4.7
6000+ Ratings
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Restaurant (Garden City)
4.7 x (6,000+) • 2584.7 mi • Italian • Pasta • Comfort Food • Family Meals • Group Friendly • Exclusive to Eats • $ • Info
2429 Jericho Tpke
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"By far, the House Salad with Grilled Chicken & Mozzarella is my favorite salad around! The house dressing is incredible! And try the Chicken alla Vodka - you won't be disappointed! Be sure to get extra dressing & sauce for take-out. You'll need it!"
• Donald P. • 04/16/23
"Never had a bad selection! The chicken alla vodka is one of my favorites! And you must have the garden salad with grilled chicken and fresh mozzarella!!! Don't forget to ask for extra house dressing. It's delicious and there's never enough!"
• Donald P. • 11/06/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
3:00 PM - 8:45 PM • Dinner
11:00 AM - 3:00 PM • Lunch
Friday - Saturday
3:00 PM - 9:45 PM • Dinner
11:00 AM - 3:00 PM • Lunch
Featured items
Appetizers
Lunch Salads
Salads
Soups
Lunch Pastas
Pastas
Baked Pasta
Heros
Entrees
Platters
Side Pastas
Panini
Sauteed Vegetables
Side Orders
Pizzettas
Pizza Pies
Specialty Pies
Slices
Calzones
Rolls
Desserts
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•6000+ Ratings •
103 Reviews
Denise N.• 05/18/24Quality food
Paul C.• 05/05/24Eggplant parmigiana is delicious.
Toodie F.• 04/29/24Best Italian food in Nassau county. Im the happiest camper with my chopped grilled chicken salad. Chefs kiss!!
Maria V.• 04/29/24The best Italian food I have ever eaten and quick delivery
Meghan G.• 04/20/24Fresh food every time!
ALEKSANDRE K.• 04/10/24Fas delivery
Piero G.• 03/24/24Great tasting food
Jean Z.• 03/24/24The food is always fresh and excellent!
Sudeep K.• 03/22/24Always consistent. Delicious food.
Jean Z.• 03/09/24Food is consistently very good!
Jean R.• 02/25/24Best food
Maria V.• 02/16/24The best everything
Norma S.• 02/11/24Very good
Tiffany M.• 02/03/24Food is delicious and affordable
Annie W.• 01/30/24delicious
Jean R.• 01/01/24It’s the best pizzeria and Italian restaurant.
Miranda V.• 12/31/23Food never disappoints
Michael T.• 12/28/23Reliable food and service.
Helene R.• 12/19/23Great
Sudeep K.• 12/18/23The food is always great and on point here.
Norma S.• 12/16/23Every is perfect the soup is delicious
Anthony M.• 12/08/23Great Italian Food!!! DuhLish!!!!
Jean Z.• 12/07/23Everything is always delicious! Best soups and pastas. First time trying the meatballs. They were excellent.
Paul C.• 12/04/23Great food and good portions.
mimi S.• 12/01/23meatballs and pasta excellent
Jean Z.• 11/26/23Always excellent! Best soups, pasta, and salads!
M T.• 11/20/23This place is so great and everything is always freshly made and tasty
Paul C.• 11/10/23Food is always good.
Donald P.• 11/06/23Never had a bad selection! The chicken alla vodka is one of my favorites! And you must have the garden salad with grilled chicken and fresh mozzarella!!! Don't forget to ask for extra house dressing. It's delicious and there's never enough!
Jean Z.• 11/04/23As always, excellent food! Best soups too!
Justin H.• 11/02/23Great food
Maira B.• 11/01/23Quick Delivery!
Jean Z.• 10/31/23The food is always excellent with a great selection.
Debra K.• 10/19/23Taste like homemade Italian food. So delicious and a lot of choices
carol D.• 10/15/23its great
Jason V.• 10/12/23Best pizza in New Hyde Park
Jean Z.• 10/08/23Great food every time. Best soups and rice balls and pasta!
Jean Z.• 10/02/23Excellent food! Good portions.
Laurie D.• 09/26/23Pizza and rice balls were delicious!
