4.9
2000+ Ratings
Olmo Bagels
4.9 x (2,000+) • 2614.5 mi • Bagels • Coffee and Tea • Sandwiches • American • Breakfast and Brunch • Info
93 Whitney Avenue
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"you went above and beyond with the service for my order! thank you so much for your attention and kindness! and, the food was excellent! i’ll be writing a more detailed review on your site and trip advisor! glad i picked you!"
• LoraAnn V. • 01/25/23
"Some of the best bagels you can get locally in CT! I love their options of bagel and schmear flavors. Their breakfast sandwiches are always well-made. So delicious!"
• Sarah J. • 02/01/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Monday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Tuesday - Saturday
7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Featured items
Bagel Sandwiches
Breakfast and Lunch bagel sandwiches served all day. Modify our menu to your liking!- Bagel w. Schmear$5.55 • 98% (327)Olmo’s signature bagel with our house whipped cream cheese. Add a couple toppings to customize your breakfast!
- Bacon, Egg, & Cheese$9.95 • 99% (313)Choose your bagel - comes with bacon, two eggs, provolone, salt, and pepper
- Lox w. Love$15.50 • 97% (157)Choose your bagel - comes with choice of cream cheese, 2oz of double smoked Acme lox (salmon), tomatoes, red onions, and capers
- Sausage, Egg, & Cheese$11.20 • 98% (120)Choose your bagel - comes with Lamberti's sausage, two eggs, provolone, salt, and pepper
- Egg & Cheese$7.15 • 98% (76)Choose your bagel - comes with two eggs, provolone, salt, and pepper
- Bagel w. Butter$3.15 • 100% (25)Choose your bagel and we'll schmear the farm fresh butter
- Egg Sandwich (No Cheese)$6.40 • 100% (24)Choose your bagel - comes with two eggs, salt, and pepper
Bulk Bagels
Olmo Bagels in a bag! Voted best in New Haven - Grab some bagels for your freezer so you can start each day off with a smile.- Solo Bagel$2.35 • 100% (60)Original New Haven Bagels - simply a bagel in a bag
- Tub of Schmear$9.00 • 96% (146)8oz tub of schmear (cream cheese) - we recommend one per six (6) bagels
- Half Dozen Bagels$11.75 • 99% (136)Six (6) of New Haven's best bagels in a bag - does not include schmear
- Baker's Dozen Bagels$23.50 • 98% (60)13 of New Haven's best bagels in a bag - does not include schmear
- Half Pound of Lox$23.00Acme double smoked nova lox thin sliced and served on the side. Good for 4-6 bagels.
*Bagels and Schmear sold separately*
Drinks
- Iced Coffee / Cold Brew$6.50 • 94% (168)A cup of 4Jacks Cold Brew - we add the dairy and the sweetener
- Fresh JuicePriced by add-ons • 98% (52)Fresh pressed juices by Natalie's
- Organic Hot Coffee$4.25 • 92% (150)A cup of Organic Olmo Blend - we add the dairy and the sweetner
- Olmo Arnold Palmer$7.50 • 85% (21)Olmo Lemonade + Iced Tea = Arnold PalmerYour choice of black tea or hibiscus tea for your refreshing beverage!
- Olmo Lemonade$7.50 • 100% (13)Our homemade lemonade made from fresh lemon juice, meyer lemon, and yuzu juice. Served over ice - so refreshing!
- Sparkling Water$2.25 • 100% (9)Spindrift and La Croix
- Bottled Water$1.95"Now that's what I call high quality H2O." Better than Gatorade!
Baked Goods & Things
Other offerings from our baking team!- Rating and reviews
4.9
•2000+ Ratings •
58 Reviews
Hadeel A.• 05/30/24Great bagel
Nicole O.• 05/28/24Best bagels in New Haven
Abigail B.• 05/20/24Amazing
Gillian G.• 05/18/24Love Olmo and glad yhey ate on Uber Eats
Errin G.• 04/23/24Best in town
Kayley B.• 04/10/24Delicious bagels and schmear! Love the cold brew, too. Startin' your day with Olmo is startin' your day proper.
