4.6
2000+ Ratings
Caffe Amici
4.6 x (2,000+) • Italian • Comfort Food • Salads • Pizza • Pasta • Wings • Chicken • Fish & Seafood • Soup • Info
x Available at 11:00 AM
353 Independence Plz, Selden, NY 11784
(631) 698-0818
Rating and reviews
"First time ordering from Caffe Amici. Everything was excellent! Portion sizes were very generous, and the order was prepared (and subsequently delivered) very quickly."
• Michele M. • 12/13/22
"The pasta and pizza we ordered were delicious. The portion of Broccoli Rabe was huge. The delivery was quick."
• Carolyn K. • 05/04/24
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Featured items
Antipasti
Zuppe
Insalata
Pasta
From the Oven
Combination Dishes
Entrées
Pollo
Pesce
Zuppe Di Pesce
Heros
Pizza
Specialty Pies
Calzones and Rolls
On the Side
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•2000+ Ratings •
58 Reviews
Anita S.• 11/22/25Always perfect!
Gail G.• 10/17/25Portion was tremendous. Enough for three meals for me. Very good.
Nick C.• 05/21/25Excellent flavor. Enough for two meals. Will definately order again!
allison P.• 04/25/25All other Italian restaurants can close, no one comes close to Amici
SANDRA W.• 03/17/25Delicious square pizza, excellent turnaround time from ordering to delivery!
Brittney S.• 03/07/25Delicious!
Suzie G.• 03/06/25Fast and efficient.
Cherisse L.• 01/03/25Large portions, always fresh and hot! Fast turnaround. Reliable.
Christian M.• 12/30/24very consistent
Amairani O.• 12/19/24Best pizza
Brandon C.• 11/23/24delicious
Dawn S.• 10/19/24Everything was great 😄
Rosalba V.• 09/21/24thank You for making My pizza well done as requested
Robert K.• 08/28/24Store customer service is above and beyond expectation.
George K.• 08/11/24excellent service
Marisol Q.• 07/22/24Good food!!!
Sam M.• 07/16/2410
Alex R.• 07/07/24Mad good
concetta C.• 06/23/24best tasting pizza
Jennifer M.• 05/19/24Never disappoints! Delicious & well made!
Danielle G.• 05/16/24friendly staff
Nick A.• 05/14/24Very good food
Carolyn K.• 05/04/24The pasta and pizza we ordered were delicious. The portion of Broccoli Rabe was huge. The delivery was quick.
Nanette S.• 04/28/24Always hot, fresh, and delicious.
Donna C.• 04/05/24Food is always delicious
Ryan A.• 03/27/24Quality food and super fresh!
tom M.• 03/21/24Great
JEFFREY A.• 03/15/24Delicious
Bob M.• 03/04/24Very Delicious Pizza 🍕
Jess I.• 01/31/24good
Jose M.• 01/21/24can't compare, best pizza
Linda W.• 01/13/24Quick delv, great food
ALICIA S.• 12/04/23Always great quality.
Nanette S.• 09/30/23pizzas are delicious. fresh and tasty
Danielle S.• 08/27/23Great price and quick delivery
Louise L.• 08/24/23Love their pizza
George L.• 08/21/23Great food that arrived correctly and fast.
T S.• 07/22/23everything is delicious!
Brandon B.• 07/20/23current promotions are unbeatable.
jennifer V.• 07/16/23Always delicious!
maria S.• 07/10/23Best pizza in town!!
Christine L.• 07/03/23Perfect!!
James B.• 06/24/23Great pizza!
Tracie B.• 06/22/23Good
ANABELA A.• 06/20/23Good pizza, nice service
John K.• 06/19/23Great food
Traci E.• 03/10/23Good experience
Amanda L.• 02/26/23My favorite
Ana M.• 01/27/23Excellent
Meghan R.• 01/05/23delicious
Jennifer T.• 12/18/22food and service are always great
Michele M.• 12/13/22First time ordering from Caffe Amici. Everything was excellent! Portion sizes were very generous, and the order was prepared (and subsequently delivered) very quickly.
Corrin B.• 12/03/22best pizza for sure
Chuck P.• 08/21/22Excellent
Michele M.• 03/31/22Delicious as usual
Doctor Adrienne B.• 03/21/22Great
MICHAEL P.• 03/19/22Great food !!!!
Maureen F.• 03/12/22The food was satisfying and exactly as expected