Jean Z.• 09/25/23Excellent food!
Theresa S.• 09/06/23Delicious!
Jason V.• 09/06/23Best pizza in New Hyde park
Edward G.• 08/27/23Great family style dinner
Jean C.• 08/25/23Always great
Jean C.• 08/25/23Food always great ! Delivered on time
Theresa S.• 08/23/23Yummy
Brandon P.• 08/15/23delicioso
Matthew G.• 08/14/23Fresh
james m. E.• 08/12/23Always great
Edward G.• 08/12/23Kids love the Rigatoni with fried chicken cutlet. Great portion sizes!
Theresa S.• 08/09/23So delicious and fresh
Juliana L.• 08/03/23Great food!!
Theresa S.• 08/02/23So delicious
Tea A.• 08/02/23Great
Mia C.• 08/01/23great food
SUDESH S.• 07/23/23Excellent taste!
Chloe L.• 07/17/23Authentic
Cathy C.• 07/16/23Delicious
Guy D.• 07/10/23Food was delicious and good portions
Danielle M.• 07/08/23Great food and great service.
Paul C.• 07/07/23Delicious.
Danielle N.• 07/06/23I always get the balsamic chicken and penne in pink sauce. It is my favorite!!
Maria V.• 07/03/23It’s always fantastic
Shannese G.• 06/22/23Delicious 😋
Anthony M.• 06/16/23Great food!
cyril T.• 06/09/23great food
Cathy C.• 06/08/23I always order this from here always!! I love it!!!
Kiera K.• 06/07/23Best tasting food around here!
Sofia Q.• 06/04/23Amazing stuff
Allie C.• 06/03/23Delish
Paul C.• 05/28/23Good food all the time.
Ali M.• 05/14/23We made a very large order and everything was perfect!
Maria V.• 05/02/23It’s the best Italian restaurant and it comes quickly
Laura K.• 05/01/23Quick, delicious
Maria V.• 05/01/23We ordered other food there many times and always delicious and delivered promptly, so we decided to try the pizza and it was delicious and prompt delivery
Stephen G.• 04/29/23Excellent food which is packed well for delivery
Donald P.• 04/16/23By far, the House Salad with Grilled Chicken & Mozzarella is my favorite salad around! The house dressing is incredible! And try the Chicken alla Vodka - you won't be disappointed! Be sure to get extra dressing & sauce for take-out. You'll need it!
Toni W.• 04/05/23Always delicious
MRS S.• 04/04/23Fresh, tasty food
Amneris M.• 03/23/23yummy food
Jeffrey P.• 03/11/23Woot!!
Piero G.• 02/23/23Great food!
Jean Z.• 02/04/23Great food, best soups, salads, pizzettes, and tiramisu!
Jean Z.• 01/30/23Best soups, salad, and pasta!
Diana N.• 01/07/23all the food is fresh and made to order and delicious! never had a bad meal from Mama Theresa's.
Matt R.• 12/24/22top taste and consistency
Nyesha M.• 12/20/22good eats
Bella K.• 11/28/22Made fresh to order. Always tasty and reliable quality!
Bella K.• 11/24/22Made to order. Very fast. Always busy… because it’s delicious!!
Stephen G.• 10/17/22Always great food!
Sandra Q.• 10/05/22Great food!
Christina M.• 10/02/22Fast and good
Douglas R.• 06/28/22Thanks
Louis F.• 03/03/22Linguine with fresh clams in white the clam sauce sa
Royce SK S.• 02/10/22Love, love, love their mussels. The best.
Carter Anne M.• 02/06/22Buffalo pizza from MT is heaven
Beth G.• 01/06/22Awesome!
Paul C.• 12/12/21Great Italian food.
Royce SK S.• 11/24/21Love the clam sauce pasta! As always! Even the pizza was good. So was the mussels (in massive love with the Diavolo sauce!!)
Beth G.• 11/18/21best grilled chicked and salad
Regina P.• 10/25/21everything was hot and delicious
Roberto M.• 08/20/21Great work and the order was fresh and hot.
dwight O.• 07/23/21Delicious and quick
