4.6
500+ Ratings
Goodfella's Pizzeria
4.6 x (500+) • $0 Delivery Fee • 2447 mi • Pizza • Wings • Pasta • Alcohol • Info
x Delivered by store staff
x Delivery unavailable
11873 East Colonial Drive
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"One of my favorite pizzarias in Orlando. The pizza is great and the service is fantastic. I ordered a delivery tonight from Uber eats. The driver came with just a plain cheese pizza. I called the restaurant to tell them about the error and they immediately sent one of their own drivers to get me the correct order."
• Raymond G. • 10/20/23
"Flavor on Stromboli was excellent! The deluxe option was a bit watery(due to mushrooms?) but flavor was good. The Antipasto salad looks amazing!"
• Tina F. • 12/23/23
$0 Delivery Fee
Pricing & fees
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Monday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Goodfella's Pasta
- Meatball Pasta$14.95 • 100% (4)Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Pink Sauce Pasta$14.95Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Meat Sauce Pasta$14.95 • 100% (8)Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Sausage Pasta$13.95 • 100% (4)Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Garlic and Oil Pasta$11.95Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Tomato Sauce Pasta$11.95Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Marinara Sauce Pasta$13.95Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
Goodfella's Specialty Pastas
- Penne alla Vodka Pasta$16.95 • 80% (10)Mushrooms, onions, and peppers sauteed in a creamy pink sauce with a touch of vodka. Includes mozzarella and marinara. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken Pasta$21.95 • 16% (6)Our classic fettuccine alfredo with grilled chicken. Includes Parmesan and alfredo sauce. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta$15.95 • 50% (8)A blend of fresh cream, butter, and parmesan cheese. Includes mozzarella and alfredo sauce. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Tortellini Alfredo Pasta$16.95Cheese stuffed tortellini pasta in our alfredo sauce. Includes mozzarella. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Spaghetti Progantini (Our House Special Pasta)$18.95 • 100% (4)Spaghetti in a creamy sherry wine sauce topped with tomatoes and feta cheese.Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Broccoli, Garlic and Oil Pasta$15.95 • 66% (3)Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Spaghetti Carbonara Pasta$18.95 • 100% (3)Spaghetti with sauteed bacon, ham, and onions, in a creamy parmesan sauce. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
Oven Baked Pastas
- Baked Ziti Pasta$13.95 • 92% (13)Ziti pasta blended with ricotta cheese, topped with tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Lasagna Pasta$15.95 • 100% (8)Layered pasta with meat sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Homemade Baked Manicotti Pasta$15.95 • 100% (6)Ricotta cheese rolled in pasta and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Goodfella's Baked Combo Pasta$15.95 • 100% (5)Baked ziti, 1 manicotti, 2 cheese raviolis topped with sauce and melted mozzarella. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
- Baked Trio Pasta$17.95Manicotti, eggplant rollatini, and meat lasagna. Served with Italian bread and a choice of soup or salad.
Side Orders
Fresh Deli Subs
Hot Subs
Desserts
Salads
Beverages
Speciality Soups
Seafood
Veal & Eggplant
Strombolis
Chicken Entrees
Wings
Pizzas
Appetizers
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•500+ Ratings •
32 Reviews
Shaner S.• 03/17/24good food
Albie R.• 03/16/24Food is always fresh
Eliazar M.• 03/12/24my favorite
Donna D.• 02/15/24Delicious, many choices, fast delivery
Tom J.• 01/26/24Great pizza. Slice of cake is so small probably 4 bites in size
Albie R.• 01/03/24Excellent and authentic
Robert H.• 12/31/23Always great Italian food. You have to get the garlic knots.
Tina F.• 12/23/23Flavor on Stromboli was excellent! The deluxe option was a bit watery(due to mushrooms?) but flavor was good. The Antipasto salad looks amazing!
Robert H.• 12/09/23Lasagna very tasty and you must get garlic knots.
DAVID G.• 12/02/23Pizza is good quality
Brian Z.• 11/13/23All very tasty
Linda S.• 11/03/23I Love it
Tom J.• 10/27/23Always the best
Raymond G.• 10/20/23One of my favorite pizzarias in Orlando. The pizza is great and the service is fantastic. I ordered a delivery tonight from Uber eats. The driver came with just a plain cheese pizza. I called the restaurant to tell them about the error and they immediately sent one of their own drivers to get me the correct order.
KENNEDY A.• 10/14/23Great flavor
Karl P.• 10/03/23I like they sauce flavor and cheese and the topping come together to make a good tasting pizza.
Jennifer P.• 09/30/23Great
Marcus H.• 09/29/23This place is best Pizza place for me!!!
Beatriz C.• 09/25/23Delicious pizza
Sean J.• 09/10/23Everything was so tasty and fresh. Goodfellas is the most NY authentic pizza
DeVenia S.• 08/26/23Great
Michael M.• 08/12/23Delicious food
A R.• 07/11/23Best Grandma’s pizza!
A R.• 07/08/23Delicious and friendly staff
Joselyn R.• 07/06/23Love Pizza
Amy B.• 07/03/23Most authentic NY I’ve had since being in NY.
Sorrayah M.• 06/26/23Great flavor and quality!
Jeannette C.• 06/25/23BEST UP NORTH TASTING PIZZA IN TOWN!
Ariel H.• 06/23/23Great pizza
marfa H.• 06/22/23Never go wrong with this pizza
Ted L.• 05/15/23Great pizza. Delivered with care.
Joann V.• 04/11/23The best pizza and everything else on the menu I have had in Orlando!!!
