4.6
3000+ Ratings
Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy)
4.6 x (3,000+) • 2391.1 mi • Pizza • Italian • Group Friendly • $ • Info
14741 N Dale Mabry Hwy
Best NY Pizza is a highly-rated pizzeria in Tampa that serves both Neapolitan and deep-dish pizza made with local ingredients. It is an affordable restaurant that is most popular in the evening. The top ordered... More
Best NY Pizza is a highly-rated pizzeria in Tampa that serves both Neapolitan and deep-dish pizza made with local ingredients. It is an affordable restaurant that is most popular in the evening. The top ordered items include the 16" Large Cheese Pizza, 3 Meatball Garlic Knot Sliders, and Boneless Wings. Customers commonly order the 14" Medium Cheese Pizza and 16" Large Cheese Pizza together. Less
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"It was the closest and exactly the taste that I was looking what I’m used to from New York thank you so much for keeping the ingredients so fresh"
• Maria U. • 12/24/21
"I've eaten pizza around the globe and this is one of the BEST tasting and quality & quantity of products I've enjoyed. Keep up the great work."
• Fred A. • 06/28/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Featured items
Most Popular
- Buffalo Wings - ( 5 wings )$12.58 • 75% (116)Large Wings (5 piece). Bone in. Your choice hot, mild, BBQ sauce, Garlic Parmesan, or naked. ( mix of drums and wings, no substitutions )
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Cheese Pizza$21.78NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.comPopular - 18" FamilySize Cheese Pizza$22.93NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 14" Medium Cheese Pizza$18.96 • 92% (55)NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 2 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 10" Personal Cheese Pizza$14.36 • 94% (215)Good for 1 Person. Personal Size Cheese NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust. (Made for 1)
BestNYPizza.com - 12" Philly CheeseSteak Sub (SUB ONLY)$16.03 • 100% (4)HOT SUB - Thinly sliced Philly steak melted provolone and Grande Mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, and mushrooms. On a full size 12" Amoroso sub roll.
BestNYPizza.com - Cheese Calzone - Personal Size$15.51A Rich blend of Ricotta and Grande Mozzarella cheese wrapped in a pizza dough.
BestNYPizza.com - Meat Roll - Personal Size$17.18Stuffed with meat, ham, meatball, pepperoni, sausage, and melted grande mozzarella cheese.
BestNYPizza.com
Pizza
- 16" Large Cheese Pizza$21.78NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.comPopular - 18" FamilySize Cheese Pizza$22.93NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 10" Personal Cheese Pizza$14.36 • 94% (215)Good for 1 Person. Personal Size Cheese NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust. (Made for 1)
BestNYPizza.com - 14" Medium Cheese Pizza$18.96 • 92% (55)NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 2 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - Sicilian Pizza$30.98Square Thick Crust pizza made with double the cheese, double the sauce and double the dough of a regular pizza. 9 - Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com
16" Specialty Pizza
- 16" Large White Pizza$31.61 • 88% (96)Grande Mozzarella Cheese topped with dollops of Ricotta Cheese and Tuscan seasonings all on a Stone Fired Crust. (No Sauce).
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Meat Feast Pizza$35.58 • 93% (203)Five Savory Meats- Our Signature Pizza Sauce, Grande Mozzarella cheese, bacon, pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and ham on a Stone Fired crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Margherita Pizza$31.61 • 93% (108)Fresh Rustic Pizza- Sliced Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Mozzarella & Tuscan Seasoning with a Stone Fired Crust. (No Sauce)
8- Slices. Feeds 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large 4 Cheese Pizza$33.28 • 95% (199)A delicious rich blend of Cheddar, Provolone, Romano, and Grande Mozzarella Cheeses on top of our Signature Pizza Sauce and Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Veggie Pizza$35.58 • 87% (39)Five Fresh Veggies- Our Signature Pizza Sauce, Grande Mozzarella topped with tomato, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives on a Stone Fired Crust. 8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Chicken Parm Pizza$34.43 • 93% (43)Savory Chicken with breading and seasonings, Grande Mozzarella and Romano cheeses on top our Signature Sauce and a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com
Appetizers
Personal Specialty Pizzas
Calzones and Rolls
14" Specialty Pizza
Sicilian Specialty Pizza
18" Specialty Pizza
12" Hot Subs Meals
Dinner Entrees
Salads
Desserts
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•3000+ Ratings •
61 Reviews
Kevin M.• 05/03/24The best in town
Patricia O.• 04/19/24very good
Larry Y.• 04/04/24The pizza is delicious and true to NY, sausage was delicious too.
