4.7
3000+ Ratings
Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike)
4.7 x (3,000+) • 5824.6 km • Breakfast and Brunch • Desserts • Bakery • Group Friendly • € • Info
x Available Sunday 7:00 AM
Tap for hours, info, and more
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"Absolutely love this place! Anything you ask for, they deliver on. Need a candle? They got it! Need something written on a cake you got last minute?They got you covered!"
• Annaliza J. • 09/08/23
"They went above and beyond - I just asked for a happy birthday note and they actually added it to the cake on-top of a piece chocolate which they added. THANK YOU!"
• Ashley H. • 12/15/21
$0.00
Pricing & fees
Closed
Pickup time
Every Day
7:00 AM - 7:30 PM • Dessert
7:00 AM - 7:00 PM • Custom Order
Featured items
Showcase Cakes
- Strawberry Shortcake$32.85 • 94% (222)Vanilla Cake with Fresh Strawberries and Whipped Cream topped with Whipped Cream Icing
- Shadow Cake - Chocolate$28.95Vanilla and chocolate cake filled with chocolate buttercream, topped with chocolate buttercream and a chocolate ganache drizzlePopular
- Flower Celebration Cake - Vanilla$28.95 • 89% (93)Vanilla Cake
Vanilla Buttercream Filling
Vanilla Buttercream Icing
3 Buttercream Roses on top
Please indicate inscription in special instructions - Black Forest$32.85 • 95% (85)Chocolate cake filled with chocolate whipped cream and black cherries, topped with cherries, whipped cream and chocolate shavings
- Shadow Cake - Vanilla$28.95Vanilla and chocolate cake filled with vanilla buttercream topped with vanilla buttercream icing and a chocolate ganache drizzle
- Flower Celebration Cake - Chocolate$28.95 • 88% (45)Chocolate Cake
Chocolate Pudding Filling
Chocolate Fudge Icing
3 Buttercream Roses on top
Please indicate inscription in special instructions - 7 Layer Cake - Small$16.50Seven thin layers of Vanilla Cake alternating with a thin layer of Chocolate Buttercream and topped with hard chocolate icing
- Fruit Salad Cake$39.65 • 93% (58)Vanilla Cake filled with Fresh Strawberries, Bananas, Peaches and Pineapples topped with Whipped Cream Icing
- Large Fruit Torte$42.85 • 90% (52)Pastry shell lined with chocolate and vanilla custard topped with fresh fruit
- Mocha Cake$32.85 • 90% (54)Vanilla cake soaked in coffee syrup with mocha buttercream topped with sliced almonds.
- 7 Layer Cake - Individual Slice$7.95Seven thin layers of Vanilla Cake alternating with a thin layer of Chocolate Buttercream and topped with hard chocolate icingPopular
- Carrot Cake$32.85 • 93% (47)Carrot Cake filled with Raisins and Sweet Cream Cheese and iced with sweet cream cheese, coconut flakes and topped with Marzipan carrots
- NY Cheesecake Strawberry - Individual Size$8.15 • 92% (154)
- Dulce de Leche$32.85Vanilla Cake
Ducle de Leche
Ducle de leche Buttercream - Cheesecake - NY Style 7"$24.65 • 100% (48)
- Cheesecake - NY Style 7" topped with Strawberries$32.85 • 96% (86)
- Cannoli Cake$44.65Our signature cannoli filling set atop layers of moist vanilla cake, enclosed by a thin ring of rainbow cookies, finished with a light coating of raspberry jam and a crispy fried shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese
- Candles$2.95 • 92% (83)
- 7-Layer Cake Large$28.50 • 89% (29)Seven thin layers of Vanilla Cake alternating with a thin layer of Chocolate Buttercream and topped with hard chocolate icing
Cupcakes & Cake Pops
Cookies by the Pound
Mousse Cakes
Individual Pastries & Slices
Jumbo Cookies & Sweets
Breakfast Pastries
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•3000+ Ratings •
108 Reviews
Zymeen C.• 05/08/24Absolutely Delicious Cakes. Always Have Whole cakes available. Everyone who eats it loves it. Definitely worth the price.
Fahmida C.• 05/05/24Thank you so much for your service/ really appreciate your last minute accommodation to drop it at a different location
Michael T.• 05/05/24great
Adam B.• 04/30/24Was able to get my mom a birthday cake on short notice, awesome job
Juanita N.• 04/26/24Great Service!
Eva C.• 04/20/24One of the best cakes I’ve ever tasted & Staff are very professional.
Manjit G.• 04/20/24always rock
Rina O.• 04/17/24Always amazing and fresh.
Jeremy M.• 04/17/24Great chocolate mousse cake , I bought it for my dad and it was perfect . Not overly sweet where you might get diabetes .
Loretta S.• 04/16/24Always good
Samantha S.• 04/10/24Amazing
Selina S.• 04/02/24Fresh and tasty
Julio E.• 03/31/24love their desert
Vivine H.• 03/31/24Love the taste and presentation.
Ngina G.• 03/12/24Always great cakes and pastries!
Justine H.• 02/28/24Lovely as always
Jacques D.• 02/28/24Great cake!!!
Erika H.• 02/26/24i love everything!
Summi M.• 02/25/24Tasty pastries
Veer J.• 02/23/24Good
TA-SHUNNA W.• 02/22/24Amazing taste I absolutely love the cake. I definitely will be ordering again.
Natasha R.• 02/20/24Amazing desserts! Love them!
Simone D.• 02/10/24Delicious
Danny R.• 02/01/24Cake is awesome what more can you say
Geidy R.• 01/31/24Best tres leche cake I’ve ever had and friendly nice staff.
