4.8
1500+ Ratings
Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave
4.8 x (1,500+) • 528.8 km • Salads • Pizza • Italian • Info
x Delivered by store staff
x Delivery unavailable
1667 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10028, USA
Delivery
Pickup
Gotham Pizza on 1st Ave in the Upper East Side of Manhattan specializes in a variety of pizza sizes and styles, catering to all tastes. Patrons can enjoy classic 12" and 16" pizzas, including popular options li... More
Gotham Pizza on 1st Ave in the Upper East Side of Manhattan specializes in a variety of pizza sizes and styles, catering to all tastes. Patrons can enjoy classic 12" and 16" pizzas, including popular options like the Regular Cheese and Pepperoni Pizzas. For those with a larger appetite, the restaurant offers square pies such as Grandma and Sicilian pizzas, with options to add toppings. Alongside pizzas, Gotham Pizza also serves salads like Caesar and House, and beverages including soda. Notably, the Regular 16" Pizza and a Soda Can are frequently ordered together, making them a favorite combo among customers. Less
Rating and reviews
"Gotham Pizza has consistently high quality pizza and the best prices in town."
• Christopher A. • 02/28/24
"The price is always reasonable and the quality of the product is always good."
• Christopher A. • 09/27/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Every Day
10:30 AM - 11:30 PM
Featured items
12" Pizza Pies
- 12" Regular Cheese Pizza$12.95 • 93% (271)
- 12" Pepperoni Pizza$15.95 • 97% (182)
- 12" Margherita Pizza$16.95 • 89% (75)
- 12" Buffalo Chicken Pizza$18.95 • 100% (14)
- 12" White Pizza$15.95 • 84% (13)
- 12" Vegetable Pizza$18.95 • 85% (21)All vegetable toppings.
- 12" Chicken Cutlet Pizza$17.95 • 92% (14)
- 12" Buffalo Chicken Pizza with Toppings$21.95 • 85% (27)
- 12" Regular Cheese Pizza with Toppings$15.95 • 88% (26)
- 12" Pepperoni Pizza with Toppings$17.45 • 98% (50)
- 12" Chicken Pizza with Toppings$20.95 • 100% (4)
- 12" BBQ Chicken Pizza$18.95
- 12" Vegetable Pizza with Toppings$21.95All vegetable toppings.
- 12" Margherita Pizza with Toppings$19.95 • 93% (15)
- 12" White Pizza with Toppings$18.95
- 12" House Special Pizza with Toppings$22.95EVERYTHING ON IT !!
16" Pizza Pies
Whole Square Pizza Pies
Garlic Knots
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•1500+ Ratings •
38 Reviews
Christopher A.• 05/15/24The food is always good and the price is right.
Zarinah M.• 03/17/24It’s was flavorful, delicious, hot and very nice delivery
Nora G.• 03/16/24It’s great
Christopher A.• 02/28/24Gotham Pizza has consistently high quality pizza and the best prices in town.
Francesca C.• 02/05/24Pizza buona per essere a ny
Christopher A.• 01/23/24I’m so appreciative for the great quality of the food and the service.
Edward L.• 01/16/24Great pizza
Christopher A.• 01/10/24I’m always pleased at the quality of the product and the reasonable prices.
Christopher A.• 12/28/23The food is constantly good and the price is very reasonable.
Anna M.• 12/19/23Delicious always
Alice C.• 12/09/23Good Pizza ☺️
Christopher A.• 12/04/23They product is of stellar quality and the price can’t be beat.
Laura C.• 12/03/23Kids favorite pizza
Courtney F.• 12/01/23Great pizza
Christopher A.• 11/14/23The quality is consistently good and the price is very reasonable.
Anthony D.• 11/03/23Best pizza upper east side bruh
Christopher A.• 10/25/23The food is of great quality and the price is very reasonable.
Christopher A.• 09/27/23The price is always reasonable and the quality of the product is always good.
ANJELIKA A.• 08/28/23Tasty yummy yum
Christopher A.• 08/02/23The quality of the food is consistently good and the price is reasonable.
Craig R.• 08/01/23Had there pizza twice! Loved it!
Jasper C.• 07/22/23So good and fast
Yaacov A.• 07/11/23Good and quick delivery
Christopher A.• 07/06/23The price can’t be beat and the quality is great.
Antonio N.• 06/25/23W pizza
Tia V.• 06/17/23Good pizza.
Julio L.• 04/16/23Top notch. Best ever.
Alex O.• 04/16/23They'll climb up flights of stairs! That is dedication :)
Bianca G.• 02/25/23Some of the best pizza in NYC
David K.• 02/18/23Best pizza!!
Angela M.• 08/03/22Consistently amazing pizza. Best crust!
Fritz B.• 01/13/22Pizza was delicious
William A.• 11/06/21Great!!!!!
Allison S.• 10/30/21Super yummy
William A.• 10/11/21The best!
William A.• 09/27/21GREAT FOOD
William A.• 09/14/21The Pizza is simply "GREAT"
William A.• 08/29/21Good food!
Can I order Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave delivery in New York with Uber Eats?
Yes. Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave delivery is available on Uber Eats in New York.
Is Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave delivery is available to your location in New York.
How do I order Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave delivery online in New York?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave delivery in New York?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Gotham Pizza - 1st Ave order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
