MF
Michael F.
2 weeks ago
Best pizza in Orlando!
Too far to deliver
Location and hours
9852 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32817
| Sunday | ||
| 12:00 PM - 6:00 PM | ||
| Monday - Wednesday | ||
| 12:00 PM - 8:30 PM | ||
| Thursday | ||
| 12:00 PM - 9:30 PM | ||
| Friday - Saturday | ||
| 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
I Love NY Pizza
4.5 x (900+) • $4.95 Delivery Fee • 7292.3 km
x Delivery unavailable
Tap for hours, info, and more
9852 E Colonial Dr
Delivery
Too far to deliver
Pickup
10–20 min • 1,000+ mi
Featured items
Specials
- 18'' One XX Large Pepperoni Pizza$16.99 • 97% (186)
- 12" One M Cheese Pizza$12.99 • 81% (111)
- 14'' Large Pepperoni /10 wings/6 knots$25.99 • 83% (125)One pizza, ten wings, and six garlic knots.
- 18'' XXL Cheese Pizza/ 10 Wings / 6 Garlic Knots / 2 Liter Coke Soda$32.99 • 92% (27)Ten wings, six garlic knots and one 2 liter coke soda.
- 18" Two XXL Cheese Pizza$26.99 • 83% (12)
- 14" Two LG pizza with 2 toppings$29.99 • 100% (4)
- 18" XXL cheese pizza, bread sticks, 6 knots, and 2 liter Coca Cola$28.99 • 100% (6)
- 14'' Three Large Pizza with Three Toppings$43.99
- 14" One LG Pepperoni Pizza$14.99 • 100% (18)
- 12" One M Cheese Pizza/6 knots/6 wings/2 can soda$17.99
Cold Subs
Hot Subs
Calzones and Strombolis
Wings
Salads
Appetizers and Side Orders
Burgers
Desserts
Beverages
5-Star Reviews
Hear from people who love this spot
AG
Amanda G.
3 weeks ago
Great pizza
FA
Fabiola A.
3 months ago
muy rico
KM
Karina M.
6 months ago
amazing
JR
Justin R.
8 months ago
Amazing pizza! Give it a try. The cheesebread actually has cheese unlike most other places
FE
Felix E.
8 months ago
good
SR
Stephen R.
9 months ago
Delicious food for good price
JR
Justin R.
10 months ago
It's one of the best local pizza places in the area. The food is always fresh and made with high-quality ingredients! The cheese breadsticks surprised me with how good they are
ES
Emi S.
10 months ago
The best NY style pizza I have ever had!
DC
DONALD C.
10 months ago
It is all whys good and worth the $$$$$
DK
David K.
10 months ago
Such a great pizza and even better value!
MW
Mike W.
10 months ago
Best pizza I have had in at least 5 years. Tons of toppings unlike the chains.
JG
Johnny G.
10 months ago
Great quality in food
JR
Jaime R.
10 months ago
Great
C*
Che *.
11 months ago
Delicious Pizza Pies Yummy!!!🤤🤤🤤
SS
steve S.
12 months ago
simply delicious a New York slice in orlando
KM
Karina M.
1 year ago
love the pizza
DD
Dana D.
1 year ago
Yummy food. The qty of garlic knots per order would be helpful on the Uber Eats app menu.
