4.6
6000+ Ratings
Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike)
4.6 x (6,000+) • Breakfast and Brunch • Desserts • Bakery • Group Friendly • $ • Info
x No delivery people nearby
217 Jericho Turnpike, Floral Park, NY 11001
Rating and reviews
"I was looking for a mince pie for Thanksgiving but couldn’t find one anywhere and any store that had the ingredients had already sold out. Not only did Buttercooky have them, when they didn’t have the size I ordered, they subbed out two of the smaller size and didn’t charge extra. I’m actually glad we have two pies because everybody wanted to have some right now and it’s absolutely delicious!! Highly, highly recommend Buttercooky Bakery for quality and customer service!!"
• Debra C. • 11/26/25
"Absolutely love this place! Anything you ask for, they deliver on. Need a candle? They got it! Need something written on a cake you got last minute?They got you covered!"
• Annaliza J. • 09/08/23
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Every Day
7:00 AM - 7:30 PM
Featured items
Happy Holiday Treats :)
8" Pies & Mini Pies
Sweet Treats Ready 2 Go
Savory Bites
DUBAI CHOCOLATE TREATS <3
Breakfast Pastries
Croissants
Bread/Bagels
Brownies & Donuts
Rings/Horns
Showcase Cakes
Mousse Cakes
Individual Slices
Cheesecakes
Cupcakes
Cake Pops
French Pastries, Tarts, Eclairs
Large Cookies & Sweets
Coffee / Espresso/ Tea / Hot Coco
Candles
Custom Order (Cake, Bread, Cupcakes, Cookies, ETC...)
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•6000+ Ratings •
145 Reviews
lucia T.• 01/03/26Good delivery
Moqudas J.• 12/03/25Doesn’t taste as fresh as usual
Sophia D.• 12/03/25Friendly and efficient staff!
sadna H.• 12/26/25Thank you for your patience
Natasha R.• 12/03/25Always the best sweets around!
Debra C.• 11/26/25I was looking for a mince pie for Thanksgiving but couldn’t find one anywhere and any store that had the ingredients had already sold out. Not only did Buttercooky have them, when they didn’t have the size I ordered, they subbed out two of the smaller size and didn’t charge extra. I’m actually glad we have two pies because everybody wanted to have some right now and it’s absolutely delicious!! Highly, highly recommend Buttercooky Bakery for quality and customer service!!
Jeanine L.• 11/24/25Fast and friendly
Bielka M.• 11/06/25Excelentes postres
Mayuri S.• 11/04/25good dessert
Liz P.• 10/03/25Order was delivered quikly, thank you!!
Rae-Anna S.• 09/17/25Great
MAIYAH P.• 09/16/25Thank you so much!
Celina V.• 08/18/25Quick and accommodating.
June S.• 08/16/25Omg unbelievable. I HIGHLY recommend. The delivery was stellor but the pastries are OUT OF THIS WORLD
lemi S.• 08/12/25Beautiful very satisfied .
Dyann D.• 07/25/25Omg!!! Large portions and delicious deserts! This is my new spot for special occasions.
Nuranjalie O.• 07/19/25The quality, the service, amazing. Truly my favorite bakery in New York!
Aisal K.• 07/05/25Great
CHENNELL H.• 06/27/25French strawberry shortcake for the win. It was very moist and it wasn’t too sweet
TaTyana P.• 05/09/25Amazing quality and quick service
romah S.• 04/18/25Driver was early, happy with the delivery order, thank you.
Lupita D.• 04/11/25Muy Rico todo y frescos gracias
Maitri J.• 04/10/25Very nice and delivered quickly.
Wayne B.• 04/05/25very very goooooooooooood
Jennifer H.• 03/25/25Delicious fresh baked goods 💕
Mark B.• 03/14/25The best cakes
thomas M.• 03/09/25Yummy
Shayn L.• 03/08/255 stars every single time. Thank you! It is worth it.
TRENIA K.• 02/26/25Everything was Perfect!
