4.8
800+ Ratings
Buttermilk Bake Shop
4.8 x (800+) • 3055.9 km • American • Desserts • Bakery • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
264 5th Avenue
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"The cake is really delicious very good quality and was really good at following the information on my request. My only issue is that no one answers the phone. I almost didn't order from here because of that , but I was in a time crunch. Good cake"
• Meiko H. • 04/18/24
"Delicious cake, perfect for my birthday!"
• MAUREEN Z. • 10/22/21
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday
11:00 AM - 5:40 PM
Monday
Tuesday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 5:40 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 7:40 PM
Featured items
Gift Boxes
- Assorted Sweets Gift Boxes (12 Piece)$25.00 • 100% (4)Our favorite gift box includes 5 assorted chocolate-covered Oreos and 6 assorted macarons.
- Assorted Macarons Gift Box (6 piece)$15.00 • 95% (22)Vanilla, Pistachio, Chocolate, Espresso, Raspberry, Tiramisu
- Chocolate Covered Oreo Gift Box (6 piece)$15.00
Cookies
- 4 Pack of Cookies$16.00 • 95% (23)
- Sprinkle$3.25his item is limited to a maximum purchase of 2 units per order.Popular
- Salted Nutella$3.60 • 91% (45)
- Chocolate-Chunk$3.60 • 94% (95)
- Chai Spice Snickerdoodle$3.60 • 88% (45)
- V/GF Chocolate Chunk Cookie$3.60 • 87% (24)
- 6 Pack of Cookies$23.00 • 91% (23)
- Sprinkle$3.60 • 95% (45)
- 12 Pack of Cookies$42.00 • 90% (10)
- Chocolate Almond Oat$3.60 • 100% (20)
- Peanut Butter$3.60 • 95% (21)
- Vegan Ginger Snap$3.60 • 92% (25)
- Cookies And Cream Cookie$3.60
Six-Inch Cakes
- Classic Birthday Package$59.00 • 97% (35)Classic birthday cake composed of vanilla cake, raspberry jam, and vanilla buttercream or double Chocolate cake. Included personal inscription on cake, handwritten card, and candles! Please request inscription in the special order notes!
- Double Chocolate$48.00 • 94% (19)Chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream. Yum!
(8 - 10 ppl)
Mini-Cakes
Bars
Cupcakes
Pies
Cakepops
Cake in the Jar for Two!
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•800+ Ratings •
15 Reviews
URIEL B.• 05/15/24So good!
Meiko H.• 04/18/24The cake is really delicious very good quality and was really good at following the information on my request. My only issue is that no one answers the phone. I almost didn't order from here because of that , but I was in a time crunch. Good cake
Stephani S.• 04/12/24Yum!
S. J.• 03/17/24Perfect vanilla mini cake!
Carl C.• 03/07/24Fire!
Marquis A.• 02/14/24Quick delivery!
esteban Q.• 11/12/23excellent selections
Nicole K.• 03/03/23Great price.
Denise G.• 03/01/23These cookies are super delicious..
Sophie L.• 06/26/22Thanks for sorting so quickly!
Nashuda A.• 05/13/22Delicious!
Sheya J.• 12/18/21Great !!!! Amazing!!!!!!
MAUREEN Z.• 10/22/21Delicious cake, perfect for my birthday!
Aida Z.• 10/05/21Lovely!
Louise H.• 08/12/21Fantastic!
