4.7
4000+ Ratings
Make My Fish
4.7 x (4,000+) • Comfort Food • Wings • Fish and Chips • Seafood • Black-owned • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
120 W 116th St
Make My Fish, located in Central Harlem, Manhattan, is a seafood restaurant that delights its patrons with a variety of fish and shrimp dishes. Popular menu items include All Fish, Shrimp and Fish Combo (includ... More
Make My Fish, located in Central Harlem, Manhattan, is a seafood restaurant that delights its patrons with a variety of fish and shrimp dishes. Popular menu items include All Fish, Shrimp and Fish Combo (including fries), Shrimp and Chips, and the Fish Dinner, with French Fries and All Fish often ordered together. The menu also features comforting side orders like Macaroni and Cheese, Collard Greens, and Cole Slaw, along with a selection of beverages such as Lemonade and Ice Tea. With a customer rating rounding to 4.2, this restaurant is a favored choice during the evening. Less
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"One of the best Fish & Chips joint in NYC. The food is well seasoned, never overly seasoned. The fish and shrimp are a nice crisp to them. I like the shrimp, catfish, and whiting combo. I eat from this dish for 2 days."
• Jocelyn P. • 04/29/24
"The portions are generous. The potato salad made me homesick. It was all so delicious. What a refreshing UE experience..to actually get food that looks and taste BETTER than it's pictures."
• Sonya S. • 02/16/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
Monday - Thursday
11:30 AM - 8:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Whiting Fish Fillet
- Fish and Chips$12.00 • 92% (864)Four pieces.
- Fish Dinner$19.75 • 94% (516)Four pieces. Includes two sides.
- All Fish$13.00 • 94% (1019)Six pieces.
- Fish & Shrimp Dinner$26.00 • 96% (150)
- Fish Sandwich$11.00 • 95% (440)four pieces.
- Fish and Shrimp Combo(incl Fries)$22.50 • 95% (264)Includes fries.
- Fish and Grits$14.50 • 93% (115)
- Fish & Side$15.00Fish and choice of 1 side
Catfish Fillet
Shrimp Jumbo
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•4000+ Ratings •
180 Reviews
Evonnia T.• 09/07/24Delicious I bite my tongue
Monisha R.• 09/06/24Absolutely Delicious
Melissa B.• 09/06/24Fresh. Hot. Good.
Vida A.• 08/29/24good and I enjoyed it well
Wilhelmina T.• 08/25/24Good eating
Kahmyiah L.• 08/17/24I Have This For Lunch Once A Week. They Never Disappoint
ann C.• 08/14/24Hot and delicious
Lawrence W.• 08/08/24the best
Wilhelmina T.• 08/08/24Good fresh
Lizzette W.• 07/18/24The food is always so good
Brenda R.• 07/17/24It was so good
nekel S.• 07/13/24Food is always delicious and good portion size. Staff is friendly
Randy C.• 07/07/24perfect
Rich B.• 07/02/24Delicious every time.
adiylah T.• 07/02/24Great guy
Rich B.• 06/19/24Always delicious.
Chris F.• 06/15/24Good eats
irena M.• 06/12/24good
patrick C.• 06/12/24Excellent service.
Timothy J.• 06/04/24Yes
Russell S.• 06/01/24Taste very good
JAMANI H.• 05/30/24Everything is always made fresh and taste fresh and is hot when I receive my food
Bonita O.• 05/26/24good food
Stephanie E.• 05/24/24Amazing as always!!!!
Cyd C.• 05/23/24Elite
Stacey B.• 05/17/24Fish is very good
Calvin D.• 05/15/24good food
Russell S.• 05/11/24Taste good good price
Jacqueline D.• 05/09/24Yum. Yum. Yum...
Devante G.• 05/02/24Food always bussin
tara T.• 05/02/24Fish is always nice and fresh so good
patrick C.• 05/01/24Amazing food as always
Jacqueline D.• 04/30/24Tasty, fresh and consistently delicious...
Jocelyn P.• 04/29/24One of the best Fish & Chips joint in NYC. The food is well seasoned, never overly seasoned. The fish and shrimp are a nice crisp to them. I like the shrimp, catfish, and whiting combo. I eat from this dish for 2 days.
Randy T.• 04/26/24Great fish sandwich.
Fatima M.• 04/26/24Everything was delicious
Lamont J.• 04/24/24Tasty very cultural and good got to love fish and chip
irena M.• 04/22/24good food
Jacqueline D.• 04/19/24My favorite fish joint...Fried to perfection. You rock, Alex!
Ronald J.• 04/09/24Thank you Make my Fish always the best in the world I always enjoy spot on seasoning The best tasting fish I have ever haved
Wilhelmina T.• 04/07/24Always enjoy the fish
Tanesha G.• 04/05/24Food is always amazing 👏🏾
Jacqueline D.• 04/03/24Lightly coated deliciousness! Perfect for my taste and my ONLY choice when I want fried fish, hands down.
