4.8
1000+ Ratings
Mario's Pizzeria (Oyster Bay)
4.8 x (1,000+) • $0 Delivery Fee • 2589.5 mi • Pizza • Italian • Comfort Food • Kids Friendly • Family Friendly • Family Meals • Affordable Meals • Sandwich • Sandwiches • Pasta • Group Friendly • $ • Info
x Delivered by store staff
x Delivery unavailable
253 Pine Hollow Rd
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"The quality of the food is always excellent. You will never be disappointed."
• Jon H. • 03/16/24
"Penne alla vodka so good but the artichoke pizza omg it amazing thank you"
• Erica L. • 03/11/24
$0 Delivery Fee
Pricing & fees
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
10:30 AM - 9:30 PM
Friday - Saturday
10:30 AM - 10:00 PM
Featured items
Free with $30 purchase
Pizza
- Slice Neapolitan Pizza$4.25 • 97% (109)Triangle slice.
- 18" Neapolitan (Round) Pizza$23.95 • 94% (314)8 slices.
We use 100% real mozzarella cheese from Wisconsin. Our tomatoes are sourced from California. Our dough is made fresh daily on premises. - 12" Thin Crust Pizzette$15.95 • 98% (62)12" pizza. 6 slices.
- Slice Sicilian Pizza$4.50 • 92% (26)Square slice.
- 16" Sicilian (Square) Pizza$25.95 • 97% (38)12 slices.
- 10" Cauliflower Gluten-Free Thin Crust Pizzette$16.95 • 100% (40)10" cauliflower gluten free pizza. 6 slices.
- 8.5" Pan Pizzette$15.95 • 96% (27)8.5" pan pizza. 4 slices.
- 12" Gluten-Free Thin Crust Pizzette$16.95 • 93% (15)12" gluten free pizza. 6 slices.Gluten Free
- 12" Whole Wheat Thin Crust Pizzette$16.9512" whole wheat pizza. 6 slices.
Gourmet Pizzas
- Grandma Pizza$5.00 • 96% (103)Square thin crust pizza with fresh mozzarella, fresh basil leaves, and crushed tomatoes.
- Buffalo Pizza$5.75 • 96% (65)With mozzarella. Spicy.
- BBQ Chicken Pizza$5.75With mozzarella.Popular
- Penne Alla Vodka Pizza$5.50 • 91% (47)
- Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza$5.75 • 90% (40)
- Old Fashioned Pizza$5.50 • 89% (28)Fresh mozzarella, crushed tomato, and fresh basil.
- Marinara Pizza$4.25 • 100% (17)Marinara sauce, a touch of Romano, and no mozzarella.
- Chicago Meat Lovers Pizza$7.25Sausage, pepperoni, meatball, mozzarella, provolone, and tomato sauce. Deep dish.
- Broccoli Rabe Pizza$5.75 • 100% (13)Broccoli rabe, sundried tomatoes, and grilled chicken topped with mozzarella on a square thin crust.
- Mario's Special Pizza$5.75Sausage, pepperoni, meatball, peppers, onions, mushrooms, extra cheese, and anchovies (optional).
Calzone & Rolls
Appetizers
Homemade Soup Of The Day
Entrées
Pasta Specialities
Hero Sandwiches
Fresh Baked Panini & Wraps
Pasta & Casseroles
Salads
Side Orders
Dessert
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•1000+ Ratings •
25 Reviews
Jon H.• 05/01/24no matter what you order,it is always good.
Jon H.• 04/20/24consistency of excellent food always
Joann A.• 03/28/24great food
Joseph M.• 03/24/24Great meals
Jon H.• 03/16/24The quality of the food is always excellent. You will never be disappointed.
Erica L.• 03/11/24Penne alla vodka so good but the artichoke pizza omg it amazing thank you
craig M.• 03/09/24Great food!
Jon H.• 02/24/24one of the best pizzas around.Along with the other food that they serve.
Rinaldo I.• 02/04/24great service
Lisa V.• 02/02/24Love their pizza and salads!
Jon H.• 11/12/23The food is always excellent!
Tim M.• 10/12/23Delicious and thanks for the baked ziti!!
cristian M.• 09/23/23everything nice! i love yours sauces!
Maggie H.• 09/21/23Thank you!
Joseph M.• 08/26/23Great meal
Osman O.• 08/25/23it was delicious and prepared excellent!
Alexis C.• 07/30/23Quick and efficient!!
Alexis C.• 07/21/23Amazing entrees always!!
Mercedes R.• 07/01/23Great
ALMUER M.• 06/03/23Delicious
Alexis C.• 05/02/23The best entrees!!
Lisette R.• 09/29/22Always delicious and crispy!
Peter S.• 08/11/22Everything was delicious. Nice job fam!
Lisette R.• 06/11/22Delicious!! Worth the wait
Paul H.• 01/28/22The food wass delicious and hot.
