4.8
8000+ Ratings
Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side
4.8 x (8,000+) • 2567.8 mi • Desserts • Bakery • Cupcakes • Breakfast and Brunch • Group Friendly • $$ • Info
200 Columbus Ave
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"I live in Las Vegas but my daughter lives in Manhattan and she absolutely love’s Magnolia Bakery. It’s east to send gifts."
• Lisa C. • 11/03/23
"They have the best cakes and pudding! Their delivery always has all the items in the order which is awesome!"
• Gauri S. • 09/02/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
8:15 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
8:15 AM - 11:45 PM
Featured items
- #1 most likedClassic Banana Pudding Large
$9.75 • 93% (633)
- #2 most likedClassic Banana Pudding Medium
$8.25 • 92% (604)
- #3 most likedCookies and Cream Banana Pudding Large
$10.45 • 100% (3)
- Cookies and Cream Banana Pudding Medium
$8.95 • 85% (7)
- Chocolate Cake Slice w/ Chocolate Buttercream
$7.95 • 92% (229)
Banana Pudding (Online)
- Classic Banana Pudding Medium$8.25 • 92% (604)This world-famous, 12 ounce cup of Banana Pudding is layered with vanilla wafers, fresh bananas and creamy vanilla pudding.
- Classic Banana Pudding Small$5.95 • 96% (202)This world-famous, 4 ounce cup of Banana Pudding is layered with vanilla wafers, fresh bananas and creamy vanilla pudding.
- Classic Banana Pudding Large$9.75 • 93% (633)This world-famous, 16 ounce cup of Banana Pudding is layered with vanilla wafers, fresh bananas and creamy vanilla pudding.
- Cookies and Cream Banana Pudding Small$6.75This pudding has all the flavors of cookies and cream with our world famous banana pudding. Bananas, and Oreos are mixed into vanilla pudding.
- Cookies and Cream Banana Pudding Medium$8.95 • 85% (7)This pudding has all the flavors of cookies and cream with our world famous banana pudding. Bananas, and Oreos are mixed into vanilla pudding.
- Cookies and Cream Banana Pudding Large$10.45 • 100% (3)This pudding has all the flavors of cookies and cream with our world famous banana pudding. Bananas, and Oreos are mixed into vanilla pudding.
Cupcakes & Cakes (Online)
- Chocolate Cake Slice w/ Chocolate Buttercream$7.95 • 92% (229)A slice of dense, chocolatey cake is topped with indulgent chocolate buttercream.
- Carrot Cake Slice$8.95 • 90% (212)The layers of this cake are chock-full with goodness: freshly grated carrot, coconut, pineapple, raisins and walnuts!
- Confetti Cake Slice$8.95 • 82% (156)We make our buttery, beloved vanilla cake extra festive with confetti folded into each layer.
- Hummingbird Cake Slice$8.95 • 95% (181)Bananas, pineapples and pecans make up this classic southern cake with sweetened cream cheese icing.
- Chocolate Cake Slice w/ Vanilla Buttercream$7.95 • 90% (166)A slice of dense chocolate cake is topped with rich vanilla buttercream. Sprinkles are chosen by the bakery staff.Buttercream color and sprinkles chosen by bakery.
- Vanilla Cupcakes w/ Vanilla Buttercream - 2 Count$10.30 • 84% (142)Two of our best-selling vanilla cupcakes are swirled with rich vanilla buttercream.Buttercream color and sprinkles chosen by bakery.
- Red Velvet Cake Slice$8.95 • 75% (100)One of our best-selling desserts, this classic-style red velvet cake layers moist, crimson-colored chocolate cake and is covered with whipped vanilla buttercream.
- Red Velvet Cupcakes - 2 Count$10.50 • 84% (26)One of Magnolia Bakery’s oldest and best-selling desserts, two classic-style red velvet cupcakes are crimson-colored, chocolate-flavored cupcakes topped with whipped vanilla icing.