Julia N.• 04/03/24Nice food
Danny J.• 04/02/24Nice
Nico A.• 03/01/24Absolute perfection, next time I’m coming in person to place my order. Thank you for excellent service. My students enjoyed it, as I shared with them as well.
irena M.• 03/30/24good food
Jacqueline D.• 03/26/24Delicious, as usual. My favorite fish spot...
Yvonne H.• 03/24/24It’s consistent good
Evangeline C.• 03/23/24There fish and shrimp are amazingly delicious
Michele N.• 03/16/24Taste, and thanks for having enough…. My students look forward me sharing….
Joddell H.• 03/16/24Catfish is always delicious!
stephanie H.• 03/15/24The food always fresh taste amazing
Elizabeth C.• 03/12/24tasty
Jacqueline D.• 03/08/24Fresh & tasty every time.
Pamela G.• 03/05/24I love this place the ppl and the food is the bomb 🥰
Katrina B.• 02/27/24great
Mamie B.• 02/13/24Their Food is Absolutely Delicious Everytime!!
Yomara H.• 02/06/24Great food
DESTINY M.• 02/03/24Great customer service
Michele N.• 02/02/24Food is good, and it’s a fore filling meal
Bria C.• 02/01/24A delicious neighborhood jewel, always on point
Lisa G.• 02/01/24Arrives hot and absolutely delicious. 10 Stars.
Darlene R.• 01/19/24“Great price, piping hot food,!”
Tenisha R.• 01/19/24Great portion
Kennequa C.• 12/29/23Always hot and tasty!
Katrina B.• 12/29/23good
Paris H.• 12/22/23Because his batter stays consistent and is always good.
Katrina B.• 12/20/23perfect taste
Gregory S.• 12/17/23best fish in harlem
Alacia M.• 12/15/23Food was delicious !!!
Katrina B.• 12/07/23great food
Katrina B.• 12/06/23so good and always fresh
A A.• 12/01/23Yummy…yummy
Katrina B.• 12/01/23fresh and tasty always
June W.• 11/29/23Food is fresh, tasty, and great price.
AD H.• 11/18/23Smooth
Carolee S.• 11/15/23It’s my new lunch thang!!
Liz G.• 11/12/23Great quality, good portion!
TAMIKA J.• 11/07/23The best seafood in Harlem
Luther B.• 10/24/23Fresh food
Darlene R.• 10/19/23Often fresh and well prepared!
Queen R.• 10/12/23Fresh & Tasty!!
Quinney R.• 09/30/23The food is always good
Delicia H.• 09/27/23Fish and shrimp are my favorite
Keesh R.• 09/21/23Yummy, delicious and fresh!!
Wilhelmina T.• 09/16/23Tasty
Warren M.• 09/09/23The food is excellent
Shannon J. E.• 09/01/23Best catfish I’ve had in ages!
Terrence W.• 08/26/23Always on point.
Shaquan W.• 08/26/23Food is good
Stephon B.• 08/25/23Nice conversation friendly person
Amanda T.• 08/24/23Amazing as always!!
Supreme L.• 08/22/23Delicious food
Redd C.• 08/22/23The Whiting and Shrimp with fries Combo is Huge and Delicious! Largest in Harlem! The best fried shrimp I ever had! Perfection! Fast delivery 10/10
Shauntia N.• 08/19/23The best fish in Harlem
Alicia G.• 08/19/23Taste is always great
Calvin D.• 08/17/23very good food and staff
Melissa M.• 08/10/23Always fresh and tasty 😋
Queen R.• 08/03/23Great!
Kendra S.• 08/02/23Delicious food. It never disappoints!
william B.• 07/01/23great catfish frying, the best grits in New York
Melissa M.• 07/29/23Love it so much 😉
Latrice L.• 07/27/23fish and shrimp was delicious
Tawanda J.• 07/25/23Best fried shrimp I ever had . Thank u
Howard H.• 07/20/23Food is always fresh and delicious upon delivery
Queen R.• 07/15/23Fresh & Tasty!
Theresa B.• 07/14/23They have one of the best catfish,shrimp, and grits... Its a MUST TRY!
denise G.• 07/08/23They're always pleasant. They always get it right and the fish is fresh and delicious!
Uthman A.• 07/05/23Tasty affordable.
Tanesha G.• 07/04/23fish and shrimp are always good!
Christina E.• 07/02/23You can’t go wrong! Consistently good.
Melissa M.• 07/01/23love them, seafood is fresh and tasty, also best tartar sauce.
