Skip to content
Uber Eats Home
    1. United States
    2. Wisconsin
    3. Milwaukee
    4. Brewers Hill
    5. New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave)

    New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) Menu and Delivery in Milwaukee

    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    231 E North Ave, Milwaukee Wi, WI 53212
    Sunday - Thursday
    11:00 AM - 09:00 PMAll Day
    11:00 AM - 09:00 PMAll Day
    10:00 AM - 11:59 PMMenu
    Friday - Saturday
    11:00 AM - 09:00 PMAll Day
    11:00 AM - 09:00 PMAll Day
    10:00 AM - 02:00 AMMenu

    New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave)

    3.2 (30 ratings) • Pizza • $
      •  Read 5-Star Reviews  •  More info
    231 E North Ave, Milwaukee Wi, WI 53212
    Tap for hours, info, and more
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    This place is so popular that it's actually one of the 10 most ordered from spots in all of Brewers Hill. Wondering what to order at this late at night go-to? Of the 280 things on the menu, the Wild Wings is one of the items that gets the most orders. • $ • Pizza • Italian • Salads • Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • Sandwiches • Kids Friendly
    • Picked for you
        • Sour Cream & Chives Fries
        • Meat Lasagna
        • Double Cheeseburger with French Fries
          Meal.
        • Cheeseburger with French Fries
          Meal.
        • Pecan Pie
      • Appetizers
          • Mozzarella Marinara
          • Cheese Bals
          • Onion Rings
          • Breaded Okra
          • Breaded Zucchini Sticks
          • Broccoli & Cheese Bites
          • Breaded Mushrooms
          • Jalapeño Popppers
          • Mac ‘N’ Cheese Wedges
        • Soup
            • Cheddar & Broccoli
          • Salads
              • Garden Salad
              • Caesar Salad Large
              • Italian Salad
              • Favoite Greek Salad
                Served with pita bread.
              • Small Side Salad
            • Nachos
                • Nachos with Cheese
                • Nachos with Beef & Cheese
                • Nachos Supreme
                  Includes lettuce, tomatoes, onion, salsa, and sour cream.
              • Gourmet French Fries
                  • French Fries
                  • Chili Fries
                  • Chili Cheese Fries
                  • Seasoned Fries
                  • Cheese Fries
                  • Sour Cream & Chives Fries
                • New Special
                    • Extra Large Pizza & 1/2 pound Boneless wings
                  • Wild Wings
                      • Wild WIngs
                        Priced by add-ons
                    • Boneless Wings
                        • Boneless Wings
                          Priced by add-ons
                      • Specialty Bread
                          • Garlic Bread Specialty
                          • Garlic Cheese Bread Specialty
                          • Parmesan Bread–Sticks Specialty
                          • Pizza Bread Specialty
                            1 topping.
                          • Pizza Puffs Specialty
                          • Pita Bread Specialty
                        • Specialty Pizza
                            • Mexican Special Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Seasoned ground beef, onions, tomatoes, black olives, lettuce, salsa, and mozzarella.
                            • Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ Chicken Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Grilled chicken, sweet baby ray’s BBQ sauce, tomatoes, onion, and mozzarella.
                            • Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Grilled chicken, ranch dressing, buffalo sauce, and mozzarella.
                            • Bacon Cheeseburger Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Hamburger meat, bacon, mozzarella, American cheese, and a side of mayo, and ketchup.
                            • Garden Veggie Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Parmesan, fontinella, romano, and mozzarella.
                            • Four Cheese Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Parmesan, fontinella, romano, and mozzarella.
                            • Favoite New York Finest Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Pepperoni, sausage, and mozzarella.
                            • Favoite Mexicali Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Grilled chicken, onion, green pepper, jalapenos, mozzarella, and tomatoes.
                            • New York Deluxe Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Sausage, mushroom, onion, and mozzarella.
                            • Caesar Chicken Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Grilled chicken, caesar dressing, Parmesan, and mozzarella.
                            • Hawaiian Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Canadian bacon and pineapple.
                            • Upstate Deluxe Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Pepperoni, mushroom, onion, and mozzarella.
                            • New York Supreme Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion, and mozzarella.
                            • New York Meat Lovers Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, and mozzarella.
                            • Chicken Philly Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Grilled chicken, mushrooms, onion, green peppers, tomatoes, and mozzarella.
                            • Mediterranean Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Grilled chicken, onion, tomatoes, olives, mushrooms, green peppers, feta, and mozzarella.
                            • Mac n Cheese Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Mozzarella and mac n cheese.
                            • Favoite Ellis Island Specialty Pizza
                              Priced by add-ons
                              Pepperoni, Pepperoncini peppers, and mozzarella.
                          • Build Your Own Pizza
                              • Cheese Pizza (12" Small)
                              • Cheese Pizza (14" Medium)
                              • Cheese Pizza (16" Large)
                              • Cheese Pizza (18" Extra Large)
                            • Seafood Dinners
                                • Catfish Dinner
                                  6 pieces.
                                • Favoite Jumbo Shrimp Dinner
                                  7 pieces.
                                • Cod Fish & Chips Dinner
                                  4 pieces.
                                • Perch Dinner
                                  6 pieces.
                                • Grilled Tilapia Dinner
                              • Golden Fried Chicken Dinners
                                  • Chicken Strip Dinner
                                    6 pieces.
                                  • 4 Pieces Chicken Dinner
                                    BBQ chicken for an extra charge.
                                  • Chicken Dinner
                                    Priced by add-ons
                                • Texas Split BBQ Ribs Texas Split BBQ Ribs
                                    • BBQ Beef Rib Dinner
                                    • BBQ Pork Rib Dinner
                                  • Greek Dishes
                                      • Gyro Dinner
                                      • Chicken Shish Kabob Sandwich
                                      • Gyro Sandwich
                                      • Chicken Shish Kabob Dinner
                                    • Combo Dinners
                                        • Chef’s Sampler Combo Dinners
                                          4 flavored wild wings of your choice, 3 pieces of BBQ ribs, and 2 pieces of seafood of your choice
                                        • Southern Combo Dinners
                                          Your choice of 2 pieces of chicken tenders, 4 sweet, and tasty BBQ ribs.
                                        • New York Combo Dinners
                                          Your choice of 2 pieces of juicy fried chicken, 2 pieces of battered cod, and 2 pieces of catfish.
                                        • Seafood Combo Dinners
                                          2 pieces of perch, 2 pieces of battered cod, 2 jumbo shrimp, and 2 pieces of catfish.
                                        • Pizza Combo Dinner
                                          A small 1 topping pizza.
                                        • Chicken Combo Dinner
                                          6 flavored wild wings.
                                      • Ice Cream Treats
                                          • Sundaes