Kelen L.• 01/23/24Everything I order from here is always delicious.
Zanae D.• 01/12/24Delicious cake and amazing service. Great for any occasion.
Jose Q.• 01/12/24Fresh
Christiana A.• 01/10/24Delicious, fresh and timely
Samala A.• 01/03/24Scrumptious desserts.
Coranny J.• 01/01/24Awesome
Natasha R.• 12/31/23Amazing desserts! Love them
Taiye A.• 12/31/23Good
Abigaelle A.• 12/24/23I love this store
Jillian N.• 12/24/23Absolutely delicious cake!!!
Jennifer Y.• 12/17/23Fav strawberry shortcake
Louis G.• 12/17/23We love Buttercooky Bakery everything is always made to perfection!!!!
Hisen D.• 12/11/23Delicious
Ranjit S.• 12/10/23Awesome
Kelen L.• 12/03/23Cake was perfect! Delicious and moist.
Anita P.• 12/03/23Best cakes and pastries
Onyl Dawn C.• 11/18/23Always delicious
Brianna B.• 11/14/23Great job
Helena A.• 11/12/23always a go-to
Stefy T.• 11/12/23Best tres leches!
Michelle A.• 11/09/23They never disappoint!
Veer J.• 11/06/23Good
John D.• 10/28/23great black and white cookies
Nahid M.• 10/20/23The best bakery
Madeline M.• 10/14/23Always fresh and delicious
Rosalie T.• 10/13/23The cake taste delicious and they did my request of writing happy birthday on the cake
Monisha M.• 10/06/23Very good
Sandeep S.• 09/23/23Good
james G.• 09/19/23GET THE CARROT CAKE
Lucky G.• 09/13/23Delicious
Elizabeth S.• 09/11/23good baked goods
Annaliza J.• 09/08/23Absolutely love this place! Anything you ask for, they deliver on. Need a candle? They got it! Need something written on a cake you got last minute?They got you covered!
Jan V.• 09/01/23Corey was very courteous and so prompt and knew the area so well! My order was delivered in the utmost care!
Bryan D.• 08/26/23Great Everything!
Dee P.• 08/26/23fresh and great portions for the price
Aimi T.• 08/24/23Yummy
Irving C.• 08/19/23I love the pastries from here. The eclair and cannoli are my favorite though.
Anita M.• 08/17/23Friendly and professional service. Delicious cakes!
Isheema S.• 08/15/23French Strawberry shortcake is very delicious.
Syed H.• 08/12/23Nice
Lourdumary S.• 08/10/23very satisfied
Fahad I.• 08/09/23Good cake
Ranita M.• 08/01/23Excellent everything.
Ranita M.• 07/31/23Everything was just perfect!
Helen C.• 07/14/23everything is delicious!
Marilyn A.• 06/24/23I order from Mexico through the app, I asked for a note to say I love you in Spanish, it was a birthday cake and they made it happen… thank you everyone
Dylan B.• 06/20/23stunning and gorgeous tres leches
Khalilia S.• 06/18/23I loved the lemon tart and the strawberry cheesecake
Eva C.• 06/18/23I’m a first time customer and am very pleased with the cake I ordered. Packed & beautifully decorated!
Riana K.• 06/18/23It’s rlly good
Mercedes G.• 06/17/23the best f cake in the world
Olivia Y.• 06/12/23For any birthday or occasion, I can never go wrong with ButterCooky's cakes! Absolutely love there cakes!
Rosa P.• 06/11/23Buenísimo todo fresco y buena presentación lo mejor de lo mejor
Lindsay L.• 05/17/23always delicious
Grace K.• 05/17/23Love! Love! Love!
Brittany J.• 04/16/23This is the best bakery ever! My favorites are the blueberry tart, strawberry shortcake, and tres leches.
Sandra M.• 04/15/23Very tasty cake and well design
Renay M.• 04/11/23Cheese danish and apple turnover are the best!
Jason J.• 04/10/23Great
Carolyn H.• 04/09/23Best cakes. Get them every party. No leftovers ever.
David L.• 04/09/23best sweets
Crystal C.• 03/18/23Always amazing cakes
Tracey H.• 03/11/23Cakes are delicious
Wendy C.• 03/02/23Love the pastries.
Brittany J.• 02/27/23The blueberry tarts are delicious! The ingredients are always fresh.
Henry K.• 02/26/23My first experience with Buttercooky n it was Par Excellence
Nervanie S.• 02/23/23Great and tasty
Chanel A.• 02/01/23So good!!
Kiran A.• 01/15/23Great cake!!
Pam S.• 01/02/23Food always fresh. They don’t have a problem with delivering to my home in Jamaica NY. Fast service.
Christine F.• 12/14/22Wonderful shadow cake. Fresh and delicious.
Natasha R.• 12/10/22Amazing bakery! Love their treats! ^_^
Charisse C.• 11/12/22perfect!
Tisha T.• 11/06/22Cake was fresh & tasty! Delivery was quick & easy.
SHREYa C.• 10/07/22Great service!
maria T.• 09/16/22Strawberry shortcake was out of this world.
Runako D.• 07/01/22the best
Lola S.• 06/06/22Absolutely tasty I was so happy
Anna S.• 04/01/22Cake is so fresh.
Arceli N.• 02/06/22We received the cake in absolutely perfect condition.
Maria M.• 12/21/21So glad I discovered this gem! Great service beautiful and tasty treats. This will be my new go to.
Ashley H.• 12/15/21They went above and beyond - I just asked for a happy birthday note and they actually added it to the cake on-top of a piece chocolate which they added. THANK YOU!
Carmen B.• 08/19/21Just as I expected,Delicious an neatly delivered
