L.• 08/26/23great pizza!
Kimberley R.• 05/19/23Pizza never disappoints
Nicholas M.• 02/06/23Best NY Style pizza in Orlando. Can't beat it.
keir V.• 07/22/23Great food
Nic A.• 11/10/23Oh my god this place is amazing, and the portions last me two days or so I am so glad i found them
Esther L.• 04/20/24We love the Pizza from Anthony’s. Reminds us of the delicious pizza in NY! Grazie!
Isaac M.• 02/17/24Pizza was good but the wings were surprisingly great.
Ron K.• 06/17/23very good, foldable crust and not too salty either
Stef C.• 06/05/23Best chicken parm and red sauce. I love their bianca pizza. Good house salad with the best ranch.
Taylor C.• 11/24/23Yes
Timothy M.• 06/09/24great pizza
Mike G.• 05/15/22Great customer service, fast delivery , amazing pizza
Cowl G.• 09/03/24In my opinion, it’s the very best pizza! Go get a pie!!!
Dania C.• 06/06/24Delicious!
Jake S.• 11/18/23Haven’t really had better pizza in Orlando - simple and delicious
Emmanuel C.• 09/20/22best pizza in altamonte springs period!
Bradley H.• 12/17/23Great food
Kathy B.• 02/16/24Good pizza
Melissa S.• 06/02/23Delicious
Al Tarek W.• 12/17/23Pizza was Fire
Oliver J.• 02/28/23I love eating here the wings, pizza, and pasta is good yum!!!
chelsea G.• 09/05/24I love pizza 😋🍕
Christopher M.• 02/13/22Awesome
Kathryn M.• 02/27/23So delicious! Don’t sleep on the subs; fresh and soooo good!
Pamela B.• 06/24/23Best NY style pizza in Central Florida!
Michel C.• 10/12/23excellent communication
Melissa M.• 03/24/23Always great food!
kayla S.• 02/14/23Best pizza in Orlando and that's coming from a New Yorker!
mary M.• 04/23/24great
Deana J.• 05/24/24Best Italian restaurant in town. Everything on the menu is delicious.
Nancy W.• 11/25/25I am born and raised in New York and my expectations are high and Anthonys NY Pizza exceed them. Absolutely delicious food.
Michael K.• 07/09/23Pound for pound, best and most consistent.
Marcos R.• 10/27/22Delicious, the best Pizza in Casselberry.
KRISTOPHER M.• 03/09/24Small business big flavor. Casselberry staple.
Jackson W.• 07/20/24Been going here for years. Best pies in central Fl
Konstance S.• 07/05/22Love the pizza.
Heather P.• 04/16/23Food was good - large portions. Yummy garlic knots! Will purchase from here again.
joel H.• 06/07/23Great taste
Alviz L.• 09/01/23really good taste and huge
Melody C.• 06/30/23The cheese pizza has excellent cheese flavor and good cheese to tomato sauce ratio.
Lauretha R.• 06/04/23Delicious
Reinaldo B.• 10/01/22Excellent
Jessica L.• 01/20/24everything was delicious. I dream about the sauce used on the pizza. the salad is always perfect.
Keith N.• 11/18/24NY style
Eileen P.• 09/19/23taste great
Bridghid D.• 07/29/23Anthony’s has been favorite local pizza for years
Luz R.• 09/20/21Delicious 😋
Denise D.• 06/04/23Great pizza
Shane B.• 12/10/22Amazing pizza
Chris L.• 06/28/23First time customer. Very impressed with quality of pizza and garlic bread w/cheese! Will be back for more!!
TIFFANY M.• 08/07/23Perfect everytime
HEIDI K.• 07/29/23Best pizza that is not homemade by my son hahaha. And their extra large is actually...extra large! Also great prices. My new fave for delivered pizza.
Filipe Z.• 07/24/23Excellent pizza
Richard T.• 10/07/23Great real NY pizza!!
carol F.• 11/29/23The delivery was timely.
Rhinemark V.• 08/23/23Best pizza in town!
Mark W.• 08/27/23Great food for a great price.
Dave B.• 08/04/24Best pizza in town
MARCUS L.• 01/22/23awesome service and food
mark T.• 07/13/25"Gave Dean the wrong address and he ""re-delivered"" it ... no questions asked! Thanks Dean!"
DIANNE R.• 08/11/23Tastes absolutely delicious!!
Kim M.• 07/09/23I ordered the eggplant parmesan with spaghetti. it came with salad and garlic knots. it was absolutely delicious and a very generous portion.
Christina H.• 12/29/23It was great! Thanks!
Carolena P.• 03/02/24Very nice 😊
Katelyn C.• 02/05/25The best pizza spot in all of Central FL
Sandra M.• 05/07/26I’m from New York so when i tried this pizza I melted in my chair at how nostalgic and back at home I felt. Yummy yummy yummy nothing like New York style pizza in Florida
Can I order Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery in Casselberry with Uber Eats?
Yes. Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery is available on Uber Eats in Casselberry.
Is Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery is available to your location in Casselberry.
How do I order Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery online in Casselberry?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery in Casselberry?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