                                          • Hot Fudge Ice Cream
                                          • Floats
                                          • Frozen Flurry
                                          • Strawberry Ice Cream
                                          • Malts & Shakes
                                          • Caramel Ice Cream
                                          • Turtle Ice Cream
                                        • Italian Dishes
                                            • Mac ‘N’ Cheese
                                            • Meat Lasagna
                                            • Shrimp Alfredo
                                            • Chicken Alfredo
                                            • Fettuccine Alfredo
                                            • Spaghetti with Marinara
                                            • Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
                                            • Chicken Parmesan
                                          • Sandwich Meals
                                              • B.L.T.
                                              • Double Cheeseburger with French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Grilled Cheese
                                              • Chicken Breast Sandwich with French Fries
                                                Cheese meal.
                                              • Hamburger Meal with Fries
                                              • Corned Beef Sandwic
                                              • Cheeseburger with French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Jumbo Chilli Cheese Dog with French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Cod Fish Sandwich with French Fries
                                                Cheese meal.
                                              • All Beef Jumbo Hot Dog
                                              • Chicken Parmesan with French Fries
                                                Cheese meal.
                                              • Hamburger
                                              • Cod Fish Sandwich
                                              • Gyro Cheeseburger
                                              • Double Hamburger with French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Gyro Cheeseburger with French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Double Cheeseburger
                                              • Cheeseburger
                                              • All Beef Jumbo Hot Dog with French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Corned Beef Sandwich with Fries
                                              • Chicken Breast Sandwich
                                              • B.L.T with French French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Double Hamburger
                                              • Grilled Cheese with French Fries
                                                Meal.
                                              • Jumbo Chilli Cheese Dog
                                              • Chicken Parmesan
                                            • Sub Sandwich Meals
                                                • Club Sub Meal
                                                • Turkey and Cheese Meal with French Fries
                                                • Meatball Sub Meal with French Fries
                                                • Gym Shoe Sandwich Meal
                                                • Philly Cheesesteak Meal with French Fries
                                                • Veggie Sub Meal
                                                • Ham and Cheese Meal
                                                • Italian Beef & Cheese Meal
                                                • Favorite Chicken Philly Cheesesteak Meal
                                                • Italian Beef & Cheese Meal with French Fries
                                                • Ham and Cheese Meal with French Fries
                                                • Gym Shoe Sandwich Meal with French Fries
                                                • Meatball Sub Meal
                                                • Philly Cheesesteak Meal
                                                • Favorite Chicken Philly Cheesesteak Meal with French Fries
                                                • Turkey and Cheese Meal
                                                • Club Sub Meal with French Fries
                                                • Veggie Sub Meal with French Fries
                                                • Italian Sausage
                                              • Kid’s Meal
                                                  • Kid's Chicken Nuggets
                                                    6 pieces. Served with french fries.
                                                • Dessert
                                                    • New York Cheesecake
                                                      All varieties.
                                                    • Sweet Potato Pie
                                                    • Pecan Pie
                                                    • Fudge Brownie
                                                  • Beverages
                                                      • Pepsi Product
                                                        Priced by add-ons
                                                      • Water
                                                    • Catering
                                                        • Pasta
                                                          Priced by add-ons
                                                        • Wild Wings
                                                          Priced by add-ons
                                                        • Desserts
                                                          14PC Slices
                                                        • Italian Beef Tray
                                                          Priced by add-ons
                                                        • Bread Tray
                                                          Priced by add-ons
                                                      5-Star Reviews
                                                      Hear from people who love this spot
                                                      Pola N.
                                                      10 months ago
                                                      I like your chicken alfredo
                                                      Frequently asked questions

                                                      Can I order New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) delivery in Milwaukee with Uber Eats?

                                                      Yes. New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) delivery is available on Uber Eats in Milwaukee.

                                                      Is New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) delivery available near me?

                                                      New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) delivery might not be available everywhere in Milwaukee, so enter your address to see if it’s available near you.

                                                      How do I order New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) delivery online in Milwaukee?

                                                      There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.

                                                      What’s the best thing to order for New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) delivery in Milwaukee?

                                                      What’s best at New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) is totally up to you and your personal preference. If you’re in need of some inspiration, consider trying one of the items featured in “Picked for you.”

                                                      How do I get $0 Delivery Fee at New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) in Milwaukee?

                                                      The Delivery Fees may vary depending on a number of factors, like your location. Enter your Milwaukee address to see the current Delivery Fee. You can also explore the Uber Eats membership and subscription options available in your area to see if you can save money on New York Pizza Delivery (231 E North Ave) delivery with $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.