4.6
1000+ Ratings
Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs)
4.6 x (1,000+) • Pizza • American • Breakfast and Brunch • Burgers • Comfort Food • $ • Info
x No delivery people nearby
528 S Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Rating and reviews
"I came to Colorado from Long Island this summer and this is REAL NY Pizza…every pizza joint claims to be ny pizza but isn’t and Fat Sully’s is the REAL DEAL.. have never had pizza like in NYC outside nyc until now…Heaven Yeah!!!"
• Lisa V. • 02/03/26
"Fat Sullys is THE BEST PIZZA IN COLORADO SPRINGS! Period.\nBest crust sauce cheese and it’s BIG!\nIt’s like REAL NYC PIZZA!"
• David P. • 11/25/25
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 4:00 PM • Fat Sully's Online Menu AM
4:00 PM - 11:59 PM • Fat Sully's Online Menu PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 4:00 PM • Fat Sully's Online Menu AM
4:00 PM - 2:00 AM • Fat Sully's Online Menu PM
Apps
Salads
Wings
Burgers & Sandwiches
Side Sauces
Canned Sodas
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•1000+ Ratings •
46 Reviews
Lisa V.• 02/03/26I came to Colorado from Long Island this summer and this is REAL NY Pizza…every pizza joint claims to be ny pizza but isn’t and Fat Sully’s is the REAL DEAL.. have never had pizza like in NYC outside nyc until now…Heaven Yeah!!!
Sebastian S.• 12/07/25After an Uber driver stole my order. They still made the order again and I got my delivery which I really appreciate.
Taylor H.• 11/01/25The best
David P.• 11/25/25Fat Sullys is THE BEST PIZZA IN COLORADO SPRINGS! Period.\nBest crust sauce cheese and it’s BIG!\nIt’s like REAL NYC PIZZA!
Shaun R.• 11/01/25Best pizza in Col Spgs. Simple & delicious!
Michael S.• 12/19/24I requested napkins, forks and plates but didn't get any of them. On the bright side the food was delicious.
Michael F.• 08/03/25Thank you very good
jorge M.• 11/17/24Love this place!
Christopher R.• 09/06/24Mom
Alex S.• 09/02/24It was very tasty!
Samantha F.• 08/25/24Great pizza. From NY and missing home. You guys do the best NY style pizza. Just like back home. Thank you!!
John H.• 08/04/24Big tasty slices
Michelle S.• 07/03/24Yummy!
Elie S.• 06/17/24Delicious sauce and crust!
Olivia H.• 05/01/24Nice
John P.• 05/15/24fantastic!
Jeanine A.• 05/14/24Best NY pizza around.
Nakkia S.• 05/09/24very good, love the sause the tenders come with
Scott C.• 04/26/24Great wings!
Youssef K.• 04/26/24Great ingredients definitely high quality and great flavor always consistent
Frank B.• 03/15/24really good burgers
Kevin A.• 02/28/24Friendly delivery
IAN M.• 02/28/24Best pizza I’ve had since I was a kid
Camille D.• 02/23/24Everything I’ve tried from here has been delicious
Chris H.• 02/22/24excellent
Evan C.• 02/11/24Great pizza!
Owen B.• 01/15/24NA
Airi B.• 01/14/24Great garlic knots and white pizza sauce!
Ryan B.• 12/16/23N/A
Sean W.• 12/03/23Great food
Fabian B.• 10/15/23Good
tracy R.• 09/24/23Best pizza in town !!!
ASHLEY D.• 09/02/23best pizza ever!
MATTHEW S.• 08/23/23Amazing pizza
Jean R.• 08/12/23Best Pizza in the Co. Springs area great flavor legit NY Style.
Alex L.• 08/07/23Delicious
Kimberly E.• 07/10/23sweet baby Jesus, I'm addicted to their garlic knots.
Jacob S.• 07/10/23Great thin pizza
Jennifer D.• 06/16/23The pizza and loaded garlic knots are amazing. Great food!!!
Coral R.• 06/14/23As a new yorker, its comforting finding authentic ny style pizza
LUIZ F.• 06/12/23Best pizza at CO Springs!!!
Peter C.• 06/08/23A great NY style pie. Never disappoints.
Olivia L.• 03/03/23great
Jered M.• 03/09/23great quality and delicious
Clinton A.• 03/09/23Best pizza downtown
James E.• 02/20/23Honestly the best pizza I had in a while. Thank you!
Can I order Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) delivery in Colorado Springs with Uber Eats?
Yes. Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) delivery is available on Uber Eats in Colorado Springs.
Is Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) delivery is available to your location in Colorado Springs.
How do I order Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) delivery online in Colorado Springs?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) delivery in Colorado Springs?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs) order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
What are some other stores nearby Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs)?
Here are some stores near Fat Sully's Pizza (Co. Springs):
MX Market
Upstate Pizzeria
The Ice Cream Parlor
Jack Quinn’s Irish Pub and Restaurant (Colorado Springs)
Brekkie Bix - Breakfast Sanwiches & Bowls
Streetcar520
Aces Burger Bar (1025 South Sierra Madre Street)
Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria
Gyro Express
McDonald’s® (Col Spngs-Wahsat)