- One Vanilla Cupcake w/ Vanilla Buttercream + One Chocolate Cupcake w/ Chocolate Buttercream$10.30 • 90% (145)Get the best of both swirls with a chocolate and a vanilla cupcake with chocolate and vanilla buttercream!Vanilla Buttercream color and sprinkles chosen by bakery.
- Vanilla Cake Slice w/ Vanilla Buttercream$7.95 • 76% (124)A slice of delicious vanilla cake is topped with rich vanilla buttercream. Sprinkles are chosen by the bakery staff.
- Vanilla Cake Slice w/ Chocolate Buttercream$7.95 • 83% (109)Our rich vanilla cake slice is topped with decadent chocolate buttercream. Sprinkles are chosen by the bakery staff.
- Chocolate Cupcakes w/ Chocolate Buttercream - 2 Count$10.30 • 91% (101)Two of our chocolate cupcakes are swirled with indulgent chocolate buttercream. Buttercream color and sprinkles are chosen by the bakery staff.
Cookie, Bars & Pies (Online)
Refrigerated Desserts (Online)
Bottled Beverages (Online)
Add-Ons (Online)
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•8000+ Ratings •
112 Reviews
Jennifer T.• 05/19/24Great banana pudding
Nicole J.• 05/06/24Delicious!
Valerie G.• 04/22/24Good stuff
Jennifer M.• 04/18/24Love the treats and love of it!
Taylor E.• 03/31/24big piece of cake so no complaints :)
Jimmy O.• 03/29/24Good!
Jocelin M.• 03/27/24the best banana pudding
Scott B.• 03/21/24Great bakery
Jocelin M.• 03/20/24best bakery
Joe H.• 03/16/24Fresh, flavorful desserts
Sonia K.• 03/06/24Fresh and delicious
E R.• 03/06/24Good deserts
Alliyah F.• 02/27/24Great banana pudding
John B.• 02/25/24Great
Jocelin M.• 02/25/24the best bakery
Becky R.• 02/25/24Quick
VALERIE J.• 02/24/24The chocolate covered strawberry pudding was amazing!
Jennifer W.• 02/19/24Very taste, sweet without being overpowering!
Danielle H.• 02/12/24It’s delicious
Mack T.• 02/06/24Fire banana pudding
Jim S.• 01/22/24Even delivered, it was delicious.
Krishawn S.• 01/17/24Beautiful I loved the banana pudding
Emily C.• 01/16/24delicious
Czarina L.• 01/14/24Amaze
Emily B.• 01/14/24Delicious as always
Jonah K.• 01/14/24Always excellent
Gabrielle A.• 01/14/24Definitely my favorite restaurant
Albert W.• 01/13/24Too good
Sarah S.• 12/28/23Perfect little cupcakes
Susan A.• 12/26/23Items we tasty
Luiz E.• 12/26/23The best desert
Milos B.• 12/22/23You are the best in NYC !
John B.• 12/17/23I am trying to figure out how to add a tip for the delivery person
Deedra M.• 12/15/23It’s the ABSOLUTE BEST
Laura H.• 12/14/23Fresh AF.
Michelle G.• 12/10/23Thanks so much xx
Cheryl B.• 12/09/23Great
Julian H.• 12/09/23Fantastic dessert!
Artem K.• 12/09/23Top
Sheikhar B.• 12/06/23Good
Troy B.• 11/26/23Amazing
Caty A.• 11/23/23So good!
Evelin V.• 11/20/23Great
Stephen C M.• 11/14/23Very good .
Emily C.• 11/13/23The banana pudding is the best and the humming bird cake reminds me of home.
Ally L.• 11/12/23Love the apple crisp pudding !
Bernadeta S.• 11/06/23It never disappoints! My favourite bakery that always satisfies my cravings !
Carolee S.• 11/06/23Loving this
Lisa C.• 11/03/23I live in Las Vegas but my daughter lives in Manhattan and she absolutely love’s Magnolia Bakery. It’s east to send gifts.
