4.7
1500+ Ratings
Bexley Pizza Plus
4.7 x (1,500+) • Pizza • American • Italian • Salads • $ • Info
x No delivery people nearby
2651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209
Rating and reviews
"My 8 inch MINI PEPPERONI Pizza was amazing!!!!! It came piping hot, fresh, and earlier than I was expecting by 30 minutes! The Italian sub is to die for! The banana peppers alone are like no other, with just the right amount Zesty Italian."
• De'Von W. • 11/05/25
"The Pie is one of the best in town and it will not disappoint! It comes hot and the ingredients are fresh and plentiful. I love this place and it's a mom and pop shop!!!"
• CAITLYN S. • 09/13/24
x $0 delivery fee
Other fees x
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:20 AM - 8:30 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:20 AM - 9:30 PM
Create Your Own Pizza (No Half-item Pizzas)
Specialty White Pizzas (8")( No Half-item Pizzas)
Specialty White Pizzas (12") (No Half-item Pizzas)
Specialty White Pizzas (14") ( No half-item Pizzas)
Specialty Red Pizzas 8"(No half-item Pizzas)
Specialty Red Pizzas (12")( No half-item Pizzas)
Specialty Red Pizzas (14")(No Half-item Pizzas)
Extras
Subs
Salads
Desserts & Chips
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•1500+ Ratings •
29 Reviews
Lynette F.• 11/06/25This your go-to pizza place. Always delicious.
De'Von W.• 11/05/25My 8 inch MINI PEPPERONI Pizza was amazing!!!!! It came piping hot, fresh, and earlier than I was expecting by 30 minutes! The Italian sub is to die for! The banana peppers alone are like no other, with just the right amount Zesty Italian.
Regina B.• 03/12/25The food was hot fresh and delicious. It also came on time. The driver was kind and efficient. Great experience!
Ed M.• 12/30/24Mexican pizza was fantastic
Dejha V.• 11/06/24good
Nolan C.• 11/03/24Every time I come home to Columbus from Florida I order from pizza plus, specifically the Ultimate. 20(?) years later, still the best pizza I've ever eaten.
CAITLYN S.• 09/13/24The Pie is one of the best in town and it will not disappoint! It comes hot and the ingredients are fresh and plentiful. I love this place and it's a mom and pop shop!!!
David Y.• 06/29/24The best pepperoni pizza in Columbus.
Brady I.• 04/22/24This is hands down the best pizza in the state.
Lynn M.• 01/31/24The best subs; remind me of childhood
Teresa H.• 01/30/24This was our first time trying Bexley Pizza and it was delicious.
Ian J.• 01/13/24Consistently great tasting Za
Shirley K.• 10/05/23One of the best meatball subs in town.
Chris S.• 09/16/23toppings are loaded, delicious.
Jeffrey W.• 09/02/23Great Pizza
Bree A.• 08/23/23Just good pizza!
KENDALL F.• 06/24/23good tasting
Kerriann E.• 06/13/23Love their pizzas and their subs!!
Natasha E.• 05/21/23They always have the right amount of toppings and they are very fast. I recommend the Maximum Pepperoni pizza.
Dustin H.• 04/11/23shared this with CO workers. everyone said it was amazing. Definitely gained a lifetime customer.
Eric M.• 04/08/23Delicious
Freddy M.• 09/25/22Amazing …. The best pizza
brian C.• 09/05/22The pizza is really good and the delivery driver was very polite
Selina M.• 05/12/22Always yummy!!
Athena W.• 04/11/22The pizza was delicious!
Mary G.• 11/10/21Driver was nice and professional! Good was delicious!👍 Thanks!😁
Bryan M.• 10/06/21GREAT PIZZA!
Aaron K.• 08/22/21Great pizza
Korrie J.• 08/15/21Best best best
Can I order Bexley Pizza Plus delivery in Bexley with Uber Eats?
Yes. Bexley Pizza Plus delivery is available on Uber Eats in Bexley.
Is Bexley Pizza Plus delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Bexley Pizza Plus delivery is available to your location in Bexley.
How do I order Bexley Pizza Plus delivery online in Bexley?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Bexley Pizza Plus menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Bexley Pizza Plus online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Bexley Pizza Plus here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Bexley Pizza Plus order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Bexley Pizza Plus order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Bexley Pizza Plus delivery in Bexley?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Bexley Pizza Plus order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
What are some other stores nearby Bexley Pizza Plus?
Here are some stores near Bexley Pizza Plus:
Rally’s (3260 E. Broad Street)
White Castle (1025 Alum Creek Dr.)
Harvest Pizzeria (Bexley)
Donatos Pizza (Bexley)
Pizza Hut (3089 E Main St)
McDonald’s® (Livingston & James)
Subway (2181 E Livingston Ave)
Taco Bell (2111 E Livingston)
The Mad Greek
Peking Dynasty Express
