4.7
1500+ Ratings
GENCARELLI'S PIZZA FACTORY
4.7 x (1,500+) • 5844 km • Italian • Pizza • Comfort Food • € • Info
x Delivery unavailable
Tap for hours, info, and more
1419 McCarter Highway
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"Gencarelli”s. Should change their name for the price. Of the pizza and the. Quality change name to greatcarelli”s never disappointed me great stuff for half the cost fresh and better than papajohns"
• JEMAINE R. • 02/25/23
"Been going here 30 plus years food is ALWAYS on point! that crust that marinar you can just drink! you guys follow notes and food always fresh and delicious"
• Joseph B. • 05/10/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Featured items
Pizza
- Plain Pizza$7.54 • 90% (693)Plain pizza.
- Pepperoni Pizza$9.41 • 92% (506)
- Extra Cheese Pizza$9.41 • 94% (311)
- Sausage Pizza$9.41 • 92% (108)
- SicilianPizza$18.81 • 73% (15)
- Meatball Pizza$9.41 • 95% (21)
- Mushrooms Pizza$9.41 • 93% (31)
- Peppers Pizza$9.41 • 100% (3)
- Onions Pizza$9.41 • 100% (9)
- Anchovies Pizza$9.41
- Olive Pizza$9.41
- Baby Sicilian$15.00
Specialty Pizzas
- Grilled Chicken Pizza$15.99 • 100% (11)
- Margarita Pizza$15.05 • 89% (48)Fresh mozzarella and basil.
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza$16.93 • 91% (49)Fried chicken, mozzarella, and Buffalo sauce mixed with blue cheese.
- Meat Lovers Pizza$16.93 • 93% (29)Pepperoni, sausage, ham, and meatball.
- Genc’s Special Pizza$16.93 • 94% (35)Pepperoni, sausage, onions, and peppers, olives, and mushrooms.
- White Pizza$13.17 • 100% (10)Mozzarella and ricotta (no sauce).
- Hawaiian Pizza$15.05Ham and pineapples.Popular
- Cheesesteak Pizza$16.93Chopped steak, peppers, onions, potatoes, mozzarella (no sauce).
Stuff Bread
Appetizers
Empanadas
Soups
Salads
Pasta
Pint Sauces
Subs
Dinners
Desserts
Drinks
Genc's Smash Burger Platters
SPECIAL
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•1500+ Ratings •
75 Reviews
justin H.• 05/24/24every order from here is consistently delicious. thank you Gencarelli's
Joseph B.• 05/23/24weekly tradition for the wife and I, eggplant pie is amazing
Farris L.• 05/12/24Great price
Joseph B.• 05/10/24Been going here 30 plus years food is ALWAYS on point! that crust that marinar you can just drink! you guys follow notes and food always fresh and delicious
Joseph B.• 05/01/24local and delicious every order always on point
Maria P.• 05/01/24Always reliably good, with a lot of creative items on the menu
Salena D.• 04/15/24Efficient
Kristin G.• 03/23/24everything was great with this delivery
Aja M.• 03/20/24The pizza is so delicious!
shannel R.• 03/20/24good pizza
Pamela M.• 03/20/24Great pizza
Kerry C.• 03/16/24Delicious zeppoles.
Elijah T.• 02/28/24Fresh and good
SERGIO O.• 02/20/24hola
Chelsea S.• 02/17/24pizza :3
ALAN K.• 02/03/24great quality tasty foods
shannel R.• 01/19/24good pizza
Jennifer C.• 01/03/24Love that they have delicious vegan sandwiches .
shannel R.• 12/27/23good food
Louis H.• 12/23/23delicious
axel B.• 12/22/23the best pizzas I have ever eaten
Michelle L.• 12/15/23Always good!!
shannel R.• 12/15/23good
shannel R.• 12/03/23good food
Philip H.• 11/26/23First time ordering very good what is the difference?
shannel R.• 11/22/23good
Dorene G.• 11/22/23Pizza is delicious
shannel R.• 11/03/23best pizza ever
Dorene G.• 11/01/23Everything is good here..the pizza is so good
Fran F.• 10/28/23Sauce and crust are the best!!!!!
shannel R.• 10/27/23good
axel B.• 10/24/23buena comida y excelente calidad
Yogesh K.• 10/22/23Great taste but make sure you seal the pizza boxes
Christian C.• 10/21/23always on point.
Nicole M.• 10/20/23Great tasting pizza and very affordable pizza
Janet H.• 10/08/23great service
Rolando B.• 10/06/23very good pizza
MATILDELI M.• 10/06/23Fresh
Ronald B.• 09/25/23great
Rolando B.• 09/18/23fresh every time
Cynthia M.• 09/01/23pasta very very good
Gloria V.• 09/01/23Fast and friendly service, food is delicious and priced greatly.
SERGIO O.• 08/28/23hola
Roy W.• 08/26/23The entire order was delicious!
Kamilah H.• 08/24/23Fast delivery and food is amazing with great price
Dorene G.• 08/23/23Love the food from here..pizza is delicious
Ali B.• 08/14/23Best pizza in Jersey
Gilberto A.• 07/20/23Great food and reasonable price
Brett K.• 07/15/23Great pizza!!!
Peter C.• 06/25/23Great price, delicious food
Lauren J.• 06/09/23Very creamy and rich flavor in the alfredo with fresh cheese and the perfect mushrooms
Anise ..• 05/28/23Affordable for large family and the food is always good.
Zandra L.• 05/28/23Delicious
Roberto R.• 05/27/23So good
Lisa L.• 05/20/23pizza is awsome and the oast fagioll is so so delicious served with good quality u amity bread
CiCi R.• 05/02/23Penne Vodka sauce extra thick melted mozzarella yooooo ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Robin W.• 04/27/23best pizza 🍕 😋
Shaquan H.• 04/15/23Always delicious. The only pizza my toddler will eat
Arlene C.• 04/14/23Thier pizza taste like an old school favorite and it is super affordable! love their pizza!
Robin W.• 03/31/23fresh delicious pizza 🍕
Robin W.• 03/10/23authentic fresh delicious pizza
DELISHA S.• 03/08/23this will be my new go to pizza place! nice thin crust, right amount of sauce & toppings! delicious
JEMAINE R.• 02/25/23Gencarelli”s. Should change their name for the price. Of the pizza and the. Quality change name to greatcarelli”s never disappointed me great stuff for half the cost fresh and better than papajohns
sharika R.• 02/22/23Pizza is excellent!! Delivery drivers are friendly and prompt!
Kelly B.• 02/14/23So good!
sharika R.• 02/14/23“Great Pizza nice size portions , taste great, thin crust !
Lisette M.• 02/11/23Super Great!! Would come to this place often!!
John P.• 02/06/23Their cold antipasto is delicious and are my ‘go to’ Friday treat.
John P.• 01/30/23Their antipasto salads are so delicious and their customer service is wonderful.
Yvonne H.• 12/18/22Delicious!
Sarah L.• 11/10/22Love the pizza and calzones to her most but other things I've tried are really good too! They also work fast as well!
Stephanie M.• 01/10/22Meat lovers has officially become my fav!
Analie D.• 12/23/21I got the plain cheese pizza and it was delicious, definitely ordering again!
Alex I.• 12/09/21The best pizza I ever had. The fried orios were so good. 🔥
Stacey Y.• 10/18/21Good food
