4.6
1500+ Ratings
D'Amato's Seafood II
4.6 x (1,500+) • 2613.1 mi • Seafood • Caribbean • Sandwiches • Info
x Delivery unavailable
423 Whalley Ave
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"it has always served the best seafood. Even when I was a kid and they were on Grand Ave. I would rid my bike down the hill from Clifton street just to get 2 of their fish and cheese sandwiches."
• DUVAL R. • 03/12/23
"They have always had good food. Even when I was a kid I used ride my bike to the grand Ave spot and that too was great tasting food."
• DUVAL R. • 03/09/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
Monday - Wednesday
10:30 AM - 6:00 PM • Menu
10:30 AM - 6:00 PM • Lunch Specials
Thursday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 7:00 PM • Menu
11:00 AM - 7:00 PM • Lunch Specials
Featured items
Mixed Platters
- Shrimp & Clam Strips Mixed Platter$23.99 • 92% (151)All include fries and rings.
- Fillet & Clam Strips Mixed Platter$23.99 • 89% (29)All include fries and rings.
- Fillet & Shrimp Mixed Platter$23.99 • 86% (201)All include fries and rings.
- Shrimp & Scallop Mixed Platter$26.99 • 95% (101)All include fries and rings.
- Scallop & Clam Strips Mixed Platter$26.99 • 63% (19)All include fries and rings.
- Shrimp & Crab Cakes Mixed Platter$24.99 • 90% (10)All include fries and rings.
- Shrimp & Whole Clam (Quahogs) Mixed Platter$24.99 • 85% (27)All include fries and rings.
- Scallop & Whole Clam (Quahogs) Mixed Platter$27.99 • 93% (15)All include fries and rings.
Platters
- Shrimp Platter$23.99 • 92% (184)All include fries and rings.
- Calamari Platter$24.99 • 90% (10)All include fries and rings.
- Clam Strips Platter$23.99 • 100% (22)All include fries and rings.
- Scallop Platter$28.99 • 100% (14)All include fries and rings.
- Whole Clams (Quahogs) Platter$24.99 • 88% (17)All include fries and rings.
- Fried Lobster Tails Platter$35.99 • 100% (10)1/2 pound of golden fried lobster tails served with melted butter on the side. All include fries and rings.
- Triple Crab Cake Platter$21.99 • 85% (7)All include fries and rings.
Fish & Chips
Soup
Salads
Sandwiches
Burgers, Dogs & Chicken
Hot Buttered Rolls
Kids Menu
Side Orders
Beverages
Foxon Park Bottled Soda
Desserts
Lunch Specials
Our Delicious Sauces
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•1500+ Ratings •
85 Reviews
Monica M.• 05/20/24Food is fresh, hot and tastes divine.
paulina A.• 05/18/24the food was delicious 😋 every time I ordered its been very good loved it
Cj H.• 05/05/24good eats
Dee M.• 04/29/24Always delicious!!!!
imani S.• 04/25/2410 out if 10 definitely a bang for your buck
Nakia E.• 04/06/24The food is always fresh and the portions are just right!! Best seafood in town!!
Belinda W.• 04/03/24DELICIOUS 😋
Russell L.• 03/27/24best seafood around, arrived hot and fresh 😋
Peggie B.• 03/26/24good seafood 😋
Marcie C.• 03/23/24Great fried clam not oily tasting great portions.
Nesha L.• 03/21/24Love the food
Terence B.• 03/16/24the best !
nicole S.• 03/16/24I didn’t get my hush puppies
Naomi W.• 03/09/24D'Amato's always comes through. The great portion sizes, the great taste, and the great prices are fantastic..
Diamond D.• 03/01/24Good food. Never disappointed!
Mike T.• 02/23/24perfect.
MABEL N.• 02/01/24Delicious
Raquel T.• 01/20/24I will always love D'Amatos. xo
Belinda W.• 01/02/24The Best Seafood in Town
Marilyn B.• 12/15/23Deliciousness
Mike A.• 12/08/23Great food - very consistent
Lekeshia B.• 12/01/23Always a good meal especially the shrimp and hush puppies.
Tiffany W.• 11/20/23The food is always fresh and tasty.