Victoria P.• 07/01/23THAT CATFISH!!! My God
Queen R.• 06/30/23Fresh & Tasty!
Juanita T.• 06/29/23Food is delicious! Seasoned right! ❤️🤤
Supreme L.• 06/28/23delicious food
Jacqueline D.• 06/27/23Lightly coated, which I LOVE! Fresh and tasty. Definitely my favorite fried fish and shrimp spot. Hands down!
Darlene R.• 06/24/23Just the best fried fish around. Fresh, well prepared lovely portions!
Jacqueline D.• 06/21/23Best fried fish and shrimp, IMO. Definitely my go to.
Supreme L.• 06/20/23oh my goodness the food was delicious 😋
Denise B.• 06/19/23Delicious
TAMIKA J.• 06/15/23The food is delicious and always fresh.
Gilroy M.• 06/11/23it's delicious
Lele M.• 06/10/23Fast , friendly and the FOOD IS EXCELLENT!
Yarabi S.• 06/08/23everything is really well seasoned and fresh
Taryn S.• 06/02/23Great
Queen R.• 05/24/23Fresh to the Gills!!
Janet A.• 05/14/23Delicious
Robert M.• 04/13/23the food is just remarkable al and those guys over there are killing it much love to them.
Lida A.• 04/11/23Fresh and well prepared toasty fish and sides!
Kisha C.• 04/10/23Always fresh, hot and well seasoned. Make my fish never fails!!!
Queen R.• 04/01/23Nice, Fresh & Tasty!
Robert M.• 03/01/23excellent
Black G.• 03/03/23❤ amazing
Fatima D.• 02/23/23Amazing
Lida A.• 02/17/23The fish and chicken is so good and fresh!
Sonya S.• 02/16/23The portions are generous. The potato salad made me homesick. It was all so delicious. What a refreshing UE experience..to actually get food that looks and taste BETTER than it's pictures.
Cydney J.• 02/11/23The fish was fresh! Everything was delicious!
Mega M.• 01/27/23Tasty!
Kennequa C.• 12/02/22Always fresh and tasty! And they gave you all the sauce you need.
Jacqueline D.• 11/04/22Finally, fish fried exactly the way I like it! The food is tasty, fresh and well presented.
Barbara S.• 10/20/22The Fish is always fresh and Delicious
Franciane C.• 09/28/22Fresh and yummy
Kevin D.• 09/13/22Great
Pinkky L.• 08/23/22Food delicious 😋
Tequila D.• 08/20/22Delicious!
Queen R.• 08/13/22It was Great!
Crystal B.• 08/03/22Great
Ronald T.• 07/01/22Loved it!!! Fish & chips, Mac & cheese, collards & yams
Candice E.• 06/24/22Great food. Very delicious
Lakisha H.• 06/18/22Tasty
Marshall F.• 06/15/22Perfect as usual!
Luther B.• 06/05/22Always delicious
Gail R.• 05/25/22Absolutely Good
Hubert B.• 05/21/22VERY GOOD FISH!!!
Ophelia E.• 05/19/22The Food was fresh and delicious as usual
Hubert B.• 05/14/22VERY GOOD!!!
KRISTINA A.• 05/04/22I love eating food from this restaurant.
DeeC C.• 04/01/22Fantastic!
Raymond T.• 03/13/22GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE
Dolison D.• 03/04/22Shrimp is to die for
regina C.• 03/04/22The food is always great.
Raymond T.• 02/27/22GREAT
Sharonne L.• 02/11/22Perfect in every way
Dee M.• 02/08/22Polite
Annette Y.• 02/01/22Great price
John W.• 01/29/22Speedy and careful.
Kelli D.• 01/21/22SO GOOD AND ALWAYS FRESH
Rayshawn S.• 01/08/22Fire
Marlo D.• 11/30/21great
Meredith J.• 11/20/21unbelievably good. Food came warm and crispy
Dorothy B.• 11/11/21Very delicious. Good to the last bite.
Rema W.• 10/16/21Food was great. Fast & friendly delivery service! Great experience
Shí W.• 09/11/21Good
Theresa C.• 08/29/21Food is fresh & delicious
Kelli D.• 08/13/21always fresh
Sharonne L.• 08/07/21Great and prompt service
Sheila G.• 07/07/21FAST AND FRESH!!
Sheila G.• 07/07/21FAST AND FRESH NOW THATS WHAT'S UP!!
Can I order Make My Fish delivery in New York with Uber Eats?
Yes. Make My Fish delivery is available on Uber Eats in New York.
Is Make My Fish delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Make My Fish delivery is available to your location in New York.
How do I order Make My Fish delivery online in New York?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Make My Fish menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Make My Fish online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Make My Fish here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Make My Fish order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Make My Fish order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Make My Fish delivery in New York?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Make My Fish order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
