4.5
3000+ Ratings
La Rustica Pizza
4.5 x (3,000+) • 2569.1 mi • Italian • Pizza • Pasta • Comfort Food • Salads • Family Friendly • Group Friendly • $$ • Info
1426 Lexington Ave
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"WOW! This is the place. What makes La Rustica stand out amongst other places is the true, authentic Italian tomato sauce. Clearly made from crushed peppers, like every Nonna makes, this pasta sauce stands out because it is clearly not canned pizza sauce or purred. You see the tomatoes that someone chopped. You see the seeds. So fresh and delicious—everything is!"
• Jessica F. • 10/07/23
"We’re regulars are La Rustica and will continue to be because of their delicious food, wonderful customer service, and super fast delivery."
• Alex B. • 10/24/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
12:00 AM - 4:30 AM • MENU
11:00 AM - 11:59 PM • MENU
Monday - Thursday
12:00 AM - 1:30 AM • MENU
10:00 AM - 11:59 PM • MENU
Friday
12:00 AM - 3:30 AM • MENU
10:00 AM - 11:59 PM • MENU
Saturday
12:00 AM - 4:30 AM • MENU
10:00 AM - 11:59 PM • MENU
Featured items
Pizza Pies
- Plain Cheese Pie$14.50 • 78% (137)
- Cauliflower Personal Pie (Gluten Free, Keto)$18.00 • 83% (37)10" seasoned cauliflower crust with your choice of toppings, sauce & cheese.
- Grandma Pie$26.00 • 89% (19)Fresh mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil on a thin pan baked crust.
- Rainbow Pizza$20.00Tri-color (marinara, vodka, pesto).Popular
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie$20.00 • 75% (8)Chicken cutlet, chopped crispy bacon, mozzarella cheese & ranch dressing.
- Bianca Pie$16.00Mozzarella & ricotta blend with garlic & Italian herbs, no sauce.Popular
- Large 16" Focaccia Pie$22.00Crushed fresh tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, & extra virgin olive oil on a sicilian square crust, no cheese.
- Margarita Pie$16.50Fresh mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, & extra virgin olive oil.Popular
- Pizza Ala Vodka$18.00 • 85% (7)Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, & Vodka sauce
- Supreme Pizza$22.00 • 83% (12)Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms.
- Hawaiiana Pie$18.00Slices ham & pineapple with sauce & mozzarella cheese.
- Small Vegan Cheese Pizza$20.00
- Meat Lovers Pie$20.00 • 80% (10)Pepperoni, sausage, meatball & bacon.
- Veggie Lovers Pie$20.00Broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, onions.
- Sicilian Pie$24.00Crunchy thick crust square, with your choice of sauce, cheese & toppings.
- Buffalo Chicken Pie$20.00With your choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing.
- Chicken Ala Vodka Pizza$22.00 • 83% (6)Chicken Cutlet, Vodka Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese
- Spinach Artichoke Alfredo Pie$20.00Chopped spinach & artichoke hearts mixed in our creamy garlic Alfredo sauce & mozzarella cheese.
- Chicken Parmigiana Pie$18.00 • 80% (5)Chicken cutlet, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.
- Chicken Pesto Pie$20.00Chicken cutlet, pesto sauce, artichoke hearts, & mozzarella cheese.
Wings and Fingers
Pizza Slices
Heros
Appetizers & Sides
Calzones and Pizza Rolls
Soups
Salads
Oven Baked Pastas
Homemade Pastas
Italian Dinners
Desserts
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.5
•3000+ Ratings •
73 Reviews
Linette H.• 04/28/24Great amount of food for the money and my eggplant parmigiana and spaghetti was delicious
Steven T.• 04/21/24great
Kojaa L.• 04/18/24love it here
Mark S.• 04/08/24The meat balls are fresh
Kiasia A.• 04/08/24my favorite pasta restaurant
Shannon T.• 04/02/24Food was delicious
Soham B.• 04/01/24Good
Emily S.• 03/22/24Awesome
Miriam S.• 03/12/24They have wonderful pizza
MARI C.• 03/09/24Delicious chicken parm
kookie M.• 03/09/24very good
Milika C.• 03/04/24everything was delicious 😋
DIEGO S.• 02/29/24Never disappoints!
