4.7
250+ Ratings
Fat Sully's Pizza (Westport)
4.7 x (250+) • Pizza • Fast Food • American • Burgers • Comfort Food • Info
4144 Pennsylvania Avenue
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Probably the best I've ordered from Uber eats hands down!! The price was wonderful and the food was better."
• Dasha H. • 01/26/23
"My kids loved it I loved and my pregnant sister in law fell In love with it"
• walter K. • 05/27/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 11:59 PM
Featured items
Fat Sully's Apps + Salads
- Loaded Garlic Knots$13.74 • 100% (13)Fried Sully's Dough, Garlic, Parmesan, Creamy Mozzarella, Basil Pesto + red dipping sauce
- Perfectly Plain Garlic Knots$10.29 • 57% (7)Fried Sully's Dough, Garlic, Parmesan + Red Dipping Sauce
- Caesar Salad$12.59 • 71% (7)(Serves 2) Romaine, Caesar Dressing, Grated Parmesan + Bread Crumbs
- Buffalo Wings$18.34 • 100% (4)One pound of Wings lightly breaded, fried and tossed with Buffalo Sauce.
- Garlic Parmesan Wings$18.34 • 100% (3)One pound of Wings, fried and tossed with Garlic Parmesan
- House Salad$12.59(Serves 2) Romaine, spinach, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, Feta Cheese, Croutons + your choice of House Made Dressing
- Oreo Dessert Knots$11.44 • 100% (5)Fried Sully's Dough tossed in Oreo + topped with Icing
- BBQ Wings$18.34One pound of Wings, fried and tossed with BBQ
- Chicken Tenders$12.59Buttermilk fried chicken tenders served with house-seasoned waffle friesPopular
- Waffle Fries$5.18We have Substituted Traditional Fries while Waffle Fries are unavailable due to supply chain issues. Apologies for any inconvenience.
- Garlic Parm Fries$6.90
- Korean Wings$18.34One pound of Wings, fried and tossed with Korean Sauce.
- Arugula Salad$12.59Arugula, fried artichoke, shaved parm and toasted bread crumbs tossed in a house-made creamy pesto dressing
- Italian Chopped Salad$13.74Romaine, spinach, tomatoes, green pepper, cucumber, red onion, banana pepper, black olives, chopped ham and pepperoni topped with feta and tossed in house-made greek vinaigrette
Fat Sully's Pies
- 20" Red Pie$25.24 • 93% (90)Red Sauce- "The Traditional" - Our flavor packed tomato based sauce, blended with fresh onions, and our blend of spices and herbs
- 20" White Pie$25.24 • 87% (8)White Sauce- "The Wild Card" - No olive oil here folks! We take fresh Ricotta Cheese and blend it with a little milk, fresh garlic and spices
- 12" Gluten Free Red Pie$18.34Red Sauce- "The Traditional" - Our flavor packed tomato based sauce, blended with fresh onions, and our blend of spices and herbs On a Gluten Free Cauliflower crust
Burgers & Sandos
- Lights Out Burger (Impossible Double)$17.19Double Smash Burger with Aged American Cheese, House Made Pickles, Onion + Burger Sauce on a Garlic Butter toasted Brioche Bun
- Lights Out Burger (Double)$12.59 • 90% (50)Double Smash Burger with Aged American Cheese, House Made Pickles, Onion + Burger Sauce on a Garlic Butter toasted Brioche Bun
- Chicken Sando$11.44 • 100% (3)Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Duke's Mayo and House-Made Pickles on a toasted Brioche Bun
Fat Sully's Side Sauces
Drinks
Atomic Cowboy Mocktails
Utensils
Would you like to have utensils with your order?Tailgate Packages
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•250+ Ratings •
10 Reviews
Matthew D.• 04/06/24good good good
Quentin T.• 03/11/24Good
Stephanie A.• 02/26/24my burger was cooked perfectly and everything tasted great!
Braden R.• 02/12/24So delicious, possibly the best pizza in the city.
Lizzy G.• 12/16/23Delicious New York style pizza! Fresh and flavorful
Sophia V.• 11/26/23We love fat silly’s pizza! The perfect ny style
Cody W.• 11/05/23Gluten Free pizza!!
Charles H.• 07/25/23Good Pizza
walter K.• 05/27/23My kids loved it I loved and my pregnant sister in law fell In love with it
Dasha H.• 01/26/23Probably the best I've ordered from Uber eats hands down!! The price was wonderful and the food was better.
