4.9
130+ Ratings
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"the cookies, if you can call them that, we're so thick and rich with flavor! They were both crumbly and soft."
• Kevin H. • 12/02/22
"these cookies are so delicious. The Banana Pudding is my favorite! love the packaging box as well."
• Bryan F. • 04/09/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
11:00 AM - 5:40 PM
Monday
10:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Tuesday - Saturday
10:00 AM - 6:40 PM
Cookies
- Sea Salt Caramel Pecan$6.00 • 100% (11)Sprinkled with sea salt, these cookies are handcrafted with old fashion caramel and pecan halves in the ultimate southern delight.
Size: 4 inches in diameter, and 2 inches thick!
Crunchy. Gooey. Delicious. - Chocolate Chip$6.00 • 97% (86)Our beloved bestseller chocolate chip is loaded with premium semi sweet chocolate chips in our signature dough.
Size: four" diameter, one-2 inches thick!
Crunchy. Gooey. Delicious. - Snickerdoodle$6.00 • 93% (33)Look no further! We bake your favorite Snickerdoodle.
Indulge in this classic cinnamon and sugar goodness with perfectly toasted exteriors and soft interiors.
Size: 4" diameter and 2" thick! - Golden Goose$6.00 • 94% (35)Our hidden treasure...unit now!
Freshly baked with Golden Oreos, white chocolate, and hand rolled in delicate sprinkles for an extra crunch.
Size: 6-ounces, 4" diameter & 2" thick!
Crunchy. Gooey. Delicious. - Cookies & Cream$6.00 • 95% (83)Handcrafted with milk chocolate, delicious white chocolate chunks, and crushed Oreos for the ultimate Cookies & Cream delight!
Baked to perfection with a crunchy exterior and deliciously gooey center.
Size: 4' diameter, and 2" thick! - Banana Pudding$6.00 • 95% (24)Irresistibly delicious!
Our Banana Pudding cookie is handcrafted with fresh bananas, Nilla Wafers, and filled with a banana pudding center, and topped with a homemade whip and Nilla Wafer.
If you love banana pudding, then you'll love this gourmet treat! - Campfire Bliss$6.00 • 98% (54)One bite and this cookie will have you daydreaming of roasting marshmallows by the campfire!
Baked with milk chocolate chips, honey graham crackers, and filled with a toasted marshmallow.
Size: four" diameter, one-2 inches thick!
Crunchy. Gooey. Delicious. - Red Velvet Cream Cheese$6.00 • 95% (65)Our Red Velvet Cream Cheese is the perfect combination of flavors!
Delicious red velvet cookie baked with milk chocolate, and filled with cream cheese frosting in the center.
Size: four" diameter, one-2 inches thick! - Dozen Minis - Chocolate Chip$26.00 • 100% (14)Milk Mustache Minis are the perfect size for sharing!
Whether you’re treating yourself, or gifting to make a lasting impression, these minis are a guaranteed winner.
Cookies are delicately packed by the dozen in a clear cellophane bag, and tied off with a ribbon to lock in freshness. - Vintage Peanut Butter$6.00 • 100% (3)Our "Vintage Peanut Butter" is baked to perfection and handcrafted with the finest ingredients, these cookies boast a perfect balance of rich, nutty flavor and a buttery, melt-in-your-mouth texture.
A true Milk Mustache experience! - Dr. Pepper Float$6.00Weekly feature, available for a limited time only!
Take your taste buds on a fizzy and flavorful journey like never before with our Dr. Pepper Float cookie! It's a combination of an irresistible chocolate brownie base with the creamy decadence of house-made Dr. Pepper buttercream for a memorable and delicious Dr. Pepper Float in a cookie experience! - Texas Cowboy Cookie$6.00Saddle up for our Texas Cowboy Cookie - Featuring a hearty mix of oatmeal, crunchy pecans, rich chocolate chips, and sweet coconut. It's the ultimate cookie experience, capturing the big flavors of Texas.
Treat yourself to a taste of the Wild West with Milk Mustache's Texas Cowboy Cookie! - Crookie (Croissant Cookie)$7.00Introducing our Crookie: a masterful blend of flaky croissant layers and delectable chocolate chip cookie dough baked to perfection.
This culinary experience offers the best of both worlds, combining the buttery, airy texture of a croissant with the sweet, chewy goodness of our classic best seller, chocolate chip cookie.
Savor the fusion, share the joy! - Key Lime Pie$6.00Weekly feature, available for a limited time only!
Fresh, light, and delicious is the best way to describe our homemade Key Lime Pie cookie.
Handcrafted with a vanilla base and honey graham crackers and topped with our homemade key lime buttercream using all-natural and fresh ingredients. - Minis Variety Pack$26.00Introducing our Minis Variety Pack Assortment! Beautifully stacked and presented in a clear cellophane bag, tied with a delightful ribbon, this gift-ready pack features four delectable flavors: Birthday Cake, Brownie Bites, Chocolate Chip, and Sea Salt Caramel Pecan. Each mini cookie is baked to perfection, offering a burst of flavor and a satisfying crunch in every bite. Perfect for any occasion, this variety pack from Milk Mustache is guaranteed to spread joy and make life sweet.
Treat yourself or share the love today!
Edible Cookie Dough
- Chocolate Chip - Edible Cookie Dough$4.00Indulge in our nostalgic Chocolate Chip house-made edible cookie dough. Each spoonful is rich in flavor and made with premium ingredients and crafted with care.
Serving Size: Single Scoop
Storage: Keep refrigerated
(Safe to eat. Heat treated flour, no eggs.)Popular - Cookies & Cream - Edible Cookie Dough$4.00Treat yourself to a delicious scoop of our house-made Cookies & Cream edible cookie dough! Each spoonful is rich in flavor and made with premium ingredients that include Oreo cookies, white chocolate, and milk chocolate chips and is crafted with care.
Serving Size: Single Scoop
Storage: Keep refrigerated
(Safe to eat. Heat treated flour, no eggs.) - Cotton Candy - Edible Cookie Dough$4.00Our house-made blue Cotton Candy edible cookie dough is fun and delicious! Each spoonful is rich in flavor and made with premium ingredients and is crafted with care.
Serving Size: Single Scoop
Storage: Keep refrigerated
(Safe to eat. Heat treated flour, no eggs.)
- Rating and reviews
4.9
•130+ Ratings •
16 Reviews
Michael D.• 06/03/24Great cookies …
Jeremy P.• 05/27/24Great cookies
Victoria B.• 05/24/24yummy cookies
Meenu S.• 04/22/24Delicious cookies
Jerry W.• 04/15/24good cookies
Mika N.• 03/04/24Everything’s was perfect when arrived ! Thanks for the cookies and for the delivery !!!!!
Nyeshia B.• 03/01/24Very tasty and fresh
Christopher H.• 01/14/24The best cookies I ever had, hands down. Milk Mustache hits the spot for comfort food.
Ayla R.• 12/30/23Literally the best
Nyeshia B.• 12/03/23Love them
Christopher H.• 11/22/23Literally the best thing delivered to you at 6pm!
Mary H.• 08/28/23There are no words. I would drive into a desert to get these cookies. They are that good. Bravo.
Mary H.• 07/22/23Delicious and great gifts for friends or family.
Enmary P.• 05/15/23excellent
Bryan F.• 04/09/23these cookies are so delicious. The Banana Pudding is my favorite! love the packaging box as well.
Kevin H.• 12/02/22the cookies, if you can call them that, we're so thick and rich with flavor! They were both crumbly and soft.