Christina T.• 02/06/25This was such a great first experience!! The cake was delicious and we even got the details 100 percent above and beyond!!! Thanks so much !! ☺️
Luz S.• 01/18/25The Tres Leches cake was super delicious! The best tasting cake of this type !
John D.• 01/13/25good cookies
whitney S.• 12/08/24Excellent bakery!
leila B.• 12/02/24so good i loved everything i ordered
Rolando M.• 11/27/24Everything is always Freshly baked.
Robert P.• 11/09/24there bakery all is great.
Amin K.• 10/21/24Best tres leche
Mari R.• 09/09/24Best cake ever
Rachel L.• 08/23/24Fast, efficient, and delicious!
Rhonda G.• 08/17/24delicious
CLYDE W.• 07/24/24Order the Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse cake for shared with 10 of my friends. It was delicious and enjoyed by all.
Sheleema H.• 07/23/24Delicious!
Marie P.• 07/14/24Love love love !
James A.• 07/11/24I felt special having a delivery like this so early in the morning!
Dorla G.• 07/08/24Everything was delicious. I ordered from here just to test the pastries and I wasn’t disappointed.
Philippe G.• 06/18/24Great service and very helpful staff
Morika G.• 06/02/24Thank you
Cecile C.• 05/28/24The Best of the Best!!!!!
Sazzad H.• 05/26/24Best cake in the neighborhood
Zymeen C.• 05/08/24Absolutely Delicious Cakes. Always Have Whole cakes available. Everyone who eats it loves it. Definitely worth the price.
Fahmida C.• 05/05/24Thank you so much for your service/ really appreciate your last minute accommodation to drop it at a different location
Michael T.• 05/05/24great
Max G.• 04/02/24Was able to get my mom a birthday cake on short notice, awesome job
Juanita N.• 04/26/24Great Service!
Eva C.• 04/20/24One of the best cakes I’ve ever tasted & Staff are very professional.
Manjit S.• 04/20/24always rock
Rina O.• 04/17/24Always amazing and fresh.
Jeremy M.• 04/17/24Great chocolate mousse cake , I bought it for my dad and it was perfect . Not overly sweet where you might get diabetes .
Samantha S.• 04/10/24Amazing
Selina S.• 04/02/24Fresh and tasty
Vivine H.• 03/03/24Love the taste and presentation.
Julio E.• 03/03/24love their desert
Ngina G.• 03/12/24Always great cakes and pastries!
Justine H.• 02/28/24Lovely as always
Jacques D.• 02/28/24Great cake!!!
Erika H.• 02/26/24i love everything!
Summi M.• 02/25/24Tasty pastries
Veer J.• 02/23/24Good
TA-SHUNNA W.• 02/22/24Amazing taste I absolutely love the cake. I definitely will be ordering again.
Simone D.• 02/10/24Delicious
Danny R.• 02/01/24Cake is awesome what more can you say
Geidy R.• 01/03/24Best tres leche cake I’ve ever had and friendly nice staff.
Kelen L.• 01/23/24Everything I order from here is always delicious.
Zanae D.• 01/12/24Delicious cake and amazing service. Great for any occasion.
Christiana A.• 01/10/24Delicious, fresh and timely
Samala A.• 01/03/24Scrumptious desserts.
Coranny J.• 01/01/24Awesome
Taiye A.• 12/03/23Good
Jillian N.• 12/24/23Absolutely delicious cake!!!
Abigaelle A.• 12/24/23I love this store
Louis G.• 12/17/23We love Buttercooky Bakery everything is always made to perfection!!!!
Jennifer Y.• 12/17/23Fav strawberry shortcake
Hisen D.• 12/11/23Delicious
Ranjit S.• 12/10/23Awesome
Anita P.• 12/03/23Best cakes and pastries
Onyl Dawn C.• 11/18/23Always delicious
Brianna B.• 11/14/23Great job
Stefy T.• 11/12/23Best tres leches!
Helena A.• 11/12/23always a go-to
Michelle A.• 11/09/23They never disappoint!
