4.7
2000+ Ratings
Mama Lisa Restaurant
4.7 x (2,000+) • 2625.1 mi • Italian • Pasta • Pizza • Group Friendly • $ • Info
1226 Montauk Hwy
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"It's Fantastic Every Time I Love This Place! Additional Note: A bonus from Mama Lisa compared to similar restaurants is that you're able to get chicken added to the Alfredo which surprisingly isn't a option at many other places I looked"
• Branden S. • 04/02/23
"Mama Lisa never disappoints. Food was delicious as always. Thanks so much to Uber for allowing us to be able to enjoy a good meal. Cynthia got it here hot and on time."
• rose S. • 01/26/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
From the Counter From the Counter
Calzones & Pizza Pops Calzones & Pizza Pops
Desserts Desserts
Appetizers | Antipasti Appetizers | Antipasti
Beverages Beverages
Chicken Specialties | Pollo Chicken Specialties | Pollo
Classic Baked Oven Dishes | Pasta Al Forno Classic Baked Oven Dishes | Pasta Al Forno
Eggplant Entrees | Melenzane Eggplant Entrees | Melenzane
Heroes Heroes
Hot Soups | Zuppe Calde Hot Soups | Zuppe Calde
Pasta Dishes Pasta Dishes
Pizza | By The Slice Pizza | By The Slice
Pizza | Dalla Pizza | Dalla
Pizza | Specialty Pizza | Specialty
Salads | Insalate Salads | Insalate
Seafood Entrees | Frutti Di Mare E Pesce Seafood Entrees | Frutti Di Mare E Pesce
Side Orders | Contorini Side Orders | Contorini
Veal Entrees | Vitello Veal Entrees | Vitello
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•2000+ Ratings •
64 Reviews
lisa M.• 05/06/24Delicious! flavor is always on point. the best pizza around. Sauce, cheese, crust. Pizza is king.
Mustafa D.• 05/02/24Great Sicilian pizza 🍕
Aldo A.• 04/25/24Na
Vito P.• 04/18/24You make the best chicken rolatini I’ve ever eaten. If o could eat it daily I would lol
Guy B.• 04/01/24Great food quick delivery, feel like I am in Italy. The real deal.
Tom T.• 03/24/24Great food, consistently fantastic
Christa S.• 03/12/24Gluten free options
Denise B.• 02/25/24Great pizza at a great price!
meghan D.• 02/18/24always great food and prices are fair
Chelsea C.• 02/18/24Mama Lisa always makes the best food. It’s good every single time.
April N.• 02/12/24best pizza around!
Adri J.• 02/03/24Yummy
lisa M.• 01/29/24My Stuff Pizza order was Amazing! packed with cheese!!!!! delicious and the meat was not too salty
Anthony S.• 01/27/24love that square slice. keep it up
rose S.• 01/26/24Mama Lisa never disappoints. Food was delicious as always. Thanks so much to Uber for allowing us to be able to enjoy a good meal. Cynthia got it here hot and on time.
Sherry P.• 01/15/24Their food never disappoints!
Andrew H.• 01/14/24Great food as always
Philip C.• 12/21/23Great food
Jaspet V.• 12/15/23Best pizza in town
Philip C.• 12/15/23My favorite place on Long Island
Philip C.• 12/06/23I have not had a bad experience with this place. Everything is top notch
HEATHER L.• 12/05/23Absolutely amazing! Every thing on the menu is delicious! Yum!!
Philip C.• 12/03/23The food is outstanding
Jay L.• 11/22/23Great pasta
Philip C.• 11/19/23I’ve been eating here for quite a while and everything is delicious
April N.• 11/15/23good food
Ben C.• 11/14/23Best authentic food in the area hands down.
Philip C.• 10/23/23Because it’s really good food
Christa S.• 10/22/23Great gluten free options
KAITLYN S.• 10/18/23My go to for the best Italian food!!
Jason B.• 10/02/23Best Italian in town!
Parlato K.• 10/02/23Food is great
Diane R.• 09/30/23Food is excellent
Linda S.• 09/23/23It’s the best Italian restaurant around! :)
RENEE S.• 09/02/23The pizza is very good
Kym P.• 08/28/23yummmmy
Gina B.• 08/16/23Local and Awsome.
ADRIANNA M.• 08/15/23I order from here at least once a week!! You could never go wrong with any dish but my favorite go to is the Alfredo w/ fettuccine and grilled chicken!
Rose P.• 08/12/23Amazing!
Kathy S.• 07/08/23Good
Christian A.• 04/03/23Dope.
Branden S.• 04/02/23It's Fantastic Every Time I Love This Place! Additional Note: A bonus from Mama Lisa compared to similar restaurants is that you're able to get chicken added to the Alfredo which surprisingly isn't a option at many other places I looked
Jason B.• 02/17/23Been going there over 20 years, food is consistent, and excellent!
Normel S.• 02/07/23Pizza
Javier C.• 02/04/23Excellent!
JONATHAN C.• 01/03/23Always very tasty.
David P.• 12/18/22The food is always consistently excellent, great generous portions and priced right.
Thomas L.• 12/12/22Always excellent
Andrea P.• 12/06/22Everything I've ever eaten at Mama Lisa is delicious 😋
Ben C.• 11/30/22Great food great service
David P.• 11/30/22Always a great meal, plenty of food, very good value.
Michael T.• 10/01/22Generous portions and good food.
Thomas L.• 09/20/22Sauce was delicious
Javier C.• 07/17/22incredible!
Paige P.• 04/28/22Always good, i dont order pasta or pizza from anywhere else
Tabatha C.• 03/08/22Fast delivery... Tasty as usual
John L.• 01/20/22Delicious as always !!!
Marisol C.• 12/28/21Excellent
Alexandra B.• 12/27/21Great food goid value
Robin S.• 12/22/21Excellent
Mara H.• 10/13/21It was my first time ordering a pie there, half plain half peperoni. It was delicious and they didn't skimp on the peperoni. Will order again!
peter T.• 09/13/21Very good
Lisa B.• 08/26/21Friendly delivery person!
Katie S.• 08/23/21My favorite place for pizza and Italian food. My family loves that they offer so many gluten free options.
