4.7
360+ Ratings
Nicolosi's Pizza
4.7 x (360+) • 2504.9 mi • Pizza • Italian • Pasta • Comfort Food • Info
x Delivery unavailable
1700 Sullivan Trl Ste 3
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"The pizzas were fresh hot and delicious with crisp edges and tasty dough, sauce on the sweeter side and yummy mozzarella! Antipasto salad had plenty of ham and olives with quality balsamic dressing. The 2 of us polished it off so I would recommend 2 salads for 4 people. From a previous order we give 5 stars to the pepperoni bites-absolutely delicious pinwheels of dough, pepperoni and cheese with garlic bits all around Highly recommend!"
• Christine C. • 04/07/24
"The pizza sauce is probably the best I've ever had- I usually order white pizza from most places because the red sauce is usually subpar, but this was pleasantly surprising! Would definitely order her again!"
• Janet C. • 09/13/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
Monday - Thursday
10:45 AM - 8:30 PM
Friday
10:45 AM - 9:20 PM
Saturday
10:45 AM - 8:30 PM
Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- GARLIC KNOTS$8.95Great starters! (6 per order)Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- CINNAMON KNOTS$8.95A sweet treat after lunch or dinner! (6 per order)Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- Pepperoni Bites$8.95Great Starters! (6 Per Order)Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- SMALL NEW YORK STYLE$13.95NOW 12"!! Voted one of the top 10 Pizzerias in the Valley!Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- CHICKEN PARMIGIANA$14.25Includes Sauce & Mozzarella baked in the ovenBuy 1, Get 1 Free
Appetizers & Starters
- SKUL GARLIC KNOTS!$9.95Now available ! 6 per order!
- FRENCH FRIES$5.50
- CHEDDAR CHEESE FRIES$6.99
- MOZZARELLA CHEESE FRIES$6.99
- BACON RANCH FRIES$6.99Topped with Ranch & Crumbled Bacon
- PIZZA FRIES$6.99Topped with our Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella & baked in the oven
- PIEROGIES (4 per order)$5.50
- ONION RINGS$5.50Thick Cut & Beer Battered Style
- GARLIC KNOTS$8.95Great starters! (6 per order)Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- CINNAMON KNOTS$8.95A sweet treat after lunch or dinner! (6 per order)Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- CHICKEN TENDERS & FRIES$14.95(Includes 1 side of Dipping Sauce)
- GARLIC BREAD$4.95
- CHEESY GARLIC BREAD$5.95
- Pepperoni Bites$8.95Great Starters! (6 Per Order)Buy 1, Get 1 Free
- MOZZARELLA STICKS (5 per order)$9.75
Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Stromboli & Calzone
Clubs & Subs all prepared on 10" rolls
From the Grill all prepared on 10" rolls
Wings
Salads
1/2 lb. Burgers
Dinners
Kid's Sizes
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•360+ Ratings •
35 Reviews
Christine C.• 04/07/24The pizzas were fresh hot and delicious with crisp edges and tasty dough, sauce on the sweeter side and yummy mozzarella! Antipasto salad had plenty of ham and olives with quality balsamic dressing. The 2 of us polished it off so I would recommend 2 salads for 4 people. From a previous order we give 5 stars to the pepperoni bites-absolutely delicious pinwheels of dough, pepperoni and cheese with garlic bits all around Highly recommend!
Robin H.• 04/04/24Had the chicken. parm sandwich delicious and hot.
Kellie R.• 03/23/24Quick service
Ben D.• 02/17/24good
Steven F.• 02/16/24Food was hot, fresh, and excellent taste.
Bill T.• 02/03/24Good food
Steve S.• 01/23/24One of the areas best tasting pizzas.
Wayne J.• 01/09/24Their well-done plain pies are killer. a true new york slice.
LENA H.• 12/28/23The pizza was great
Donna Z.• 12/14/23Great food all around
David D.• 12/10/23great tasting food
David D.• 12/03/23delicious food and great deals
Jim L.• 10/26/23We took advantage of the BOGO deal and it was a huge WIN for us. Will see you again.
Veronica S.• 10/25/232 orders so far. Delicious
Lloydanee S.• 10/23/23really good!
Dana E.• 10/15/23good food
David H.• 09/14/23Perfect pie for lunch!
Janet C.• 09/13/23The pizza sauce is probably the best I've ever had- I usually order white pizza from most places because the red sauce is usually subpar, but this was pleasantly surprising! Would definitely order her again!
Teresa M.• 09/03/23good
George S.• 09/02/23Pizza is amazing
Michelle F.• 07/10/23Great pizza and cinnamon knots!
Erik W.• 07/08/23I decided to try something new and I was not let down!!
Vikki A.• 07/07/23I’m from NY and I thought I’d never find good pizza here. I was wrong. Nicolosi’s is AMAZING. We LOVE it! You will too!
Ryan H.• 07/06/23Good
Paul M.• 06/13/23Delicious fast complete thanks
Lato B.• 05/20/23delicious❤️
scott W.• 05/17/23Good food! Thanks!
Katie B.• 04/01/23I tried the Grandma pie and it was amazing!
TERRY D.• 03/05/23good
Jack H.• 03/01/23great food and pizza
ALEX G.• 02/26/23El mejor servicio y comida de todo el area
Brian H.• 02/16/23great food, good prices
Judy K.• 01/31/23good food
Gregory G.• 01/22/23Yummy
REBECCA R.• 12/30/22fresh and amazing taste
