4.9
900+ Ratings
First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville)
4.9 x (900+) • 1854 mi • Desserts • Vegetarian • Coffee and Tea • Group Friendly • $$ • Info
5357 N Ashland Ave
First Slice Pie Cafe, located in Chicago's Andersonville neighborhood, specializes in a delightful array of desserts, particularly pies. This cafe is celebrated for its rich and creamy French Silk Pie and the t... More
First Slice Pie Cafe, located in Chicago's Andersonville neighborhood, specializes in a delightful array of desserts, particularly pies. This cafe is celebrated for its rich and creamy French Silk Pie and the tangy Michigan Sour Cherry Pie, which are also frequently ordered together by patrons. The menu features a variety of fruit and cream pies, including Key Lime Pie and Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, alongside other offerings like salads, soups, and sandwiches. In the evenings, First Slice Pie Cafe becomes a popular spot, reflecting its cozy allure and a customer rating of approximately 4.2. Less
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Amazing turkey chili and sandwiches and can’t forget the French silk pie! Such a sweet place with wonderful people!"
• Elodie T. • 03/08/22
"The best pie shop I’ve ever experienced, with the nicest staff in the world - no exaggeration!"
• Courtney C. • 07/14/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
10:00 AM - 5:45 PM
Monday - Saturday
10:00 AM - 7:45 PM
Fruit Pies
- Michigan Sour Cherry PiePriced by add-ons • 97% (172)Michigan sour cherries, flour, butter, shortening, cornstarch, cinnamon, cane sugar, vanilla, and salt.
- Traditional Apple PiePriced by add-ons • 95% (176)Granny smith apples, brown sugar, juice, butter, flour, shortening, cornstarch, vanilla, sugar, salt, cinnamon, and spices.
- Balsamic Raspberry Pear PiePriced by add-ons • 94% (17)Raspberry, balsamic vinegar, pear, sugar, cinnamon, butter, flour, egg, and salt. Only available as a mini pie.
Cream Pies
- Key Lime PiePriced by add-ons • 97% (206)Condensed milk, sugar, lemon juice, lime juice, heavy cream, egg yolks, lime zest, graham cracker, and butter.
- French Silk PiePriced by add-ons • 97% (134)Unsweetened chocolate chips, eggs, sugar, heavy cream, butter, vanilla, flour, and shortening.
- Chocolate Peanut Butter PiePriced by add-ons • 97% (130)Peanut butter, cream cheese, sugar, vanilla, whipped cream, chocolate, peanuts, and oreo.
- Polka Dot PiePriced by add-ons • 97% (68)Chocolate, almond paste, eggs, kahlua, espresso, vanilla, almond extract, sugar, and cream cheese.
- Chocolate Cream PiePriced by add-ons • 90% (75)Oreo crust, chocolate chips, cream, egg yolks, vanilla, corn starch, and salt.
- Coffee Toffee PiePriced by add-ons • 96% (59)Coffee, unsweetened chocolate, eggs, confectioners sugar, heavy cream, butter, oreo crumbs, and espresso.
Soup
- Roasted Tomato Soup$8.00 • 96% (55)Tomato, onion, carrot, celery, olive oil, garlic, and herbs, served with grilled cheese garnish.
- Spicy Grain Soup$7.50 • 85% (27)Vegetable stock, carrot, onion, guajillo, celery, tortilla, tomato, lentil, brown rice, herbs, and spice.Spicy
- Turkey Chili Soup$9.00 • 100% (52)Turkey, a medley of beans, tomato, onion, chili, butternut squash, peppers, and spices.
- Cuban Black Bean Soup$7.50 • 100% (21)Black beans, peppers, onion, celery, garlic, and spices.
Salad
- Latin Hip Hop Salad$10.00 • 86% (15)Romaine, roasted cauliflower, tomato, scallions, grilled red onion, radish, queso fresco, spiced pepitas, tortilla strips, and mojito vinaigrette.
- Harvest Salad$10.00 • 92% (14)Baby mixed greens, poached pear, grilled red onion, garbanzo beans, radish, candied pecans, spiced pepitas, bleu cheese, and cranberry vinaigrette.
- Cobb Salad$12.00 • 100% (16)Romaine, chicken breast, bleu cheese, bacon, candied pecans, apple, radish, scallions, and cranberry vinaigrette.
- Apple and Baby Lettuce Side Salad$5.50Green apple, baby lettuce, tomato, and radish salad with vinaigrette dressing.
70's Style Salad
- Pesto Tortellini 70’s SaladPriced by add-ons • 92% (26)Tri-color cheese tortellini, mayonnaise, fresh basil, basil pesto, and cherry tomato.
- Curry Chicken 70’s Style SaladPriced by add-ons • 96% (25)Poached chicken breast, green apple, dried cherry, scallions, shredded carrot, yellow curry, and yogurt sauce.
Sandwiches
Quichees
Community Plates
For the Kids
Café Specials
- Rating and reviews
4.9
•900+ Ratings •
17 Reviews
Kristen W.• 04/02/24Excellent food!
Karen M.• 04/01/24Great pies!
Nicole W.• 12/31/23The kind of pie you’d want to steal off a country windowsill.
Avi I.• 10/22/23I’ve gone here off and on for a decade and I’ve never been disappointed!
Richard S.• 09/24/23You
FRANK P.• 09/24/23Key lime pie is good
Aisha K.• 07/16/23Blueberry cheesecake was amazing!
Courtney C.• 07/14/23The best pie shop I’ve ever experienced, with the nicest staff in the world - no exaggeration!
Karen M.• 07/03/23best place for pies
Elise H.• 06/09/23Highly recommend the blueberry cheesecake!
Nicole W.• 05/31/23Everything was delicious and the pie flavors are all fantastic. Must try!
Jennifer L.• 05/19/23Key Lime pie was amazing
Anthony G.• 03/11/23the pies are amazing
Jordan A.• 02/16/23Soooooo gooooood
Pam D.• 09/01/22I loved it but you guys missed the side salad or chips for my parents sandwich:(
Joyce K.• 07/13/22Yummy pie. Best in Chicago
Elodie T.• 03/08/22Amazing turkey chili and sandwiches and can’t forget the French silk pie! Such a sweet place with wonderful people!
Can I order First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) delivery in Chicago with Uber Eats?
Yes. First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) delivery is available on Uber Eats in Chicago.
Is First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) delivery is available to your location in Chicago.
How do I order First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) delivery online in Chicago?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) delivery in Chicago?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your First Slice Pie Cafe (Andersonville) order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
Frequently asked questions
Allergens: These items may include unlisted ingredients and/or be prepared on equipment that processes allergens. Take precautions if you have an allergy.
