4.6
800+ Ratings
Goodfellas Pizzeria
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Meat lovers and green chile chicken Pennine... amazing!!!!! First time trying Goodfellas but definitely got a repete customer!!! Great job!!!"
• Nicole S. • 07/30/24
"amazing calzone great food more portions than I asked for everything was delicious and I didn't have to wait too long I'll be a regular customer"
• austin J. • 06/27/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Featured items
Specialty Pizza
- GoodFellas Special$22.79 • 96% (31)2 SLICES PEPPERONI, 2 HAWAIIAN, 2 SAUSAGE & 2 BUFFALO CHICKEN SLICES
- The Wise Guys$22.79 • 92% (51)A MEAT-LOVERS PIZZA!
LOADS OF PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SAUSAGE, MEATBALLS, BACON & HAM - The Soprano$22.79 • 88% (45)PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SAUSAGE, BLACK OLIVES, RED ONIONS, MUSHROOMS & BELL PEPPERS
- INFERNO PIZZA$22.79 • 100% (15)CHEESE PIZZA TOPPED WITH LOADS OF PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SAUSAGE, GREEN CHILE & JALAPENOS
- VEGETARIAN STYLE PIZZA$22.79 • 88% (9)MUSHROOMS, BELL PEPPERS, ONIONS, FRESH TOMATOES, BLACK OLIVES & NM GREEN CHILE
- HAWAIIAN PIZZA$22.79 • 100% (12)HAM & PINEAPPLE ON OUR TRADITIONAL PIZZA PIE
- BBQ/ Hot Buffalo$22.79CHOOSE YOUR FAVORITE!
GRILLED CHICKEN TOSSED W/ EITHER HOT BUFFALO SAUCE OR BBQ SAUCE & TOPPED OFF W/ MOZZARELLA CHEESE, *SERVED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF RANCH OR BLUE CHEESE - CHICKEN BACON ALFREDO PIZZA$22.79 • 100% (5)CREAMY ALFREDO SAUCE, GRILLED CHICKEN, CRUMBLED BACON, RED ONIONS, SAUTÉED SPINACH, TOPPED OFF WITH FRESH MOZZARELLA CHEESE
Italian Classics
- Garlic Knots$5.99 • 95% (44)HOMEMADE DOUGH TIED IN KNOTS
BRUSHED W/ GARLIC BUTTER, ITALIAN
HERBS, & GRATED PARMESAN CHEESE
& SERVED W/ MARINARA SAUCE - Jumbo Pizza Roll (Stromboli)$15.59 • 100% (5)DOUGH ROLLED W/ MOZZARELLA. BRUSHED
W/GARLIC BUTTER & PARMESAN
SERVED W/ SIDE OF MARINARA - Cheezy Bread$9.59 • 96% (28)10" dough with lots of cheese and garlic butter. Served with a side of marinara
- Meatball Parm Penne$14.39HOMEMADE MARINARA, RICOTTA
CHEESE, ITALIAN SEASONINGS, &
MEATBALLS OVER PENNE NOODLES
TOPPED W/ MOZZARELLA, SERVED WITH
2 GARLIC KNOTS - Calzones$15.59MOZZARELLA, GRATED PARMESAN, &
RICOTTA, BRUSHED W/ GARLIC BUTTER
& SERVED W/ MARINARA - Green Chile Chicken Alfredo Penne$14.39PENNE PASTA BAKED IN ALFREDO SAUCE AND
TOPPED WITH GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST,
GREEN CHILI, CRUMBLED BACON, ITALIAN
SEASONINGS & MELTED MOZZARELLA,
SERVED WITH 2 GARLIC KNOTS - Philly Cheese Steak Calzone$19.19THINLY CHOPPED STEAK, SAUTÉED
MUSHROOMS, ONIONS & BELL PEPPERS,
LOADED WITH MOZZARELLA CHEESE &
BAKED TO A GOLDEN BROWN, BRUSHED WITH
GARLIC BUTTER
Salads
Desserts
Subs & Wings
Sides
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•800+ Ratings •
23 Reviews
Amy H.• 08/21/24Best pizza ever
Nicole S.• 07/30/24Meat lovers and green chile chicken Pennine... amazing!!!!! First time trying Goodfellas but definitely got a repete customer!!! Great job!!!
SARA P.• 06/28/24That cheesy bread is to die for. Cannot wait to order again
austin J.• 06/27/24amazing calzone great food more portions than I asked for everything was delicious and I didn't have to wait too long I'll be a regular customer
Car A.• 06/25/24So delicious it tasted home made.
Jack C.• 05/14/24Good pizza!
Dan L.• 03/25/24Great
Stephanie B.• 02/10/241st time trying and will be back the flavor and the crust is amazing
Amber B.• 01/21/24Amazing pizza as always! ❤️🍕thanks!!
NATHAN G.• 12/10/23Great pizza lots of toppings. Great price.
Patrick H.• 11/13/23love pizza
Christopher A.• 11/04/23Tasty!
Carrie D.• 10/13/23The sauce is delicious! Love the thinner crust! I liked our inferno pizza!!! and Uber delivery was great too!
Kim P.• 10/05/23so good
Lee C.• 09/03/23Great taste and generous dips
Jonathan W.• 08/27/23Wow! The special was amazing!
Linda D.• 08/03/23Great taste
Bex R.• 07/16/23Yummy
Joe O.• 07/14/23Great pizza, always fresh and tasty!
Jessica S.• 10/28/22Literally the best pizza in the NE Heights area!
Jimmy M.• 09/24/22Always on point! The food is always fresh and tasty, we order several times a month.
chris S.• 01/27/22Mmm
chris S.• 11/23/21Mmm
