Sign in
Top categories
Top dishes
Popular cities
Browse by state
Popular chains
Skip to content
Uber Eats Home
    1. United States
    2. New York
    3. East Setauket
    4. NY Cookie Cow
    NY Cookie Cow
    Too far to deliver

    NY Cookie Cow

    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday
    12:00 PM - 12:00 AM
    Monday - Friday
    Closed
    Saturday
    12:00 PM - 12:00 AM

    248 Main Street, Suite 5, Setauket-East Setauket, NY 11733 • More


    • Cookies

      • Oreo Face Plant

        A must-try if you love Oreo cookies. Sweet, rich, fluffy, with some chocolate chips, and loaded with crushed Oreo’s and vanilla crème filling. The most unbelievably creamy Oreo cookie of a lifetime.
        $5.95
      • I <3 NY Chocolate Chip

        Our version of the classic chocolate chip cookie. Everything you know and love, but freshly baked with the finest ingredients. The slight crunch on the outside, gooey in the middle thickness, and melt in your mouth perfection.
        $5.00
      • Midnight Peanut Butter Overload

        The perfect cookie for chocolate peanut butter fanatics. Full of rich moist chocolate and studded with Reese’s butter cups and morsels, this cookie is a prized peanut butter chocolate sensation. These cookies will knock your socks off. We promise.
        $5.50
      • Somewhere Over the Rainbow Cookies

        Our signature chocolate chip cookie, with rainbow sprinkles mixed in, and stuffed with an authentic Italian rainbow cookie. You will hear angels sing once you have a piece of this heaven.
        $5.95
      • S'Moo

        Brown butter dough, chocolate chips, graham cracker crumbs, and a gooey marshmallow center topped with a Hershey bar piece makes this cookie completely irresistible. The perfect way to get your s’mores fixes without a campfire.
        $5.95
      • Mystery Cookie

        As the name suggests, leave it up to us to surprise you with a cookie of our choice!
        $4.75
    • Organic Milk

      • Organic Whole Milk

        What’s so special about cold, creamy Horizon Organic® whole milk? Well, it’s certified organic, so it has to meet all of these standards: no GMOs, no antibiotics, no added hormones, no toxic and persistent pesticides and the humane treatment of cows. Plus, it has 50% more vitamin D than typical whole milk in every delicious serving.
        $2.75
      • Organic Chocolate Milk

        Level up your cookies and milk experience! (8 oz carton)
        $2.75