Jason F.• 02/24/24excellent service of high quality
Frank R.• 02/21/24good combination of vodka sauce and chicken mozzarella cheese
Becca H.• 02/11/24Huge portions, extra bread with pasta. good tastes, yum delicious cake
Joe T.• 01/25/24My go to place uptown, never disappoints!
Steven S.• 01/25/24The food is fresh and plentiful.
Danielle D.• 01/12/24Yay for vegan options!
Jason W.• 01/10/24Hot and Fresh!
Charisse A.• 01/09/24Very tasty food. I love their garlic knots and their mozzarella sticks are very good!
JOAO VICTOR C.• 12/11/23BEST PIZZA EVER
Ram L.• 12/10/23Mozz sticks are amazing
Justin R.• 12/03/23Some of the best pasta and pizza you can get! I’ve been eating here for years
Nadia C.• 11/18/23Warmth
Edgar C.• 11/01/23It was big portions for the price which was surprising
Concepcion A.• 10/28/23I love their crispy pizza and thing crust
Alex B.• 10/24/23We’re regulars are La Rustica and will continue to be because of their delicious food, wonderful customer service, and super fast delivery.
laure K.• 10/19/23good prices, good delivery and very good taste.
Rosemarie N.• 10/11/23Absolutely delicious! Both the regular pizza and the cauliflower pizza crust. I had the triple sauce and Omg - best pizza ever
Jessica F.• 10/07/23WOW! This is the place. What makes La Rustica stand out amongst other places is the true, authentic Italian tomato sauce. Clearly made from crushed peppers, like every Nonna makes, this pasta sauce stands out because it is clearly not canned pizza sauce or purred. You see the tomatoes that someone chopped. You see the seeds. So fresh and delicious—everything is!
Dennis M.• 09/27/23Best New York style Pizza
Olivia M.• 09/17/23Grandma pizza was real asf
Jessica F.• 09/17/23This is really good. The sauce is the secret—it’s delicious
Casey G.• 09/03/23the order went to Robert Paul champagne from your mom's house podcast and he loved it. he says you guys are made mommies!
Maria Paula C.• 08/20/23Delicious gluten-free dough
Ally D.• 08/14/23Amazing vodka pasta!
Angel G.• 08/12/23pizza is always fresh
Kathy L.• 08/10/23Great portion size.
Tahsimul A.• 08/02/23Food was amazing and portions are great but the Alfredo didn’t really have a taste.
Gordon V.• 07/29/23Big servings, worth the price
Katherine G.• 07/26/23VERY GOOD BUFFALO CHICKEN CALZONE
JENNIE K.• 07/25/23Really good gluten free pizza!!
Laura M.• 07/21/23Great
JR M.• 07/19/23Best stuffed shells I’ve ever had
Yaleidy C.• 07/09/23Very good!
Roystone M.• 06/17/23the dishes made to order are Heavenly!
Rehana R.• 06/09/23The best cheese ravioli in Manhattan!
Dylan C.• 06/07/23Delicious
Taniqua C.• 06/04/23Delicious!
david S.• 05/24/23so far all is great just need extra sauce on many things because it's to light .
Eric H.• 04/28/23Exceptional
Michael M.• 04/28/23great sauce
Joe T.• 04/22/23Even a late night order is fresh and prepared with care at great prices - saved my life many times when getting home late from work trips!
CELEDONIO I.• 04/06/23perfecto!!
CELEDONIO I.• 04/04/23rico rico
Joe T.• 03/05/23Always fresh and great prices!
Joel L.• 02/26/23Good food.
Yago S.• 02/26/23Got a large margherita: thin crust, fresh, huge. 5 stars.
Christopher C.• 02/09/23Fresh!
cy R.• 02/06/23Best slice in the neighborhood, bar none
Esther F.• 02/03/23The food was good. Nice and hot.
Jose I.• 12/18/22Excellent toppings/ingredients, good size, consistent quality.
orlando F.• 12/16/22I love this place...the food is great
Joseph T.• 11/16/22Good portions.
Diana F.• 10/29/22Pizza was delicious!!
Hannah H.• 08/11/22the pesto pasta is AMAZING and can definitely feed two people!
Jeffrey C.• 06/12/22Great Pasta
Alex D.• 05/27/22Excellent!
Que H.• 04/01/22awesome
Calli A.• 03/27/22Get the chocolate cake. You won’t regret it.
Melissa R.• 11/14/21Delicious
Melissa R.• 11/13/21exquisite