Amanda F.• 11/01/23Apple pudding is the best thing I ever eat!!
Amy W.• 11/01/23Fire.
Jesse S.• 10/21/23Banana pudding is the best thing ever
Diogenes J.• 10/21/23Everything tasted great, and was well packaged. The banana pudding is amazing, as if the Apple pudding.
elibeth C.• 10/07/23Best bannana pudding
Jordan G.• 10/05/23good
Kathleen S.• 09/29/23Consistently Delicious Delivered ❤️
Laura T.• 09/25/23So good, especially for a girl who doesn’t love PSL flavors typically!
Aimee H.• 09/23/23Yummm!!!
Verrie G.• 09/22/23cake delicious drink spilled.
Nicole F.• 09/17/23Will return
kay I.• 09/15/23Their food is extremely tasty!
KeeKee W.• 09/13/23Always tasty
LaShawn V.• 09/06/23Fresh large cake slices
Nedra C.• 09/06/23So fresh and the chocolate cake s decadent the best in Harlem
Gauri S.• 09/02/23They have the best cakes and pudding! Their delivery always has all the items in the order which is awesome!
Daniel T.• 08/18/23Amazing. Best sweets EVER!!!!
Eva M.• 08/15/23It’s delicious! Never fail!
Elena D.• 08/14/23BEST banana pudding ever!
Carlos R.• 08/12/23Bannnnnannnnaaaaaaaaa pudding
Joseph K.• 08/09/23Missing birthday pick. True .50 but was supposed to go on birthday cake. Cake slices very delicious.
Mary Angie R.• 08/03/23It’s yummy
Erika M.• 07/30/23Excellent!
Pete B.• 07/23/23Consistently excellent!
Jazzi A.• 07/19/23Delicious
tiffany J.• 07/05/23Amazing banana pudding
Joelle T.• 07/03/23Always fresh, always delectable.
Jessamyn L.• 07/02/23very good pudding
Stephen C M.• 06/28/23I love it .
Smo O.• 06/19/23best banana pudding i’ve ever had!!!!
Mona S.• 06/16/23Also a delightful treat!
Víctor Y.• 06/16/23Delicious
tawanna B.• 06/09/23great
Margie B.• 06/09/23So yummy
tawanna B.• 06/08/23great
John C.• 06/08/23Always a fan of their bread budding. Never fails!
Louise W.• 05/24/23The best gluten free treat in the city. No kidding !
Julie M.• 05/23/23Delicious desserts. Great to send as a birthday gift.
Stephen C M.• 05/17/23I love it .
Lawrence M.• 05/01/23Great as usual
Bernadeta S.• 04/22/23Amazing as always!
Bernadeta S.• 04/17/23Delicious desserts!
Bernadeta S.• 04/16/23My favourite bakery!
elibeth C.• 04/10/23So good
Courtney H.• 03/14/23The best. The very best.
Shonese B.• 01/27/23best cupcakes!
Felipe F.• 01/25/23His so friendly
Shirol J.• 01/20/23Fresh tastes like Homemade Southern Style SWEET BANANA PUDDING
Å R.• 01/01/23always great! delicious variety!
Susan M.• 12/02/22Good service and delicious desserts
Jasmine M.• 11/30/22Amazing cupcakes and carrot cake thank you
Andrea S.• 10/09/22Heavenly baked goods!
Eun J.• 08/10/22best banana pudding ever!
Alec W.• 07/07/22Great and deliscious!
Cenk A.• 03/22/22recomended
Zack C.• 03/17/22Great
Lisa C.• 02/23/22Quick and delicious!
Benita C.• 02/09/22Fresh and super delicious
Aysenil B.• 01/28/22Just right !
Amina A.• 01/16/22they never disappoint!
Leah C.• 12/29/21Best banana pudding on Earth!
Michael R.• 07/26/21Key Lime Bar and the Blueberry Jamboree are cool desserts for a warm summer night. Sooooo good!!!
Dharshani S.• 07/25/21Banana pudding was not fresh
