4.5
1000+ Ratings
Goodfella's Pizzeria
4.5 x (1,000+) • Pizza • Wings • Pasta • Alcohol • Info
x Available at 11:00 AM
x Delivered by store staff
11873 East Colonial Drive, Orlando, FL 32826
Rating and reviews
"One of my favorite pizzarias in Orlando. The pizza is great and the service is fantastic. I ordered a delivery tonight from Uber eats. The driver came with just a plain cheese pizza. I called the restaurant to tell them about the error and they immediately sent one of their own drivers to get me the correct order."
• Raymond G. • 10/20/23
"Flavor on Stromboli was excellent! The deluxe option was a bit watery(due to mushrooms?) but flavor was good. The Antipasto salad looks amazing!"
• Tina F. • 12/23/23
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Featured items
Goodfella's Pasta
Goodfella's Specialty Pastas
Oven Baked Pastas
Side Orders
Fresh Deli Subs
Hot Subs
Desserts
Salads
Beverages
Speciality Soups
Seafood
Veal & Eggplant
Strombolis
Chicken Entrees
Wings
Pizzas
Appetizers
- Rating and reviews
4.5
•1000+ Ratings •
38 Reviews
Nancy M.• 03/31/25Best pizza
John C.• 12/09/24Sec9nd time. Just as good as the first
Alex A.• 11/03/24Great pizza as always!
F julisa F.• 10/03/24Fresh
BRANDON H.• 09/29/24love it
Jay M.• 08/22/24Amazing as always!
Alex E.• 07/17/24Amazing service she was so sweet and food was hot ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Susan W.• 06/29/24Delicious!!!
ADAM E.• 06/13/24great pizza
ANDRUS M.• 06/10/24Great pizza
Shaner S.• 03/17/24good food
Albie R.• 03/16/24Food is always fresh
Eliazar M.• 03/12/24my favorite
Donna D.• 02/15/24Delicious, many choices, fast delivery
Tom J.• 01/26/24Great pizza. Slice of cake is so small probably 4 bites in size
Robert H.• 12/31/23Always great Italian food. You have to get the garlic knots.
Tina F.• 12/23/23Flavor on Stromboli was excellent! The deluxe option was a bit watery(due to mushrooms?) but flavor was good. The Antipasto salad looks amazing!
DAVID G.• 12/02/23Pizza is good quality
Brian Z.• 11/13/23All very tasty
Linda S.• 11/03/23I Love it
Raymond G.• 10/20/23One of my favorite pizzarias in Orlando. The pizza is great and the service is fantastic. I ordered a delivery tonight from Uber eats. The driver came with just a plain cheese pizza. I called the restaurant to tell them about the error and they immediately sent one of their own drivers to get me the correct order.
KENNEDY A.• 10/14/23Great flavor
Karl P.• 10/03/23I like they sauce flavor and cheese and the topping come together to make a good tasting pizza.
Jennifer P.• 09/30/23Great
MARCUS H.• 09/29/23This place is best Pizza place for me!!!
BEATRIZ C.• 09/25/23Delicious pizza
Sean J.• 09/10/23Everything was so tasty and fresh. Goodfellas is the most NY authentic pizza
DeVenia S.• 08/26/23Great
Michael M.• 08/12/23Delicious food
A R.• 07/11/23Best Grandma’s pizza!
Joselyn R.• 07/06/23Love Pizza
Amy B.• 07/03/23Most authentic NY I’ve had since being in NY.
Sorrayah M.• 06/26/23Great flavor and quality!
Jeannette C.• 06/25/23BEST UP NORTH TASTING PIZZA IN TOWN!
Ariel H.• 06/23/23Great pizza
marfa H.• 06/22/23Never go wrong with this pizza
TED L.• 05/15/23Great pizza. Delivered with care.
Joann V.• 04/11/23The best pizza and everything else on the menu I have had in Orlando!!!