Karen C.• 03/30/24Great
michele C.• 03/10/24Pizza is always fresh and hot! Thank u!
Cheryl M.• 03/09/24The crust is my favorite part. Everything we ordered was good, but the crust was amazing.
Jesse J.• 03/04/24good
Kevin M.• 01/12/24Great food love this place
Bradley A.• 01/08/24Great
Barbie G.• 11/25/23SLIDERS WERE AMAZING!
Edward T.• 11/23/23Great pizza!
Chris R.• 11/16/23Garlic Knots were gooood.
Duane K.• 11/05/23Consistently great tasting pizza.
Kaitlin H.• 10/28/23Delicious. Worth extra money.
Kevin M.• 10/21/23Great pizza love it very much and thank you
Alain G.• 10/20/23Great pizza every time
Anita H.• 10/06/23I love the pizza, calzone, and salad!
Kevin M.• 10/06/23Love this pizza the best in town
Maria R.• 09/24/23Great taste
Alexandra H.• 09/21/23Delicious
Diane J.• 09/17/23A favorite local restaurant
Kelvin L.• 09/09/23One of the best pizza spots in Tampa
Jesus B.• 09/02/23nice under carrige
Matthew B.• 08/28/23the meatball sliders are amazing. their sauce is the best.
BRUNO R.• 08/19/23Buena pizza
Mishou S.• 08/18/23Best pizza in town
Kevin M.• 08/18/23Love this pizza - 4 Cheese is our favorite
Suzanne S.• 07/09/23Best pizza only place will eat
Karen S.• 07/02/23Great pizza
Fred A.• 06/28/23I've eaten pizza around the globe and this is one of the BEST tasting and quality & quantity of products I've enjoyed. Keep up the great work.
Cindy B.• 06/23/23great taste
Jonathan R.• 06/15/23It's as close to NY pizza as you can get in Florida. I've tried most of the others and these guys are the best I've had.
Roiniel S.• 06/10/23Delicioso
Todd S.• 06/04/23Pizza is perfect… every time
Nick G.• 06/03/23The Best!
Marcha B.• 05/26/23although pricey, always delicious fresh ingredients
MICHAEL M.• 05/26/23Delicious
Kevin M.• 05/20/23Love the 4 cheese it’s the best
Shannon W.• 04/24/23Great pizza and Calzone.
Chris M.• 04/10/23Delicious
Jesus B.• 03/25/23consistent
Kevin M.• 03/10/23Great pizza!!!! 4 cheese is amazing
GLORIA G.• 03/05/23Delicious ❣️
My I.• 02/28/23great taste
Kevin M.• 02/24/23Great tasting 4 cheese pizza
Kevin M.• 02/03/23Great tasting 4 cheese pizza.
Jesus B.• 01/30/23good
Jesus B.• 01/08/23good
Suzanne S.• 12/11/22Pizzas are so fresh. Love the crust too!
Letitia H.• 12/02/22fresh, good portion and tasty.
Michelle P.• 08/25/22Best pizza ever in the area!!
Lillian V.• 07/30/22Best pizza in town!!
Jamie C.• 05/05/22Yummy food at a fair price.
Anthony F.• 02/06/22Delicious pizza!
Maria U.• 12/24/21It was the closest and exactly the taste that I was looking what I’m used to from New York thank you so much for keeping the ingredients so fresh
Andre R.• 10/06/21Great and quick
Judith C.• 09/12/21We are New Yorkers and this is the only pizza we eat! It's the best.
Shirley G.• 08/09/21Excellently service quality food
Debbie C.• 07/28/21Best pizza and wings. Just wish the bag the food was in were closed.
Maria V.• 07/17/21Quick and delicious . Such a unique pizza!
Chris L.• 07/11/21very good!
Can I order Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) delivery in Tampa with Uber Eats?
Yes. Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) delivery is available on Uber Eats in Tampa.
Is Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) delivery is available to your location in Tampa.
How do I order Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) delivery online in Tampa?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) delivery in Tampa?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy) order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