Mari R.• 03/23/24Delicious I enjoyed
Slin N.• 03/22/24Good
Leo D.• 03/17/24Yum
Jesse P.• 03/08/24So so delicious
Gabriel M.• 03/03/24Good bagels
Mark C.• 02/25/24Amazing every time
Tom C.• 02/25/24Best bagel in New Haven.
PJ M.• 02/21/24Delicious!!
Edwin O.• 02/18/24excellent
Jackie T.• 02/15/24Love love love every time!
Ellina K.• 02/14/24Good
Sarah J.• 02/01/24Some of the best bagels you can get locally in CT! I love their options of bagel and schmear flavors. Their breakfast sandwiches are always well-made. So delicious!
Christie G.• 01/01/24Delicious
Errin G.• 01/26/24The only bagels worth your money that I know of in the state of Connecticut
Amber O.• 01/23/24delicious food
Yuqi X.• 01/21/24excellent service
Grace M.• 01/12/24Incredible zataar bagel, toasted, with umami butter
Alex R.• 01/12/24Great
Brian C.• 01/09/24Best bagels i’ve ever had
Marlow B.• 12/07/23Best bagels in New Haven
Dana M.• 12/02/23Never fail option! Always good!
Carlos S.• 11/25/23I LOVE OLMO BAGELS,
Joeseph S.• 11/10/23Absolutely the best bagels in New Haven county.
Phebean O.• 11/02/23delicious bagels!
Ellen P.• 10/29/23We always love an Olmo breakfast at home!
Kirsten H.• 10/22/23Great fresh bagels. Egg sandwiches are delicious and always arrive hot and wrapped beautifully in wax paper.
LORI D.• 09/27/23Best bagel I ever had!!!
Mari R.• 09/17/23Very good! flavor, pleasant to eat
Kam R.• 08/15/23Yum
Jessica L.• 08/14/23Play VeggieTales cream cheese is to die for
Robert S.• 08/06/23Delicious and timely.
Jennifer D.• 07/30/23Amazing bagels and babka
Cheryl T.• 07/22/23Really good bagels and I love that they use local New Haven sausage. Great Nitro ice coffee too!
mariah B.• 07/06/23best bagels in new haven hands down!
Cristina R.• 06/30/23Delicious!
Susan R.• 06/18/23Delicious avocado schmear with tomato on a perfectly toasted plain bagel. Sausage, egg and cheese was perfectly assembled and delicious
Amanda H.• 06/10/23Amazing bagels 🥯 great homemade breakfast! Nothing better in New Haven!
Hala L.• 06/08/23Thank you for the most recent order; it was wonderful.
kc D.• 06/02/23amazing quality
Mary M.• 06/02/23Best bagels and cream cheese in New Haven!
Michele L.• 05/16/23Bagels are the best around!
Felix R.• 04/17/23mmmm bacun
Lexi S.• 04/15/23Huge bagels and stuffed sandwiches
melanie M.• 03/17/23love the bagles!! always delicious!! highly recommend!!
William N.• 03/07/23These are the best bagels I think I’ve ever had. I know I’m going to make this a favorite for me.
Brainard C.• 02/21/23Satisfying, authentic experience
Caitlyn W.• 02/05/23Best bacon, egg, and cheese I’ve ever had. Lately been ordering at least once a week
LoraAnn V.• 01/25/23you went above and beyond with the service for my order! thank you so much for your attention and kindness! and, the food was excellent! i’ll be writing a more detailed review on your site and trip advisor! glad i picked you!
Rebecca F.• 01/14/23Best bagels in town. The spicy scallion cream cheese is everything!!!
Kelvin R.• 12/20/22BLT was really good and fresh!
Katie H.• 05/04/22Great!
Catherine P.• 02/23/22Absolutely amazing! The best bagels+cream cheese I’ve found in the area. Customer service is incredible as well. Thank you Sal!