Nahid M.• 10/20/23The best bakery
Madeline M.• 10/14/23Always fresh and delicious
Rosalie T.• 10/13/23The cake taste delicious and they did my request of writing happy birthday on the cake
Monisha M.• 10/06/23Very good
Sandeep S.• 09/23/23Good
james G.• 09/19/23GET THE CARROT CAKE
Lucky G.• 09/13/23Delicious
Elizabeth S.• 09/11/23good baked goods
Annaliza J.• 09/08/23Absolutely love this place! Anything you ask for, they deliver on. Need a candle? They got it! Need something written on a cake you got last minute?They got you covered!
Jan V.• 09/01/23Corey was very courteous and so prompt and knew the area so well! My order was delivered in the utmost care!
Bryan D.• 08/26/23Great Everything!
Dee P.• 08/26/23fresh and great portions for the price
Aimi T.• 08/24/23Yummy
Irving C.• 08/19/23I love the pastries from here. The eclair and cannoli are my favorite though.
Anita M.• 08/17/23Friendly and professional service. Delicious cakes!
Isheema S.• 08/15/23French Strawberry shortcake is very delicious.
Syed H.• 08/12/23Nice
Lourdumary S.• 08/10/23very satisfied
Fahad I.• 08/09/23Good cake
RANITA M.• 08/01/23Excellent everything.
Helen C.• 07/14/23everything is delicious!
Marilyn A.• 06/24/23I order from Mexico through the app, I asked for a note to say I love you in Spanish, it was a birthday cake and they made it happen… thank you everyone
Dylan B.• 06/20/23stunning and gorgeous tres leches
Riana K.• 06/18/23It’s rlly good
Khalilia S.• 06/18/23I loved the lemon tart and the strawberry cheesecake
Mercedes G.• 06/17/23the best f cake in the world
Olivia Y.• 06/12/23For any birthday or occasion, I can never go wrong with ButterCooky's cakes! Absolutely love there cakes!
Rosa P.• 06/11/23Buenísimo todo fresco y buena presentación lo mejor de lo mejor
Lindsay L.• 05/17/23always delicious
Grace K.• 05/17/23Love! Love! Love!
Brittany J.• 04/16/23This is the best bakery ever! My favorites are the blueberry tart, strawberry shortcake, and tres leches.
Sandra M.• 04/15/23Very tasty cake and well design
Renay M.• 04/11/23Cheese danish and apple turnover are the best!
Jason J.• 04/10/23Great
Carolyn H.• 04/09/23Best cakes. Get them every party. No leftovers ever.
David L.• 04/09/23best sweets
Crystal C.• 03/18/23Always amazing cakes
Tracey H.• 03/11/23Cakes are delicious
Wendy C.• 03/02/23Love the pastries.
Henry K.• 02/26/23My first experience with Buttercooky n it was Par Excellence
Nervanie S.• 02/23/23Great and tasty
Chanel A.• 02/01/23So good!!
Kiran A.• 01/15/23Great cake!!
Christine F.• 12/14/22Wonderful shadow cake. Fresh and delicious.
Charisse C.• 11/12/22perfect!
Tisha T.• 11/06/22Cake was fresh & tasty! Delivery was quick & easy.
SHREYa C.• 10/07/22Great service!
maria T.• 09/16/22Strawberry shortcake was out of this world.
Runako D.• 07/01/22the best
Lola S.• 06/06/22Absolutely tasty I was so happy
Anna S.• 04/01/22Cake is so fresh.
Arceli N.• 02/06/22We received the cake in absolutely perfect condition.
Maria M.• 12/21/21So glad I discovered this gem! Great service beautiful and tasty treats. This will be my new go to.
Ashley H.• 12/15/21They went above and beyond - I just asked for a happy birthday note and they actually added it to the cake on-top of a piece chocolate which they added. THANK YOU!
Carmen B.• 08/19/21Just as I expected,Delicious an neatly delivered
Can I order Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) delivery in Floral Park with Uber Eats?
Yes. Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) delivery is available on Uber Eats in Floral Park.
Is Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) delivery is available to your location in Floral Park.
How do I order Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) delivery online in Floral Park?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) delivery in Floral Park?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike) order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
