4.8
1000+ Ratings
Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant
4.8 x (1,000+) • 12018.7 km • Seafood • American • Alcohol • Group Friendly • Info
x Delivery unavailable
801 Eaton St, Key West, FL 33040, USA
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"I just had a tremendous dining experience at home without having to walk to the restaurant. Thank you so much I will recommend you to all of my friends who visit Key West.."
• Tommy P. • 02/06/24
"Lobster roll was lobster & mayo - no filler. Roll was overflowing with filling. Absolutely delicious!"
• Rebecca T. • 06/20/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Every Day
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Featured items
Mains
- Lobster Roll 8 inch roll$29.95 • 93% (283)The Classic Maine lobster meat, key lime mustard, mayo, and lemon juice on a traditional toasted 8 inch bun served with coleslaw and plantain chips.
- Fish or Shrimp Tacos$19.95 • 96% (225)Fresh fish or pink shrimp in our case that day fried, grilled, or blackened with spring mix, cabbage, tomato, and key lime mustard sauce served in our soft tacos served with coleslaw and plantain chips. Flour or corn tortilla.
- Fried Fish or Shrimp Basket$19.95 • 92% (225)Fresh chunks of our local fish or Key West pink shrimp fried served with coleslaw and french fries.
- Crab Cake Sandwich$17.95 • 94% (55)House-made blue crab cake pan-seared golden brown, spring greens, tomato, and remoulade on croissant roll served with coleslaw and plantain chips.
- Grilled Lobster Tail$25.95 • 88% (43)Served with butter, coleslaw, and plantain chips.
- Fish Sandwich$19.95 • 89% (46)Fresh fish of the day fried, grilled, or blackened with spring greens, tomato, and key lime mustard on ciabatta served with coleslaw and plantain chips.
- Ahi Tuna Salad Sandwich$16.95 • 100% (16)Served with spring greens, key lime mustard, and tomato on a croissant roll served with coleslaw and plantain chips.
- Shrimp Salad Sandwich$17.95 • 100% (43)Served with spring greens, key lime mustard, and tomato on a croissant roll served with coleslaw and plantain chips.
- Fish or Shrimp on a Salad$19.95 • 95% (42)Fresh fish or pink shrimp fried, grilled, or blackened on spring greens with tomato, cucumber, and green pepper with our signature key lime mustard dressing served on the side.
- Fried Conch Strip Basket$21.95 • 91% (35)Tenderized conch meat strips fried served with coleslaw and french fries.
- Onion Rings$5.95 • 90% (50)Beer battered & lightly fried onion rings.
- Shrimp Sandwich$19.95Key West pink shrimp fried, grilled, or blackened with spring greens, tomato, and key lime mustard on ciabatta served with coleslaw and plantain chips.
Appetizers & Sides
- New England Clam Chowder$5.95 • 89% (98)Clam chowder is any of several chowder soups in American cuisine containing clams and broth or milk. In addition to clams, common ingredients include diced potatoes, salt, onions, and celery.
- Smoke Fish Dip$13.95 • 100% (61)Served with Cuban crackers.
- Conch Fritters (6 pcs)$10.95 • 95% (144)Served with cocktail sauce.
- Fried Calamari$12.95 • 87% (58)Lightly dusted rings and tentacles served with marinara sauce.
- Cooked Key West Pink Shrimp$22.95 • 96% (80)Cooked Key West Pink Shrimp. Sold by the pound. 1 pound is about 16-20 shrimp. Peel and eat, comes with cocktail sauce.
- Chicken Tenders$13.95 • 94% (55)Served with fries.
- Conch Ceviche$16.95 • 80% (41)Served with tortilla chips.
- Buffalo Shrimp (8 pcs)$15.95 • 97% (41)Served with blue cheese.
Stone Crab
Beverages
Dessert
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•1000+ Ratings •
29 Reviews
Kristie H.• 06/07/24Conch strips on fkn point. 10/10 highly recommend.
Eleanor C.• 05/30/24Food there is outstanding, always has been, always will be.
Joanne F.• 05/21/24The food was fresh, hot and delicious. Would order from Eaton Seafood again
Traci A.• 04/22/24Quality ingredients cooked perfectly and packaged to go with everything as requested!! Excellent!
Victoria H.• 04/10/24Delicious and my favorite seafood spot
Victoria H.• 03/03/24Delicious and worth every penny
Tommy P.• 02/06/24I just had a tremendous dining experience at home without having to walk to the restaurant. Thank you so much I will recommend you to all of my friends who visit Key West..
Norman L.• 02/05/24Great food
Leonard C.• 01/22/24The fish and seafood are fresh and well prepared
Tim W.• 01/04/24The Lobster Roll is AWESOME!!
Todd M.• 11/02/23Best lobster roll in Florida!
Nes R.• 09/23/23Good
Abby C.• 08/14/23great thanks
HECTOR C.• 08/11/23Excelente Ceviche y Calamares Fritos 🙌
Joe H.• 08/10/23Excellent quality
Sekayi K.• 06/26/23Shrimp salad sandwich... on buttery croissant. Incredible ❣️
Rebecca T.• 06/20/23Lobster roll was lobster & mayo - no filler. Roll was overflowing with filling. Absolutely delicious!
steve M.• 06/10/23great
Sekayi K.• 05/28/23Delicious. Period.
Alison R.• 04/23/23Eaton Street had delicious food. It was delivered hot by Uber Eats.
Laura B.• 03/19/23Best fresh seafood on the island!
Cheryl J.• 02/11/23Yummy food…quick delivery
AMANDA A.• 01/30/23delicious!
Eric F.• 12/27/22Eatons Street Market is always amazing!
Annette C.• 10/10/22Absolutely the best Tuna Salad Sandwich in Key West
Joseph H.• 04/24/22Amazing service from Gladys!!
Dawn G.• 10/29/21Fabulous stone crab
Marie-Pierre S.• 10/13/21All around Very good. Shrimp and fish were as fresh as it gets.
Lauren B.• 10/12/21Food was delicious and well packaged