Adjoa O.• 11/10/23Best fish
Peggie B.• 11/08/23been buying their seafood for over 40 years and they never let me down love their food
Adjoa O.• 11/07/23Good
Dae S.• 10/17/23Followed my instructions & everything was delicious
Belinda W.• 10/16/23Just Delicious
LISL H.• 10/08/23First time ordering from D’Amato’s. The food was delicious and fresh!
Jose L P.• 09/21/23tasty
April G.• 09/06/23there food is always tasty and plus fresh
CORONA T.• 08/30/23Combo was cooked to perfection will order again
Steve F.• 08/26/23Never go wrong with their delicious seafood!
taurean D.• 08/25/23fresh and delicious
Naomi J.• 08/23/23Food is top quality, always so delicious
Corbin P.• 08/13/23they got the best platters
Felicia W.• 08/12/23Always perfectly cooked and delicious.
Robert R.• 08/10/23perfect all around
Belinda W.• 08/05/23The food is Delicious As Always
Jose L P.• 08/02/23Been in the business for many years, good food
Monica M.• 08/01/23The food is always fresh, tastes good and they follow the customer’s notes.
Lisa G.• 07/29/23Food is always outstanding!!
Peggy C.• 07/29/23Always good & fresh.
Angie N.• 07/28/23It’s always fresh & you get a lot
Marcella K.• 07/27/23I had the flounder sandwich with cheese and tomatoe. It was delicious and the portion was huge.
Alan M.• 07/24/23A favorite when I visit New Haven.
Peggy C.• 07/23/23best seafood
WILLIAM A.• 07/15/23good shrimp
Sarita Renee W.• 07/10/23Great price, quick delivery. 10/10 recommend.
Peggy C.• 07/08/23always fresh
Aim S.• 07/05/23McDonald’s makes the best Big Macs I’ve ever had. Thanks Mickey D’S.
John D.• 07/01/23Delicious seafood
Michele S.• 06/29/23The food is delicious. Best seafood around.
Jatorra P.• 06/27/23Best seafood in town! Well seasoned and cooked to perfection! Love that you get fries and onion rings with each platter.
Jeff S.• 06/23/23Delicious
Drucilla C.• 06/22/23Good food
Honora W.• 06/21/23best seafood ever
Jhamari M.• 05/31/23Food is and always delicious!
Belinda W.• 05/24/23Delicious As Always
Chandler J.• 05/02/23Excellent food and service is great. Seasoned to perfection.
Ada L.• 04/29/23fresh tasty fish.
Kimberly J.• 04/21/23Good food and consistent quality
Patricia B.• 04/20/23The food is ALWAYS fresh and good! I have been going there for years and the consistency is the same. I love it. 🙏🏼💜🥰🥰👍
Belinda W.• 04/18/23very Good
Orlando M.• 04/04/23good food
Heidi M.• 04/02/23fresh and tasty. perfectly cooked. Highly recommended.
TONIA P.• 03/17/23food was still hot...
DUVAL R.• 03/12/23it has always served the best seafood. Even when I was a kid and they were on Grand Ave. I would rid my bike down the hill from Clifton street just to get 2 of their fish and cheese sandwiches.
Damon R.• 03/11/23Great food
DUVAL R.• 03/09/23They have always had good food. Even when I was a kid I used ride my bike to the grand Ave spot and that too was great tasting food.
Frank I.• 02/17/23Food tastes great
Andrew A.• 02/08/23Quality
Aleatha K.• 01/31/23First time ordering/tasting D'Amato's. Great food, great portions!!
Frank C.• 01/30/23Food was great and plenty of it!!
Sally H.• 01/18/23Love love love!!
Peggie B.• 01/15/23Always Love there Seafood
Sheryl B.• 01/06/23CONSISTENTLY DELICIOUS!!!
Kali W.• 12/09/22always perfect!
Tanisha C.• 11/27/22I’ve been eating from the since they were located on Grand Ave Live their food and friendly customer service
Val A.• 09/21/22Great and plenty of food
karrie D.• 04/23/22Seafood is good. Had fried clams with whole belly Tonite for the first time and they were good.
Laqueana C.• 02/27/22Delicious
Shawn B.• 11/17/21the best!!
Shaira M.• 11/04/21Fresh
Amy F.• 09/16/21The food here is always good! I’ve been eating with this family since they were in Fair Haven!
