4.7
110+ Ratings
Nuyorican Pizzeria & Cuisine
4.7 x (110+) • 2109.1 mi • American • Italian • Pizza • Salads • Sandwiches • Chicken • Info
2864 North High Street
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"The food is amazing honestly! Seasoned well, delicious, also great portions. Also the food is always packed & labeled nicely and neatly! Well worth the price! Also I haven’t noticed with other places but Nuyorican gives you a chance to change your selection(s) if they are sold out (within 10 mins) rather than just canceling your order. I love that!"
• Leea F. • 09/28/23
"Great food!! Also it was very delicious and the portions were huge. There aren’t many Hispanic restaurants here in Columbus, so it was great to have comfort food and a piece of home!"
• Leea F. • 09/15/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Monday
Tuesday - Saturday
12:00 PM - 5:30 PM
Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Roasted Chicken$15.00 • 93% (15)Adobo chicken smothered in BBQ or blackened jerk sauce.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Mofongo$15.00 • 95% (21)Plantains smashed with garlic, herbs, broth, and chicharron (pork rinds) mojo sauce.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Pernil$15.00 • 92% (14)Slow-cooked marinated roasted pork.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Blackened Chicken Pasta$19.00 • 100% (15)Blackened jerk chicken. Fettuccine smothered in creamy alfredo sauce.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Pastelón Pasta$17.00 • 66% (3)Lasagna is made with layers of ripped plantains, savory beef, mozzarella, and ricotta herb mix.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Eggplant Parmigiana pasta$17.00 • 100% (3)Breaded deep-fried eggplant coated with marinara sauce and mozzarella, served on a bed of spaghetti.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Spaghetti Pasta and Meatballs$17.00Spaghetti topped with our house marinara sauce and hand-crafted meatballs.Buy 1, Get 1 Free
Appetizers
- Empanadas$4.00 • 91% (37)Served with mango habanero salsa or chimichurri sauce.
- Rellenos Depapas (4 pcs)$12.00 • 92% (13)Creamy mashed potato balls stuffed with savory beef and served with mojo sauce.
- Tostoness$6.00 • 90% (10)Basket of crispy plantains served with mojo sauce.
- Alcapurrias (3pcs)$10.50 • 100% (3)Stuffed masa filled with savory beef and served with sauce.
- Garlic Knots(5 pcs)$4.49 • 100% (4)Fresh bread twists, roasted garlic, smothered in garlic butter, and sprinkled with romano herb mix. Served with marinara sauce.
- Baked Meatballs (3 pcs)$8.49 • 100% (5)Hand-crafted meatballs smothered in marinara sauce and mozzarella sprinkled with romano herb mix.
- Bacalaíto$4.75 • 100% (6)Flakey seasoned cod fritter.
- Plátanos Maduros$6.00 • 85% (7)Fried sweet plantain slices served with sauce.
- Breadsticks (8 pcs)$5.49Freshly baked breadsticks coasted in garlic butter and sprinkled with romano herb mix. Served with marinara sauce.
Salads
- Caesar Salad$6.99 • 57% (7)Romaine lettuce, romano cheese, and plantain croutons tossed with Caesar dressing.
- Garden Salad$5.99Spring lettuce, red onions, tomatoes, black olives, cheese, and plantain croutons.
- Caribbean Salad$6.99Spring lettuce, tomatoes, mangoes, avocado, red onions, and house dressing.
Entrées
Pastas
Oven Baked Subs
Pizza - Liberty Pies
Pizza - Signature Pies
Dessert
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•110+ Ratings •
25 Reviews
Charles M.• 05/03/24The best Puerto Rican food in Columbus.
Justin B.• 04/28/24Great NY pie
Robert D.• 04/27/24Great portions, amazing taste
Lydia M.• 04/20/24Authentic Puerto Rican cuisine. I’m excited to have found a treasure in Columbus
Lori S.• 04/19/24Very tasty
Laura M.• 04/19/24Great offers, food was hot and tasty. Glad an ordered.
Niko M.• 03/07/24OMG! Definitely the best pizza in Columbus! it reminds me of NY Pizza in Orlando Florida and when I lived in NJ.
Yanicee S.• 01/24/24It was tasty and flavorful. Loved it
JaZzy B.• 01/19/24I’m Puerto Rican and their food is very authentic. It was a pleasure to have their meal.
Naomi D.• 01/01/24Loved the food! Finally found my rican food!
ANDREW M.• 11/23/23Pizza was good. Has a sweet tangy pizza sauce.
Kaela A.• 11/14/23Delicious
Joshua H.• 11/09/23A recent addition to my pantheon of great eats! Try anything, you’ll be happy!
Chelsey S.• 11/06/23Great food. Authentic, and reminded me of home!
SERGIO C.• 11/01/23Authentic
Brian B.• 11/01/23The recipes are fantastic. Great selection with very reasonable pricing.
Joshua H.• 10/30/23Fresh, handmade good food. From the best mofongo I’ve had, to the calzones. Everything here has been solidly well prepared.
Maria C.• 10/29/23The literal best food in columbus
Anna Y.• 10/18/23The food was absolutely delicious!
Monique F.• 10/07/23Had a great experience! My food tasted amazing! I will be back asap!!
Damaris C.• 10/04/23I have no words for how good the food was. You just have to try it for yourself! I wish I could give it more stars
Leea F.• 09/28/23The food is amazing honestly! Seasoned well, delicious, also great portions. Also the food is always packed & labeled nicely and neatly! Well worth the price! Also I haven’t noticed with other places but Nuyorican gives you a chance to change your selection(s) if they are sold out (within 10 mins) rather than just canceling your order. I love that!
Ari L.• 09/28/23Healthy servings!! Will definitely order again.
Leea F.• 09/15/23Great food!! Also it was very delicious and the portions were huge. There aren’t many Hispanic restaurants here in Columbus, so it was great to have comfort food and a piece of home!
David P.• 09/13/23Top notch! Fresh and delicious!
